Will my PA66 (Nylon) beam plastic deform?

5 replies · 2K views · last reply
dsire4u
Messages
2
Reaction score
0
Hello,
I have this model that required to be pressed vertically 1mm.
I successfully displaced 1mm vertically with 30N of force.
Unluckily, Von mises stress goes way beyond the yield strength.
However, the strain is below the yield strain of 5%.
I do not understand how ductile/flexible material like Nylon will plastic deform with 30N of force applied.
Can someone explain to me if my model will plastic deform or not?
Please help,
Thank you
Included the x_b file of the part model.
3D CAD render of a solid part with a rectangular block base and a tall flat plate rising at an angle from one edge, with rounded top corners.
FEA displacement plot of a curved beam on two blocks, coloured from blue (0) to red (1.043e+000 mm) with a colour bar titled URES (mm); purple arrows show downward load and green markers show fixed supports.
Finite element stress plot of a curved beam on two blocks, coloured by von Mises stress in N/m^2 from 3.210e+05 to 3.019e+08, with a yield strength marker at 9.000e+07; arrows show downward load and green supports sit under the blocks.
FEA contour plot of a curved beam resting on two blocks, with magenta arrows pushing down and green supports at the base; colour map ESTRN ranges from 7.778e-005 (blue) to 4.675e-002 (red).
 
Attachments
Last edited:
Have you done any evaluation of your problem using the classical analysis methods?
 
JBA said:
Have you done any evaluation of your problem using the classical analysis methods?

I was not able to. I can only do evaluation of the straight beams...
 
your primary concern is the bending moment tensile stress at the base of the angle cantilevered section. For a start , resolve your force vector and treat the problem as a cantilever beam connected to the base.

FEA is subject to a number of issues in its modelling, so it is important that you understand the basic principle elements of the force vectors and stress analysis that apply to the problem you are analyzing in order to evaluate the accuracy or its solutions.
 
Two words.

Fillet radius.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: Bandit127
I am with Chris. Add fillet radii wherever possible but particularly around the high stress areas and re-analyse it. I would go for a radius of 25% of the wall section to start with.