Register to reply

Doppler shift of a signal reflected in a mirror moving away from the observer.

Share this thread:
yuiop
#1
Mar15-12, 09:51 PM
P: 3,967
I have re-written this as as I accidently deleted my original post. I was wondering if the relativistic Doppler shift of a reflection from a mirror moving away from the observer was the same as the Newtonian equation in the special case that the mirror is orthogonal to the direction of motion.

I referred to equation (13) in this paper http://arxiv.org/ftp/physics/papers/0409/0409014.pdf and set theta to zero for this special case.

I now think I have figured out the answer to my own question.

The equation I gave in my my first post:

[tex] f = f_0 \frac{1-2v/c+v^2/c^2}{1-v^2/c^2} [/tex]

Can be re-arranged:

[tex] f = f_0 \frac{(1-v/c)(1-v/c)}{(1-v/c)(1+v/c)} [/tex]

and simplified:

[tex] f = f_0 \frac{(1-v/c)}{(1+v/c)} [/tex]

and this is exactly the same as the none relativistic equation for Doppler radar.

Length contraction and time dilation is not involved in this special case of reflection in a moving mirror.
Phys.Org News Partner Science news on Phys.org
What lit up the universe?
Sheepdogs use just two simple rules to round up large herds of sheep
Animals first flex their muscles
clamtrox
#2
Mar16-12, 04:15 AM
P: 939
Yes, this is kind of a trivial result though. You can just move to the coordinates of the mirror and argue that because of symmetries (light beam coming in 90 degrees wrt the mirror), outgoing angle must be same as incoming angle.
yuiop
#3
Mar16-12, 10:39 AM
P: 3,967
Quote Quote by clamtrox View Post
Yes, this is kind of a trivial result though. You can just move to the coordinates of the mirror and argue that because of symmetries (light beam coming in 90 degrees wrt the mirror), outgoing angle must be same as incoming angle.
The question was not about angles but about red shift of a reflected signal. I chose the 90 degree angle wrt the mirror to eliminate complications due to relativistic aberration. I was inspired to ask the question because in another thread there was originally some doubt about whether time dilation or red shift are factors in the signal reflected from a mirror moving parallel to the observer. I am now fairly sure that they are not factors in that scenario.

clamtrox
#4
Mar17-12, 03:20 PM
P: 939
Doppler shift of a signal reflected in a mirror moving away from the observer.

Quote Quote by yuiop View Post
The question was not about angles but about red shift of a reflected signal. I chose the 90 degree angle wrt the mirror to eliminate complications due to relativistic aberration. I was inspired to ask the question because in another thread there was originally some doubt about whether time dilation or red shift are factors in the signal reflected from a mirror moving parallel to the observer. I am now fairly sure that they are not factors in that scenario.
So more explicitly (if you want to think in terms of length contractions), you get a relativistic correction because the Lorentz transform from mirror coordinates to observer coordinates changes the angle of the mirror. If the mirror is perpendicular to the beam, you can just trivially transform to mirror coordinates and you have a moving observer observing a beam (bouncing off a stationary mirror, but you know what happens there already).
yuiop
#5
Mar17-12, 04:03 PM
P: 3,967
Quote Quote by clamtrox View Post
So more explicitly (if you want to think in terms of length contractions), you get a relativistic correction because the Lorentz transform from mirror coordinates to observer coordinates changes the angle of the mirror. If the mirror is perpendicular to the beam, you can just trivially transform to mirror coordinates and you have a moving observer observing a beam (bouncing off a stationary mirror, but you know what happens there already).
Thanks, yes it helpful to think of it in that context.


Register to reply

Related Discussions
Phase shift of reflected light wave Classical Physics 2
Doppler Effect, Stationary source moving observer Introductory Physics Homework 0
Doppler Effect: Moving Observer riding on moving source! With reflection off wall! Introductory Physics Homework 3
Relativity - Doppler effect in reflection from a moving mirror Advanced Physics Homework 0
Could moving observer be stationary vs moving and still give Albert the same results Special & General Relativity 17