Why does (dx₁)² equal zero in coordinate transformation with Jacobian 1?

2 replies · 2K views · last reply
xuphys
Messages
7
Reaction score
0
Hi,

When I do the following transformation:

$$
X_1=x_1+x_2 \\
X_2=x_2
$$

It turns out that the Jacobian ##\partial (X_1,X_2)/\partial (x_1,x_2)## is 1. But we have:

$$
dx_1dx_1+dx_1dx_2=d(x_1+x_2)dx_2=dX_1dX_2=|\partial (X_1,X_2)/\partial (x_1,x_2)|dx_1dx_2=dx_1dx_2
$$

So we have ##dx_1dx_1=0##. Is this kind of weird? Why does ##(dx_1)^2## have to be 0?

Thank you!
 
Last edited:
It represents the differential area for the parallelogram formed by varying by dx1 and then dx1. Since both sides are the same direction, the area is zero.

At a higher level the differentials are treated as Grassmann variables (like cross product but yielding tensor instead of vector). Then the Jacobian is built into the algebra.
 
Strictly speaking "[itex]dx_1dx_1[/itex]" has no meaning! How did it get in that problem?