Why moment at point C differs from book's answer at point D

6 replies · 2K views · last reply
werson tan
Messages
183
Reaction score
1

Homework Statement


for M2 , if i take the moment at pont C , then my ans would be (0.3i) x ((125X(3/5) j +125(4/5) k )= 30j +22.5k
Which is not same with the book which use moment about D . why ? Is the value at the triangle at te upper part incorrect (circle part) ?

Homework Equations

The Attempt at a Solution

 
Attachments
  • Textbook page showing Example 4-33 with three diagrams of a pipe column loaded by couples, and a solution with vector analysis writing M1 = 60i N·m, M2 = 22.5j + 30k N·m, and resultant M_R = 60i + 22.5j + 30k N·m.
    6.png
    66.1 KB · Views: 455
paisiello2 said:
Picture is too small to read.
 
Attachments
  • Photocopied textbook page, Example 4-3 on moment of a couple: three pipe-column diagrams (a), (b), (c) with forces and distances labeled, followed by the vector solution text and equations for M1 and M2.
    6.png
    58.9 KB · Views: 396
If you are taking moments about C then presumably you are considering the force at D. Isn't that in the direction -3/5j+4/5k? And should't the displacement vector be -3i?
 
haruspex said:
If you are taking moments about C then presumably you are considering the force at D. Isn't that in the direction -3/5j+4/5k? And should't the displacement vector be -3i?
Ya, I would ended up getting 22.5k +30j . But if I take moment about D , I would get 22.5j+30k... Is it correct?
 
werson tan said:
Ya, I would ended up getting 22.5k +30j . But if I take moment about D , I would get 22.5j+30k... Is it correct?
No, sorry, I had it wrong. The force at D is in the direction -4/5j+3/5k.