I Where are these neutrino masses coming from?

Click For Summary
The discussion centers on the origins of neutrino mass values, specifically questioning the sources of mass numbers for muon and tau neutrinos. It highlights that while the model suggests neutrino masses should be around 1 eV, current measurements indicate they are significantly lower, below 1 eV. The distinction between flavor states and mass eigenstates is emphasized, noting that flavor states do not possess definite masses. The quoted mass values are derived from kinematic limits based on specific particle reactions, such as the decay of pions. Overall, the conversation underscores the complexity of accurately determining neutrino masses and the limitations of current experimental data.
Turnernater
Messages
1
Reaction score
2
TL;DR
Is there a typo in the standard model of elementary particles?
Ever since High school I've seen this model of the "particle zoo," including in my recently finished particle physics undergrad course, and I can't seem to find where the mass numbers for the neutrino family is coming from!

Sure the model has a less than sign, but from what I understand all three should easily be around 1ish eV, and much less than MeV like in the picture. I've looked where Wikipedia was getting the data (the particle data group, Fermilab, PBS nova), and those sources also have something in the eV range.

Any idea where the masses for the muon neutrino and tau neutrino are coming from?
 

Attachments

  • particlezoo.PNG
    particlezoo.PNG
    66 KB · Views: 68
Physics news on Phys.org
The flavor states are not mass eigenstates. As such, they do not have definite masses.

That said, there are very stringent limits on all (light) neutrino mass eigenstates to be below 1 eV.
 
  • Like
Likes topsquark and Turnernater
As for the values quoted in the image, they are kinematics only limits from direct measurements of various reactions while effectively treating the neutrino involved as if it were a neutrino of a definitive mass. For example, the value quoted for the muon neutrino is based on measuring the muon momentum for the reaction ##\pi^+ \to \mu^+ + \nu_\mu## where the initial pion is at rest.

These limits are generally not competitive with other limits on neutrino masses. The possible exception being the beta decay experiments for ##\nu_e##.
 
Thread 'Some confusion with the Binding Energy graph of atoms'
My question is about the following graph: I keep on reading that fusing atoms up until Fe-56 doesn’t cost energy and only releases binding energy. However, I understood that fusing atoms also require energy to overcome the positive charges of the protons. Where does that energy go after fusion? Does it go into the mass of the newly fused atom, escape as heat or is the released binding energy shown in the graph actually the net energy after subtracting the required fusion energy? I...