Register to reply 
Resistance for a sphere in a half sphere containing liquid 
Share this thread: 
#1
Feb1609, 02:50 PM

P: 1,031

1. The problem statement, all variables and given/known data
A small copper sphere of radius a is half immersed at the surface of a poorly conducting liquid of resistivity [tex] \rho [/tex]. The liquid is contained in a spherical copper bath of radius b, where b>>a and where the bath is concentric with the sphere. Estimate the electrical resistance between the sphere and the walls of the bath, assuming that the copper can be assumed to be a perfect electrical conductor 2. Relevant equations [tex] R = \rho \frac{A}{l} [/tex] 3. The attempt at a solution See I think I need to use the resistivity equation I have above, however, this is only for a wire. Is there a version for situations such as these? TFM 


#2
Feb1609, 03:25 PM

P: 183

It seems to me that you've sort of got a wire here, it's just that its crosssectional area changes and it's got a weird shape. If b>>a, then doesn't that really mean that the liquid is shaped like a hemisphere? If so, then I think you can just integrate [tex]\rho dA / l [/tex]



#3
Feb1609, 03:37 PM

P: 1,031

That makes sense. So:
[tex] R v= \rho \frac{dA}{l} [/tex] But what would the limits be? Would it be from 0 to Circle(r=a)  Circle (r=a) 


#4
Feb1609, 09:23 PM

P: 183

Resistance for a sphere in a half sphere containing liquid
I agree with zero as the lower limit, this would be the bottom of the pool. The disk's radius at the top would just be b; I think the problem is implying the sphere is small enough to be treated like a point. Dig out the Calculus textbook and you ought to be able to find an example like this one where you're integrating by adding a bunch of disks together.



#5
Feb1709, 05:57 AM

P: 1,031

Could we use spherical polar coordinates, do it for a whole sphere, and then half the value?



#6
Feb1709, 07:00 AM

P: 181

R = rho *L/A 


#7
Feb1709, 07:20 AM

P: 181

R is the integral from a to b of (rho/ 2*pi*r^2)dr
Don't understand the relevance of b>>a though, except that you could make b infinity. 


#8
Feb1709, 04:15 PM

P: 1,031

So I dion't need to use:
[tex] R = \rho \frac{l}{A} [/tex] Expressed in Spherical polar coordinates? 


#9
Feb1709, 08:43 PM

P: 181




#10
Feb1809, 10:33 AM

P: 1,031

Okay, so What should I do for the length part?



#11
Feb1809, 01:12 PM

P: 272

Surely the length is just the difference between the radii?



#12
Feb1809, 01:42 PM

P: 1,031

Okay, so:
[tex] R = \rho \frac{ba}{2\pi r^2}dr [/tex] Does this look okay? 


#13
Feb1809, 02:33 PM

P: 272

Edit 2: Now I feel really stupid. The equation won't work because for a start you would get a negative resistance. I am going to go away now to be alone with my shame. Sorry for not being much use. 


#14
Feb1809, 02:36 PM

P: 1,031

Okay, so it should be:
[tex] R = \rho \frac{ba}{2\pi r dr} [/tex] ? 


#15
Feb1909, 09:20 AM

P: 272

Okay here is what I think is going on. You have a formula for the resistance, but this depends upon the path length and the crosssectional area. In this problem neither of those things are constant. You have to consider an infinitesimal path length and area. If we switch to sperical polars you can see that the only factor changing the surface area is r (theta and phi are the same for whatever hemisphere you choose). I think the expression should look something like this,
[tex]\int{RdA}=\int{\rho*dl}[/tex] Although if I am wrong please could someone correct me? 


#16
Feb1909, 02:44 PM

P: 80

L(or l) should be along the path that the electricity will flow. We need to break this up into infinitesimally thin sheets of thickness dr (the L) with changing area. Thus, you get [tex]R=\int_{a}^{b} \frac{\rho dr}{A}[/tex] where A (the area a hemisphere of radius r) is a function of r and thus you can integrate.



#17
Feb1909, 02:52 PM

P: 1,031

Okay, so:
[tex] R=\int_{a}^{b} \frac{\rho dr}{A} [/tex] We also know the area of a hemisphere is: [tex] 2\pi r^2 [/tex] Thus giving: [tex] R=\int_{a}^{b} \frac{\rho dr}{2\pi r^2} [/tex] So now would I have to integrate this? 


#18
Feb2009, 12:13 AM

P: 181

We are making a pig's ear of solving this.
The current I flows radially. dV/dr =  resistivity * current per unit area = rho * I/(2*pi*r^2) Integrate from a to b to find V. R = V/I 


Register to reply 
Related Discussions  
Surface integral of half sphere  Calculus & Beyond Homework  2  
Volume of liquid in a partially filled sphere  General Math  23  
Rotate point on sphere to exactly 'cut sphere in half'  Differential Geometry  11  
Half a sphere  Advanced Physics Homework  2  
Average Volume of Half a Sphere  Introductory Physics Homework  1 