Thread Closed

Error in measuring rock porosity by Archimedes method

 
Share Thread
Oct7-05, 04:09 PM   #1
 
Question

Error in measuring rock porosity by Archimedes method


The standard way to measure porosity of a rock is to get the pores completely saturated with water, then weigh the rock immersed in water and again in air (there are modified balances for this). Using Archimedes' principle, you then can determine the volume of the rock. Then you dry the rock completely and weigh it again (only in air). The water weight lost gives you the pore space in the rock. Divide this into the total volume and you get the porosity.

A major source of error is that when you weigh the rock after taking it out iof the water you have to blot the outside surface dry. Not dry enough and you are weighing some exterior water. Too dry and you will suck some of the water out of the pores and the rock is no longer saturated.

What I am looking for is a textbook or other publication that tells the amount of error to be expected from this source. Anyone with information or experience with this method is welcome to reply.
PhysOrg.com earth sciences news on PhysOrg.com

>> Scientists: Soggy British weather likely to stay
>> Seismic gap outside of Istanbul: Is this where the expected Marmara earthquake will originate from?
>> Meteorologists meet to mull weird British weather (Update)
Oct9-05, 10:11 AM   #2
 
The standard way? What ever happened to mercury porosimeters?
Thread Closed

Similar discussions for: Error in measuring rock porosity by Archimedes method
Thread Forum Replies
Fortra 90 : Error in my program of bisection method Programming & Comp Sci 4
solve 4th order trial n error method Differential Equations 3
Apostol: Archimedes' Method Calculus & Beyond Homework 2
Euler's method error Calculus 1
Measuring Time: A Revolutionary Method General Physics 26