Why is grasshopper more adapted to dry land than crayfish?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Knight226
  • Start date Start date
AI Thread Summary
Grasshoppers are better adapted to dry land than crayfish primarily due to their physiological features, such as spiracles for respiration and wings for mobility, while crayfish possess gills for aquatic respiration. The discussion highlights the need for a deeper understanding of the differences between these two arthropods, emphasizing that they belong to different classifications, with grasshoppers being insects and crayfish being crustaceans. Participants express frustration over the general information available and the complexity of biological concepts. The conversation suggests that understanding the adaptations related to their environments can clarify their evolutionary paths. Overall, the differences in respiratory systems and mobility are key factors in their adaptation to land versus water.
Knight226
Messages
15
Reaction score
0

Homework Statement


Why is grasshopper more adapted to dry land than crayfish?

Homework Equations


None.


The Attempt at a Solution


I tried to search up information about grasshopper and crayfish, but they are both very general information and not specific to the question that I have. I am assuming that it is because of the wings because crayfish does not have wings. Grasshopper does not have gill either instead grasshopper has spiracles. But regardless, I am unsure of my answers =/

Please help, thanks in advance.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
Honestly, can you not see any physiological differences beyond those that you have thrown out there? You don't seem to be trying too hard to answer this one by yourself. I will help, but ONLY after you make an effort.
 
What do you mean by physiological differences? Is it body changes?

I am not good with biology... :/ My textbook emphasizes on the circulatory system, but they are both open circulatory system. The sites that I look up they have very general information and they aren't helping much.

I guess you are right. I am not trying my best effort... the only thing I can pick up is the crayfish have gills/ grasshopper has spiracles and the wing difference. Sigh :/ I am really bad with biology...

Thank you anyways. I will search up more and see if I can find more information.
 
The question itself needs better development. They are both (crawfish and grasshopper) crustaceans. They evolved from some common specie, probably from some ancestor organism which lived in water (I am also bad at Biology).
 
symbolipoint said:
They are both (crawfish and grasshopper) crustaceans.

No, they are both arthropods.
 
symbolipoint said:
The question itself needs better development. They are both (crawfish and grasshopper) crustaceans. They evolved from some common specie, probably from some ancestor organism which lived in water (I am also bad at Biology).
No, the crawfish is a crustacean but the grasshopper is an insect. As Borek said, they are both arthropods (any invertebrate having an exoskeleton).
 
What other differences? Just look at a picture of each and note the differences.
 
Knight226 said:
crayfish have gills/ grasshopper has spiracles and the wing difference. Sigh :/ I am really bad with biology...
Those are the organs for so called external respiration, now to get that oxygen to where it's needed there hav to be differences in the blood to reflect functionally the different oxygen environments, maybe you could find out about that.
 
Knight: Is it possible you're overthinking the question?

There are some pretty major things that help grasshoppers live on land and crayfish live in water.
Gills, wings, swimming tail etc.
 
Back
Top