Work Check - Centripetal force - Finding Tension in a Rope

Click For Summary

Homework Help Overview

The discussion revolves around a physics problem involving centripetal force and tension in a rope as a man swings from a vine. The scenario includes a mass of 85 kg, a vine length of 11 m, and a speed of 8 m/s at the bottom of the swing, with gravitational acceleration given as 10 m/s².

Discussion Character

  • Exploratory, Conceptual clarification, Mathematical reasoning, Assumption checking

Approaches and Questions Raised

  • Participants explore the relationship between centripetal force, tension, and gravitational force. Questions arise regarding the role of gravitational acceleration and how it interacts with tension in the vine. Some participants express confusion about the net force direction and its implications for the tension required to maintain the swing.

Discussion Status

The discussion is active, with participants providing hints and guidance on applying Newton's second law and considering all forces acting on the man. There is an ongoing exploration of how to correctly account for the forces involved, particularly the distinction between tension and weight.

Contextual Notes

Participants note the importance of correctly identifying the forces at play, including the tension in the vine and the weight of the man. There is a mention of potential confusion regarding the net force direction and its implications for the tension calculation.

Abood
Messages
14
Reaction score
3

Homework Statement


A man, with a mass of 85kg, swings from a vine with a length of 11m. If this speed at the bottom of the swing is 8m/s, what is the tension if g = 10m/s^2?
Given:
m (mass) = 85kg
r (radius) = 11m
V (speed) = 8m/s
g = 10m/s^2
T = ?

Homework Equations


Fc (centripetal force) = T (Tension)
F = ma (Newton's second law)
ac (centripetal acceleration) = v^2 / r
T = m*ac
w (angular velocity) = v/r

The Attempt at a Solution


Fc = T
Fc = ma
Fc = (m)(v^2/r)
Fc = (85)(8^2/11) = 494. 545 N
T = 494.545 N

I feel as though I am missing something really important but I don't know what. The g felt like it was just to throw me off. And some wording seems vague to me, like "at the bottom of the swing."
Would be nice if someone could check my work and if there are any issues, could tell me where they are.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
Abood said:
I feel as though I am missing something really important but I don't know what.
Yes, you missed something important.

Abood said:
The g felt like it was just to throw me off.
No, you'll need it. Hint: What forces act on the person? (Note that Newton's 2nd law applies to the net force.)
 
Doc Al said:
Yes, you missed something important.No, you'll need it. Hint: What forces act on the person? (Note that Newton's 2nd law applies to the net force.)
The 2 forces are gravity (weight) and the Normal force which acts as Tension here but I'm not sure how it should be used
 
Abood said:
The 2 forces are gravity (weight) and the Normal force which acts as Tension here but I'm not sure how it should be used
The two forces are the weight and the tension in the vine. (I would not use the term normal force for the tension.)

Since the acceleration is centripetal, apply Newton's 2nd law: ΣF = ma (But make sure you include both forces.)

(Note that it's the net force in the radial direction that provides the centripetal force.)
 
Doc Al said:
The two forces are the weight and the tension in the vine. (I would not use the term normal force for the tension.)

Since the acceleration is centripetal, apply Newton's 2nd law: ΣF = ma (But make sure you include both forces.)

(Note that it's the net force in the radial direction that provides the centripetal force.)
ac = 5.818 m/s^2
g = 10
Sum of a = 10 - 5.818 = 4.182 m/s^2 downwards
Net force = 85*4.182 = 355.47 N downwards
What confuses me is how the net force is downwards. Does that mean the weight is too much that the vine will snap?
 
Abood said:
ac = 5.818 m/s^2
g = 10
Sum of a = 10 - 5.818 = 4.182 m/s^2 downwards
Net force = 85*4.182 = 355.47 N downwards
What confuses me is how the net force is downwards. Does that mean the weight is too much that the vine will snap?
The net force is upwards! It has to be, since the net force is what produces the centripetal acceleration, which is upwards.

Think this way:
What forces act on the person? Weight (downwards) and Tension (upwards)
What is the acceleration? (v^2)/r (upwards -- toward the center of the path)

Choose a sign convention: Let up = positive.
Now apply Newton's 2nd law:
ΣF = ma
T - mg = ma

You do the rest and solve for the tension (T).
 
Doc Al said:
The net force is upwards! It has to be, since the net force is what produces the centripetal acceleration, which is upwards.

Think this way:
What forces act on the person? Weight (downwards) and Tension (upwards)
What is the acceleration? (v^2)/r (upwards -- toward the center of the path)

Choose a sign convention: Let up = positive.
Now apply Newton's 2nd law:
ΣF = ma
T - mg = ma

You do the rest and solve for the tension (T).
T = ma + mg = 80(5.818+10) = 1265.44 N
EDIT: I was wondering how come is Tension opposing the weight since the man is swinging and I didn't see anything say T was opposing W
 
Abood said:
T = ma + mg = 80(5.818+10) = 1265.44 N
(1) The mass is 85 kg, not 80.
(2) Round off to some reasonable number of digits.

Abood said:
EDIT: I was wondering how come is Tension opposing the weight since the man is swinging and I didn't see anything say T was opposing W
Ropes (or vines) can only pull. So the tension the vine exerts must be upwards (at the bottom of the swing).

Note that if the man were just hanging at the bottom with no velocity, the tension would just equal his weight. Since he's swinging, the tension must be greater than his weight in order to produce a centripetal acceleration.
 
Doc Al said:
(1) The mass is 85 kg, not 80.
(2) Round off to some reasonable number of digits.
Oh sorry, was just solving another problem with m = 80 kg.
T = 85(15.818) = 1344.53 = 1345 N
Doc Al said:
Ropes (or vines) can only pull. So the tension the vine exerts must be upwards (at the bottom of the swing).

Note that if the man were just hanging at the bottom with no velocity, the tension would just equal his weight. Since he's swinging, the tension must be greater than his weight in order to produce a centripetal acceleration.
Ok, now I get it!
Thank you very much for your help! It is very appreciated that you spared some time to check my work.
 

Similar threads

  • · Replies 4 ·
Replies
4
Views
1K
  • · Replies 11 ·
Replies
11
Views
5K
  • · Replies 5 ·
Replies
5
Views
4K
Replies
8
Views
2K
  • · Replies 9 ·
Replies
9
Views
5K
  • · Replies 5 ·
Replies
5
Views
2K
  • · Replies 5 ·
Replies
5
Views
2K
  • · Replies 2 ·
Replies
2
Views
3K
  • · Replies 17 ·
Replies
17
Views
2K
  • · Replies 7 ·
Replies
7
Views
5K