Why is the new format necessary before differentiating?

1 reply · 1K views · last reply
PhysicsBoyMan
Messages
33
Reaction score
0

Homework Statement


http://postimage.org/]Printed calculus problem about a museum selling a painting and investing the proceeds at 5% compounded annually, with parts (a) to (c) asking about the formula for B(t), an equivalent form, and B'(10).[/PLAIN]
click image upload


Homework Equations


http://postimage.org/]Equation for B' = (1.05)^20 times the quotient [P'(t)(1.05)^t - P(t)(1.05)^t ln(1.05)] over ((1.05)^t)^2.[/PLAIN]
free image upload


The Attempt at a Solution


So I wanted to differentiate B(t) by saying

B(t) = P(t)(1.05)20-t ln(1.05)

Apparently this is the wrong answer.

I'm supposed to change my function B(t) into this new form. From there I understand how they differentiated using the quotient rule. I can even understand how they got the new B(t) formula by splitting (1.05)20 from (1.05)-t, then changing that to 1/(1.05)t and multiplying by P(t).
http://postimage.org/]Screen_Shot_2015_10_27_at_9_58_05_PM.png[/PLAIN]
image hosting sites


What I don't understand is why my original attempt is wrong. Why is the new format necessary before we differentiate? It is because I have a negative exponent? Is it because I have two exponents?

Thanks for the help
 
Last edited by a moderator:
PhysicsBoyMan said:

Homework Statement


Typed word problem about a museum selling a painting and investing the proceeds at 5% compounded annually, defining P(t) and B(t), with parts (a) to (c) asking for an explanation, an equivalent formula B(t) = (1.05)^20 P(t)/(1.05)^t, and B'(10) given P(10) = 150,000 and P'(10) = 5000.[/PLAIN]
click image upload


Homework Equations


Equation: B' = (1.05)^20 times [P'(t)(1.05)^t - P(t)(1.05)^t ln(1.05)] divided by ((1.05)^t)^2, a derivative written with a quotient-style fraction.[/PLAIN]
free image upload


The Attempt at a Solution


So I wanted to differentiate B(t) by saying

B(t) = P(t)(1.05)20-t ln(1.05)

Apparently this is the wrong answer.
B(t) is defined as a product, but it doesn't seem that you used the product rule.
PhysicsBoyMan said:
I'm supposed to change my function B(t) into this new form. From there I understand how they differentiated using the quotient rule. I can even understand how they got the new B(t) formula by splitting (1.05)20 from (1.05)-t, then changing that to 1/(1.05)t and multiplying by P(t).
Typeset algebra: If B(t) = P(t)(1.05)^(20−t), then B(t) = P(t)(1.05)^20(1.05)^(−t) = (1.05)^20 P(t)/(1.05)^t.[/PLAIN]
image hosting sites


What I don't understand is why my original attempt is wrong. Why is the new format necessary before we differentiate? It is because I have a negative exponent? Is it because I have two exponents?

Thanks for the help
 
Last edited by a moderator:
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: PhysicsBoyMan