"Darth Helmet" in American football

  • Thread starter Bystander
  • Start date
11 replies · 936 views · last reply
Science Advisor
Homework Helper
Gold Member
Messages
5,629
Reaction score
1,779
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Spaceballs
Watching football (American) this weekend there are one or two people on maybe half(?) the teams sporting very oversize helmets; given rules on "targeting" and other "personal fouls," how long is "Darth Helmet" going to be allowed on the field? Will oversize headgear become mandatory?
 
The more accurate name is "Guardian Caps", and they are currently mandated for NFL practices for most position groups that have hard hitting. They are optional for NFL games. Generally, players with concussion issues will be the ones who wear them in games (assuming they have cleared the standard concussion protocol first).

For high school football, I don't know if they are mandatory for practices like in the NFL, but I do know some players locally that wear them in games because they have a history of concussions.

https://www.nbcboston.com/news/sports/nfl/guardian-caps-helmet-concussions-explained/4007918/

Two American football players side by side in close-up. Left, a player in a yellow Green Bay Packers helmet cover, white jersey with green number 87, looking up. Right, a player in a grey New England Patriots helmet with a soft padded shell, navy jersey with white number 87, pointing to the side.
 
  • Informative
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: Bystander and BillTre
..., annddd the increased rotational/torsional moment as far as increase/reduction of neck injuries?
 
Bystander said:
..., annddd the increased rotational/torsional moment as far as increase/reduction of neck injuries?
I don't think so. The additions are pretty light compared to the helmet they go over.
 
Not the mass, the length of the lever...it is visibly larger/longer. "Glancing" impacts/caroms break necks while protecting brains? Any actual statistics on neck sprain rates?
 
Bystander said:
Not the mass, the length of the lever...it is visibly larger/longer. "Glancing" impacts/caroms break necks while protecting brains? Any actual statistics on neck sprain rates?
Lordy, do the search yourself and post it here if you find something actually worrisome. Think of a layer of bubble wrap strapped to the outside of the football helmets. Near zero mass translates into near zero MOI added, no? Yeesh.
 
I know that during World War II USA soldiers wore their helmets without the chin strap buckled. Otherwise when subjected to blast the high area of the helmet might gather enough force to break your neck.
 
Bystander said:
Actually, it looks like that study concludes that the Guardian Caps do nothing... Weird.

Results

No difference was present between the collapsed mean values for the entire sample between the TRAD and GC conditions for PLA (TRAD = 16.3g ± 2.0g, GC = 17.2g ± 3.3g, P = .20), PAA (TRAD = 992.1 ± 209.2 rad/s2, GC = 1029.4 ± 261.1 rad/s2, P = .51), or the total number of impacts (TRAD = 9.3 ± 4.7, GC = 9.7 ± 5.7, P = .72). Similarly, no difference was observed between the TRAD and GC conditions for PLA (TRAD = 16.1g ± 1.2g, GC = 17.2g ± 2.79g, P = .32), PAA (TRAD = 951.2 ± 95.4 rad/s2, GC = 1038.0 ± 166.8 rad/s2, P = .29), or total impacts (TRAD = 9.6 ± 4.2, GC = 9.7 ± 5.04, P = .32) between sessions for the 7 players who completed all 6 workouts.

Conclusions

These data suggested no difference in head kinematics data (PLA, PAA, and total impacts) when GCs were worn. Therefore, GCs may not be effective in reducing the magnitude of head impacts experienced by NCAA Division I American football players.
 
berkeman said:
Actually, it looks like that study concludes that the Guardian Caps do nothing... Weird.
Design a sport to cause brain damage. When people complain, design a placebo gadget.
 
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/M1_helmet
Hornbein said:
I know that during World War II USA soldiers wore their helmets without the chin strap buckled. Otherwise when subjected to blast the high area of the helmet might gather enough force to break your neck.
Apocryphal.
 
Went down the "basal skull fracture"+"high G" rabbit hole, and have emerged bewitched, bothered, and "Bemildred" (Pogo's bats)...someone else can try making sense of it.

This is the wiki/google drawback...what was once, is gone, and forever unrecoverable.