image
Physics Forums Logo
image
image
* Register * Upgrade Blogs Library Staff Rules Mark Forums Read
image
image   image
image

image done Share It Thread Tools Search this Thread image
Old Oct3-05, 05:50 PM       Last edited by Pearce_09; Oct3-05 at 08:27 PM..            #1
Pearce_09

Pearce_09 is Offline:
Posts: 74
done

Hi there,
I am have trouble with a proof. I have some steps done, but I am not sure if I am aproaching this correctly.
the question is:

Show that the matrix of any reflection in R^n is a symmetric matrix.

I know that F(x) = Ax + b is an isometry
where A is an Orthoganol matrix , and vector b is in R^n
this implies that A^t A = I (identity matrix) iff A^-1 = A^t

and if f is a reflection then f(f(x)) = x
then f(f(x)) = A(Ax + b) + b = x
_________
i need to somehow prove that A = A^t which then means the matrix is symmetric

thank you for you time and help
regards,
adam
  Reply With Quote
Old Oct3-05, 06:25 PM                  #2
AKG

AKG is Offline:
Posts: 2,529
Recognitions:
Homework Helper Homework Helper
Science Advisor Science Advisor
Not every reflection in Rn can be represented by a matrix. Now, do you mean that (1) every reflection in an n-1 dimensional hyperplane passing through the origin in Rn is a symmetric matrix, or do you mean (2) the matrix part of every reflection in Rn is symmetric? If f is a reflection in an n-1 dimensional hyperplane L, then f(x) = Ax + b, where A is the matrix corresponding to a reflection in the n-1 dimensional hyperplane passing through the origin, parallel to the hyperplane L, and if d is the shortest vector from 0 to L, then b = 2d. You know that A is orthogonal, so you know that A-1 = AT. It remains to show that A-1 = A. But this is true since:

A(Ax + b) + b = x
A²x + Ab + b = x
(A² - I)x = -(Ab + b)

Now you could use the fact that Ab = -b, so the right side is:

-(Ab + b) = -(-b + b) = -0 = 0

for all x, hence A² - I = 0, hence A² = I, and thus A = A-1. But suppose you didn't know what Ab was. Regardless, you still know that the right side is:

-(Ab + b) for all x

but this is a constant, so you have (A² - I)x = y, where y is a constant vector, and this is true for all x. If you plug in x = 0, then you get 0 = y. In other words, the only linear function that is constant is the 0 function. So without knowing explicitly what Ab is, you can deduce still that the right side must be 0 (and so, if you wanted, could then deduce that Ab = -b), and since the right side is 0 for all x, A² - I = 0, and the desired result follows.
  Reply With Quote
Old Oct3-05, 06:33 PM                  #3
Pearce_09

Pearce_09 is Offline:
Posts: 74
Oh wow, that really clears things up. thank you very much akg..
  Reply With Quote
image image
Reply
Thread Tools


Similar Threads for: Geometry help
Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post
not sure if this is geometry e-realmz General Math 2 Jan26-06 05:28 AM
Differential Geometry And Difference Geometry? adityatatu Topology & Geometry 1 Oct31-04 01:07 PM
A little geometry juef Introductory Physics 8 Sep15-04 12:02 PM
geometry Speculatrix General Astronomy 2 Nov28-03 10:34 PM
Spherical Geometry and Flat Geometry Space-Spacetime's ranyart Special & General Relativity 0 Nov10-03 06:21 PM

Powered by vBulletin Copyright ©2000 - 2009, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd. © 2009 Physics Forums
Sciam | physorgPhysorg.com Science News Partner
image
image   image