On Wednesday, the editor, Scott Dodelson, sent me the following email, but the status page still says "with editor". Physics Letters B Title: The Universe Dear Mr. Todd, Thank you for your recent submission to Physics Letters B. However, before we can send your manuscript out for review, please note that we would like you to make the following changes/corrections: 1) Please upload the revised version 2) To make these amendments, please login to the Elsevier Editorial System as an author. After getting the email, I thought that the manuscript would be in review by now. If I'm wrong, the editor should now because the analysis is short and clear. However, if I'm right, then they should be doing something because the claims made in the paper are very significant.