Why Is My Geography Professor Assigning Math Summation Problems?

  • Thread starter Thread starter axellerate
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Summation
Click For Summary

Homework Help Overview

The discussion revolves around a quiz assigned in a geography course that includes mathematical summation problems. The original poster expresses confusion regarding the relevance of these problems to their studies, particularly as they are not a math major.

Discussion Character

  • Mixed

Approaches and Questions Raised

  • Participants question the clarity and correctness of the summation problems presented, with some expressing difficulty in understanding the notation and variables used. Others emphasize the need for a clearer representation of the equations, suggesting the use of LaTeX for better readability.

Discussion Status

The conversation includes a mix of attempts to clarify the problems and critiques of the original post's mathematical expressions. Some participants are providing guidance on interpreting the summation notation, while others are debating the validity of the problems as presented.

Contextual Notes

There is mention of differing levels of familiarity with mathematical concepts among participants, with some asserting that the equations are standard while others find them confusing or poorly formulated. The original poster indicates that rounding is required for the answers, adding another layer of complexity to the discussion.

axellerate
Messages
4
Reaction score
0
Summation Problems! Please Help!

My geography prof assigned these... believe it or not. Its a quiz and its worth 5% of our mark.

1) Σi^4 = 1^xi Variables - n=4 x1=1 x2=6 x3=9 x4=17 (i think its 4)

2) (Σi^4=1^xi)^2 n=4 x1=3 x2=10 x3=9 x4=12 (i think this one is 4 also)

3) Σi^2= 1Σj^2 = 1^xij n=2 m=2 x11=2 x12=12 x21=4 x22=17 (i haven't the faintest idea...)

4) Σi^3= 1 xi/2 n=3 x1=3 x2=16 x3=6 (i think this one is 12.5)

5) Σi^n=1 xi/zi n=3 x1=14 x2=19 x3=16 z1=4 z2=9 z3=6
(i think the answer is apprx 8.28)


I have no idea why my geography teacher is giving us this quiz... i am not a math major. I have to round all answer to 2 decimal places if rounding is possible in the solution. I don't require the work as its an online quiz. But if u want to include it, all the better.

Thanks in advance.
 
Physics news on Phys.org


please use latex typeset to represent such equations. its a pain to read them or get what the question is.
 


Whether you are a math major or not, you should know enough arithmetic to at least understand what these are asking.
Σi^4 = 1^xi
This makes no sense. Σi^4 would mean (1)^4+ (2)^4+ (3)^4+ ... but where do you stop? "n= 4" makes no sense because you did not write an "n" in your formula. If you mean "i runs from 1 to 4" then it is (1)^4+ (2)^4+ (3)^4+ (4)^4, then you just need to do the multiplications and the final addition. It's just arithmetic.

I can make no sense out of 1^xi at all. 1 to any positive power is just 1.
 


HallsOfIvy,

My friend used my account to post this. I am currently a Medical Student, and I have never encountered the Summation (Σ) sign. Knowing arithmetic is one thing; but understanding what the equations mean is another. You must be taught what the variables / letters etc... mean. One cannot assume. The equations are written perfectly, and Σi^4 is a standardly used in summation problems. I suggest you do a little research before bashing one work. BTW: The n variable does stand for something. Why don't I let Mr.Arithmetic figure it out. I mean, you should know what it means... You should know enough arithmetic to understand the variables right?

Also, my buddy in forth year mech. engineering ended up solving each problem flawlessly with no issues.

The Guy that Doesn't understand arithmetic.

Axellerate
 


axellerate,
Notwithstanding that you are a medical student, or that your friend posted it, the problems in the first post make no sense. For example, in the first one, Σi^4 = 1^xi, I know what the summation on the left side means, but don't see how it could possibly be equal to what's on the right side. And what do the variables have to do with this?
 


axellerate said:
HallsOfIvy,

... I suggest you do a little research before bashing one work. BTW: The n variable does stand for something. Why don't I let Mr.Arithmetic figure it out. I mean, you should know what it means...
Axellerate

I suggest that you, Mr. math illiterate future MD, don't need to show up here and tell posters that have probably forgotten more mathematics than you ever knew, that they need to "do a little research" because they can't make sense of a nonsense post.
 


"The equations are written perfectly,"
Not in the first post - they are garbled to the point of being crap.

"Also, my buddy in forth year mech. engineering ended up solving each problem flawlessly with no issues."
I'd be amazed at that, but possible. Look at the way the problems he saw, and compare to what was posted here. How dissimilar in appearance are they?

"One cannot assume. The equations are written perfectly, and Σi^4 is a standardly used in summation problems. I suggest you do a little research before bashing one work. BTW: The n variable does stand for something. Why don't I let Mr.Arithmetic figure it out. I mean, you should know what it means... You should know enough arithmetic to understand the variables right?"

Neither HallsofIvy nor Mark44 made an assumption; both stated facts. You seem to be the one making the assumption: if you are unfamiliar with the mathematics, as you yourself claimed, it is not possible for you to know that that equations are correct. You also assumed that these two do not know what they are doing - another assumption, equally as false as the first.

I'll take you at your word that you are a medical student - and state given your apparent arrogant attitude, you are going to suck at being a doctor. Assumption or prophecy? I don't know.
 

Similar threads

  • · Replies 3 ·
Replies
3
Views
4K
Replies
6
Views
10K
  • · Replies 1 ·
Replies
1
Views
4K
  • · Replies 2 ·
Replies
2
Views
1K
  • · Replies 1 ·
Replies
1
Views
1K
  • · Replies 2 ·
Replies
2
Views
2K
  • · Replies 5 ·
Replies
5
Views
3K
  • · Replies 9 ·
Replies
9
Views
4K
  • · Replies 22 ·
Replies
22
Views
4K
  • · Replies 4 ·
Replies
4
Views
1K