Register to reply

Some questions about galaxys

by demoremda
Tags: galaxys, solved
Share this thread:
demoremda
#1
Jun21-03, 01:14 PM
P: n/a
Hi guys this is my first message

Can we assume that every spiral galaxy has a massive black hole at the center?

And why dont elliptical galaxys evolve like the spirals?

Has anyone wondered were all the energy goes that gets sucked in to a black hole?

Phys.Org News Partner Astronomy news on Phys.org
Young binary star system may form planets with weird and wild orbits
Evidence of a local hot bubble carved by a supernova
Astronomers measure weight of galaxies, expansion of universe
marcus
#2
Jun21-03, 01:35 PM
Astronomy
Sci Advisor
PF Gold
marcus's Avatar
P: 23,117
Originally posted by demoremda
Hi guys this is my first message ...

And why dont elliptical galaxys evolve like the spirals?

Hopefully several other people will reply----several parts of question.

About ellipticals, the last explanation I heard is that ellipticals are formed by the collision and merger of two or more other galaxies (which may e.g. have originally been spirals)
and an elliptical can have more than one massive black hole
in its central region.
meteor
#3
Jun21-03, 01:42 PM
P: 915
Can we assume that every spiral galaxy has a massive black hole at the center?
It's the more probable.There's a theory that says that all the AGN (Seyfert galaxies, quasars, BL Lac objects,...) are only galaxies where the central black hole is eating big quantities of material, and then shine so brightly because that material is accelerating and
giving radiation
And why dont elliptical galaxys evolve like the spirals?
All depends how the cloud that gives rise to the galaxy rotates. If the cloud rotates rapidly, becomes a spiral galaxy, and if rotates slowly, an elliptic galaxy
Has anyone wondered were all the energy goes that gets sucked in to a black hole?
I think that remains inside the black hole. Others would say that travels through a wormhole and go out from a white hole, but it's more sci-fi than pure science

demoremda
#4
Jun28-03, 10:05 PM
P: n/a
Some questions about galaxys

[QUOTE]Originally posted by meteor
All depends how the cloud that gives rise to the galaxy rotates. If the cloud rotates rapidly, becomes a spiral galaxy, and if rotates slowly, an elliptic galaxy

So your saying its a matter of mass? is it possible elliptic galaxys dont have massive black holes in the middle and if so why dont they form, the density seems about equal altough im no expert
demoremda
#5
Jun28-03, 10:09 PM
P: n/a
Originally posted by meteor
[
I think that remains inside the black hole. Others would say that travels through a wormhole and go out from a white hole, but it's more sci-fi than pure science [/B]

well for me black holes come pretty close to sci-fi and i know everything we dont understand is scifi or not possible, maybe an idea is that this is the krib of a new universe, it s a lot of energy thats been sucked in

im not educated on a high lvl in this but i like to think about it, thanx for the replies
meteor
#6
Jun29-03, 10:49 AM
P: 915
So your saying its a matter of mass? is it possible elliptic galaxys dont have massive black holes in the middle and if so why dont they form, the density seems about equal altough im no expert
No, not mass,I'm speaking about velocity of rotation. All the non-compact bodies that spin tend to have a flatlike form (for example, the sun that spin over itself, has more diameter in the equator than from pole to pole)Greater the velocity of spin, greater the flatlike form
Black Holes exists in the middle of elliptic galaxies too.The famous galaxy M87, that lies inside the Virgo Cluster, is elliptic, and has a BH of 3.000.000.000 Solar masses. It's the more massive black hole known.In comparation, Sagittarius A, the Black Hole of the center of the Milky Way, has a mass of only 3 million solar masses
well for me black holes come pretty close to sci-fi and i know everything we dont understand is scifi or not possible, maybe an idea is that this is the krib of a new universe, it s a lot of energy thats been sucked in
Interesting idea! Lee Smolin, in his book The life of the Cosmos has proposed the idea of the evolutionary universe. He says that every time that a black hole is created, gives rise to a new Universe. Then if you fall inside that black hole, you will go to that universe, that can has black holes that if collapses creates another universe..., and so on.
Tail
#7
Jun29-03, 10:54 AM
P: 197
Energy is mass. There's no real difference between them, so there's no problem as regards energy and black holes.
Andy
#8
Jun29-03, 03:27 PM
P: 255
I am sure i watched a programme on BBC a couple of years back that said that they think that most Galaxies do have a Black hole at the centre and that includes are own galaxy, not 100% sure about this though, certainly aint no expert.
Tail
#9
Jun29-03, 04:30 PM
P: 197
Yeah, that's right (to my knowledge). Many galaxies, including our own, have a massive black hole at the centre (and possibly smaller black holes, too).
Phobos
#10
Jun30-03, 01:17 PM
Emeritus
Sci Advisor
PF Gold
P: 2,020
Originally posted by demoremda
Hi guys this is my first message
WELCOME!

Can we assume that every spiral galaxy has a massive black hole at the center?
That seems to the be the trend in the new data. It's still a relatively new discovery though so there is still a lot more research to be done.

And why dont elliptical galaxys evolve like the spirals?
Galaxy formation is also an area of much research.
I've only skimmed the intro, but this seems to be an interesting scientific (very technical) paper on the subject...
http://ned.ipac.caltech.edu/level5/F..._contents.html

Has anyone wondered were all the energy goes that gets sucked in to a black hole?
Yep, many people have. My hunch is that it stays there.


Register to reply

Related Discussions
Some Questions Introductory Physics Homework 2
Two objects are dropped from a bridge Introductory Physics Homework 4
Have a few questions, can you look them over? Calculus 0
The Center of Galaxys Astronomy & Astrophysics 16