Thread Closed

No need for "dark energy", gravity will suffice.

 
Share Thread Thread Tools
Jun19-09, 09:58 AM   #86
 
Recognitions:
Science Advisor Science Advisor

No need for "dark energy", gravity will suffice.


Quote by Hal King View Post
Actually, all you can say for any model is whether it matches data or not. The importance of an 'accepted' model is that it determines what will be used for further work ... grants, money, careers, promotions, etc. So if you are 'in the business' you have to use the accepted approaches.
Again, this is unfounded non-sense. A plurality of approaches are being pursued and jobs, grants and funding are flowing to all kinds of ideas. I have no idea how you think the system works, but it's nothing like you are suggesting. If anything, it remains easier to get funding for claiming you will pursue some great new idea. Re-iterating the status quo is boring, it doesn't excite the researchers in the field or funding agencies. That being said, even the 'standard' model is such a bare boned sketch at present that there are plenty of interesting things still to be worked out within the context of the 'standard' approach. This is also a very active research area, since it is only by working out the details that we will be able to see if the model eventually stands up to scrutiny or whether significant problems are revealed.

You can rant all you like, but the fact is that well posed alternative explanations get a fair hearing. The whole dark energy idea was once 'alternative', as were other elements you could now call 'standard'. If an alternative theory works it will become the standard. Nobody has any interest or anything to gain by preventing that.
Thread Closed
Thread Tools


Similar Threads for: No need for "dark energy", gravity will suffice.
Thread Forum Replies
Question about the "coincidence" of the "dark side of the moon" General Physics 10
Wiltshire casts doubt on existence of "dark energy" Beyond the Standard Model 1
"Dark Energy Telescope" gets the go-ahead from NASA Cosmology 0
Relativity and the "Dark Energy" question Special & General Relativity 5
"Dark Matter And Dark Energy May Be Different Aspects Of A Single Unknown Force" General Physics 0