raman spectroscopy question


by n0_3sc
Tags: raman, spectroscopy
n0_3sc
n0_3sc is offline
#1
Jun29-08, 11:44 PM
P: 265
I read in a journal article that in raman spectroscopy "it is well
known that signal yield increases with shorter wavelength". Can anyone please explain why? I would've thought longer wavelengths = shorter frequencies = higher susceptibilities?
Phys.Org News Partner Physics news on Phys.org
Researchers develop scalable methods for manufacturing metamaterials
Researchers find tin selenide shows promise for efficiently converting waste heat into electrical energy
After 13 years, progress in pitch-drop experiment (w/ video)
n0_3sc
n0_3sc is offline
#2
Aug28-08, 08:36 PM
P: 265
Sorry to bring this post up again, but I found the answer to my question if anyone is interested:
Turns out the Raman process does NOT depend much on wavelength. It is the detection of the CCD's that have the highest quantum efficiencies in the visible.

Between 600nm and 1000nm there is a 60% difference in detection efficiency.
evidenso
evidenso is offline
#3
Oct12-08, 04:32 AM
P: 37
Quote Quote by n0_3sc View Post
Sorry to bring this post up again, but I found the answer to my question if anyone is interested:
Turns out the Raman process does NOT depend much on wavelength. It is the detection of the CCD's that have the highest quantum efficiencies in the visible.

Between 600nm and 1000nm there is a 60% difference in detection efficiency.
well the Raman process DO depent much on wavelengt (to the fourth power). And it's well understood.
The fourth power can appear through a lengthy derivation using timedependent pertubation theory, second quantization of E-field and derivation of interaction between charges and E-field. You don't wanner mess with this.....

n0_3sc
n0_3sc is offline
#4
Oct12-08, 03:33 PM
P: 265

raman spectroscopy question


Quote Quote by evidenso View Post
well the Raman process DO depent much on wavelengt (to the fourth power). And it's well understood.
The fourth power can appear through a lengthy derivation using timedependent pertubation theory, second quantization of E-field and derivation of interaction between charges and E-field. You don't wanner mess with this.....
Rayleigh Scattering depends on wavelength to the fourth power not Raman Scattering.
evidenso
evidenso is offline
#5
Oct12-08, 04:23 PM
P: 37
Quote Quote by n0_3sc View Post
Rayleigh Scattering depends on wavelength to the fourth power not Raman Scattering.
Sorry to disapoint ya.
Raman intensity DO varies with the fourth power of the observed frequency for normal Raman scattering, which, in turn, depends on laser frequency.
It can be derived from the classical treatment of scattering from an oscillating induced dipole, with the intensity expressed in watts.

Therefore, in biological Raman scattering one has to find a compromise between reduced fluorescence and reduced Raman signal by choosing bigger wavelength to obtain signals.

In the full quantum picture it appears when you combine final density of states, laser intensity and scattered intensity with the Kramer Heisenberg equation

You should note that modern Raman spectrometers,
which usually measure photons/seconds rather than watts, are governed by a
slightly different frequency dependence.
n0_3sc
n0_3sc is offline
#6
Oct12-08, 05:38 PM
P: 265
I'm now confused :(

Do you have any material I can refer too? In all the theory I've gone through I don't see any fourth power dependence. (haven't done QM though)

Is it:
Raman intensity varies with fourth power wavelength or,
Raman intensity varies with fourth power frequency?

Why are modern spectrometers different?
evidenso
evidenso is offline
#7
Oct13-08, 06:49 AM
P: 37
Quote Quote by n0_3sc View Post
I'm now confused :(

Do you have any material I can refer too? In all the theory I've gone through I don't see any fourth power dependence. (haven't done QM though)
This is a basic non QM practical guide
"Raman Spectroscopy in Chemical Analysis wiley 2000"

Quote Quote by n0_3sc View Post
Is it:
Raman intensity varies with fourth power wavelength or,
Raman intensity varies with fourth power frequency?
Raman intensity varies with fourth power of frequency
and you know that [tex]c=\lambda*frequency[/tex]

Quote Quote by n0_3sc View Post
Why are modern spectrometers different?
This is explained in "Raman Spectroscopy in Chemical Analysis wiley 2000"
It's because there is a factor [tex]E=hv[/tex] in difference between watts and photon/sec
omg!
omg! is offline
#8
Aug21-10, 10:00 AM
P: 52
hi, can you point me to a reference for the quantized field treatment? googling didn't help much, seems this is really a topic that not many are willing to touch.
thx in advance
alxm
alxm is offline
#9
Aug21-10, 10:16 AM
Sci Advisor
P: 1,867
"Atom-photon interactions" by Cohen-Tannodji for instance?


Register to reply

Related Discussions
Another Raman spectrum question! Atomic, Solid State, Comp. Physics 19
Raman Microscopy - simple question Chemistry 4
Spectroscopy question Quantum Physics 1
Raman and IR spectroscopy Advanced Physics Homework 1
raman spectroscopy!!! Atomic, Solid State, Comp. Physics 7