Recent content by Avodyne

  1. A

    I MWI -- Infinite number of worlds?

    You are confusing nonlinearities in the field equations of quantum field theory with nonlinearities in the time evolution of states. They are completely different. The former exist in standard QFT, the latter do not.
  2. A

    Insights 9 Reasons Quantum Mechanics is Incomplete - Comments

    Yes. But the starting point is counting branches in simpler situations. See also Carroll & Sebens, who elaborate basically the same idea, with slightly different language: https://arxiv.org/abs/1405.7907
  3. A

    Insights 9 Reasons Quantum Mechanics is Incomplete - Comments

    IMO, many-worlds with the Vaidman interpretation of the Born rule is complete: http://philsci-archive.pitt.edu/14590/
  4. A

    Insights 9 Reasons Quantum Mechanics is Incomplete - Comments

    I'm trying to reconcile the following statements: Question: is there a non-many-worlds interpretation of QM for which QM is "complete"?
  5. A

    A Path Integral Approach To Derive The KG Propagator

    When you plug in the right-hand side of the 2nd equation in (6.8) for ##\phi(x)##, you need to use two different dummy integration 4-momenta for each of the two factors of ##\phi(x)## in each term; call these ##p## and ##p'##. Then when doing the ##d^4x## integral, you will get...
  6. A

    Insights 9 Reasons Quantum Mechanics is Incomplete - Comments

    Because you still need rules to decide when to modify the state by chopping off branches. If you do it under the wrong circumstances, you will destroy observable quantum coherence effects. Psi-epistemic interpretations have all sorts of other problems as well: https://arxiv.org/abs/1303.2834
  7. A

    Insights 9 Reasons Quantum Mechanics is Incomplete - Comments

    Lüders rule, as I understand it (see below), seems to require an observer outside the system being measured. This is not the case in QFT, where observers and everything else are comprised of excitations of the quantum fields. http://philsci-archive.pitt.edu/4111/1/Lueders_rule_BuschLahti.pdf
  8. A

    Insights 9 Reasons Quantum Mechanics is Incomplete - Comments

    What is "(generalized)" Bayesian updating? (I know what ordinary Bayesian updating is.) Do you have a reference?
  9. A

    Insights 9 Reasons Quantum Mechanics is Incomplete - Comments

    I don't see why it matters whether one views the quantum state as epistemic or ontological. QFT predicts a two-branched state for the post-measurement Stern-Gerlach lab (and the people in it). At what point in time, and according to what mathematical rule, do we throw away one branch?
  10. A

    I Divergent vacuum uncertainty of fields in QFT, how to resolve?

    Yes, I think so. Just by dimensional analysis, ##\langle 0|\phi(x)\phi(x+\epsilon)|0\rangle\sim 1/\epsilon^2##, so the integral should be finite (all this is in 4 spacetime dimensions).
  11. A

    I Divergent vacuum uncertainty of fields in QFT, how to resolve?

    It means the uncertainty in the value of the field at a point is infinite. Since it's not possible to measure the value of a field at an exact mathematical point, this is not a significant issue. If you multiply together fields at slightly different points, you can express the result as a sum...
  12. A

    Insights 9 Reasons Quantum Mechanics is Incomplete - Comments

    What is the mathematical description of the collapse process? Let's say we're going to do a Stern-Gerlach experiment. We isolate the lab completely from any external environment. We put the lab (and everything in it, including the experimenters) in an initial pure state, with the experiment...
  13. A

    I How to quantum mechanically describe the photon?

    You could try David Tong's lecture notes: http://www.damtp.cam.ac.uk/user/tong/qft/qft.pdf
  14. A

    I How to quantum mechanically describe the photon?

    A quantum description of photons requires quantizing the electromagnetic field. This is discussed in any textbook on quantum field theory or quantum optics, and in many quantum-mechanics textbooks. This will result in operators that create and destroy photons with definite momentum and...
  15. A

    I QFT - Confusion about Fermi's Golden Rule & Cross-Sections

    You need to have a consistent set of conventions for the amplitude and the factors that ##|M_{if}|^2## is multiplied by. Different texts use different conventions.
Back
Top