View Single Post
Q-reeus
Q-reeus is offline
#179
Oct30-11, 09:03 AM
P: 1,115
Quote Quote by PeterDonis View Post
A better analogy for that would be to consider a surface like the Flamm paraboloid...
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Fl...paraboloid.svg
Handy reminder; while I think DrGreg had posted on it much earlier, upon finding the original article at http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Flamm%2...27s_paraboloid , studied that piece with some more attention. Had never bothered to understand the significance of the w ordinate, but now appreciate how it gives a useful handle on visualising spatial part of SM. 'Inverting' w ordinate gives the sense of radial contraction as I had envisaged. Matching that to shell transition is the interesting exercise. Brings it back to on topic, and having come to appreciate the general view of the difficulties of applying a simple reading of SC's, conclude the original posting was an inappropriate vehicle for finding problems with SM. Thanks for all the inputs.