image
Physics Forums Logo
image
image
* Register * Upgrade Blogs Library Staff Rules Mark Forums Read
image
image   image
image

Go Back   Physics Forums > Mathematics > General Math


Reply

image Need Advice on CAS Share It Thread Tools Search this Thread image
Old Aug4-04, 02:06 AM                  #1
agro

agro is Offline:
Posts: 42
Need Advice on CAS

I'm planning to learn a CAS. Can you guys give me advice on what I should choose (Mathematica, Maple, Derive, Matlab, or maybe others)?

Thanks a lot.
  Reply With Quote
Old Aug6-04, 05:47 AM                  #2
Erienion

Erienion is Offline:
Posts: 28
What do you want to do with this knowledge you plan to learn? Calculus? Stats? Linear Algebra?
  Reply With Quote
Old Aug12-04, 04:25 AM                  #3
agro

agro is Offline:
Posts: 42
In the short term, calculus...
  Reply With Quote
Old Aug12-04, 12:40 PM       Last edited by graphic7; Aug12-04 at 02:01 PM..            #4
graphic7

graphic7 is Offline:
Posts: 548
Recognitions:
PF Contributor PF Contributor
You don't need a CAS for calculus. A scientific calculator will do fine, however, if you want to learn a CAS in general, I'd pick Maple.

Maple releases all their algorithms to the general public, but Mathematica does not.

If the symbolic functions aren't essential, I'll suggest a few open-source altenatives: octave and scilab. Both, octave and scilab, use Matlab-like syntax. Octave and scilab are more for doing numerical tasks, rather than evaluating an integral symbolically.

octave and scilab are great for doing linear algebra tasks: eigenvalues, matrice operations, and such. I've solved a few ODE's and PDE's numerically on them for fun. octave is a rather modular application. It supports writing programs or "external" functions in Java, C, and C++, in addition to its on C-like language. Octave is totally GPL'd, whereas scilab is nondistributable but open-source (?).

scilab and octave support graphing, also. Octave interfaces with an application called "gnuplot", which supports all the methods of graphing that the propiertary CAS's (Mathematica, Maple, etc.) support. I'm not as familiar with scilab but it uses something *very* similiar to gnuplot. I actually like the plotting features of scilab slightly better than those of gnuplot. Scilab supports real-time rotations and zooming, whereas gnuplot does not. Mathematica doesn't either.

Learning how to use the computer for numerical calculations is all what the computer is about; I find the CAS to be pointless.
  Reply With Quote
image image
Reply
Thread Tools


Similar Threads for: Need Advice on CAS
Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post
Some advice please...? bit188 Calculus & Analysis 7 Jun16-07 04:28 PM
Course Advice David_Harkin Academic Guidance 0 Mar28-07 05:01 PM
Got the co-op with IBM! thanks for the advice all mr_coffee Academic Guidance 3 Mar14-07 09:27 PM
A little advice Yowhatsupt Academic Guidance 6 Jan18-07 10:06 PM

Powered by vBulletin Copyright ©2000 - 2010, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd. © 2010 Physics Forums
Sciam | physorgPhysorg.com Science News Partner
image
image   image