4th order differential equation

Click For Summary

Discussion Overview

The discussion revolves around finding the general solution to the fourth-order differential equation y'''' - 8y' = 0. Participants explore the characteristic polynomial, roots of the equation, and the derivation of the general solution, involving complex numbers and Euler's formula.

Discussion Character

  • Technical explanation
  • Mathematical reasoning
  • Debate/contested

Main Points Raised

  • Some participants derive the characteristic polynomial r^4 - 8r = 0 and simplify it to r*(r^3 - 8), identifying one root as 0.
  • Others propose that the roots of r^3 - 8 = 0 can be expressed as r = 2*e^(2mπi/3) for m = 0, 1, 2, and question how to arrive at this form.
  • One participant states that the cubic root of 8 is 2 and provides a factorization of the polynomial as r(r - 2)(r² + 2r + 4).
  • Another participant expresses confusion about how the roots r = 2, -1 + i√3, and -1 - i√3 relate to the earlier expression involving e^(2mπi/3).
  • Some participants discuss the implications of working over the field of complex numbers versus real numbers, noting that while there is only one real solution (r = 2), there are three distinct complex solutions.
  • Euler's formula is referenced to explain the relationship between exponential and trigonometric forms of the roots.

Areas of Agreement / Disagreement

Participants express differing views on the derivation of the roots and the relationship between the complex and real solutions. There is no consensus on the exact steps leading to the general solution, and confusion persists regarding the equivalence of different expressions for the roots.

Contextual Notes

Some participants note limitations in understanding the transition from the characteristic polynomial to the general solution, particularly regarding the treatment of complex roots and the application of Euler's formula.

chuy52506
Messages
77
Reaction score
0
I'm trying to find the gen. solution to the equation y''''-8y'=0
I found the characteristic polynomial by plugging in ert as a solution to y.
I got,
r^4-8r=0
I simplified to get
r*(r^3-8)
Thus one root is 0, for the other 3 i must find the cubed root of 8.
I know the answer is 2*e2m*pi*i/3 for m=0,1,2
How do I arrive at that answer?
I tried the following:
Represent 8 as 8=8[cos(2*pi)+i*sin(2*pi)]=8*ei*pi
 
Physics news on Phys.org
chuy52506 said:
I'm trying to find the gen. solution to the equation y''''-8y'=0
I found the characteristic polynomial by plugging in ert as a solution to y.
I got,
r^4-8r=0
I simplified to get
r*(r^3-8)
Thus one root is 0, for the other 3 i must find the cubed root of 8.
I know the answer is 2*e2m*pi*i/3 for m=0,1,2
How do I arrive at that answer?
I tried the following:
Represent 8 as 8=8[cos(2*pi)+i*sin(2*pi)]=8*ei*pi
It should be 8 = 8ei*2πm, for any m, right?
 
The roots are r=0,2*e(2*m*pi*i)/3
then it says this is equivalent to
r=0,2,-1+i*sqrt(3),-1-i*sqrt(3)

Then the gen solution is
y=c1+c2*e2*t+e-t*[c3*cos(t*sqrt(3))+c4*sin(t*sqrt(3))]

I don't know how they arrive to this
 
Obviously, the cubic root of 8 is 2.
r^4-8r = r(r-2)(r²+2r+4)
= r (r-2) [r+1+i sqrt(3)] [r+1-i sqrt(3)]
 
chuy52506 said:
The roots are r=0,2*e(2*m*pi*i)/3
then it says this is equivalent to
r=0,2,-1+i*sqrt(3),-1-i*sqrt(3)

Then the gen solution is
y=c1+c2*e2*t+e-t*[c3*cos(t*sqrt(3))+c4*sin(t*sqrt(3))]

I don't know how they arrive to this
Suppose λ is a root of the polynomial. That is, the differential equation has a factor (D-λ), where D = d/dt, so the equation can be written P(D)(D-λ)y = 0, for some polynomial P.
Try the solution y = eλt: P(D)(D-λ)eλt = P(D)(D(eλt - λeλt) = P(D)(λeλt - λeλt) = 0. So the general solution is a linear combination of such terms.
A complication arises when there is a repeated root, i.e. a factor (D-λ)n. It's fairly easy to show that treλt is also a solution for r = 1, .. n-1.
 
But where is the root e(2*m*pi*i)/3 derived from? and how is this equivalent to the roots:2,-1+i*sqrt(3),-1-i*sqrt(3) for m=1,2,3
 
exp(2∏n i)=1
so
(exp(2∏n i/3))^3=1
also
exp(2∏n ix)=cos(2∏n x)+i sin(2∏n x)
so
exp(2∏n i/3)=cos(2∏n /3)+i sin(2∏n /3)
 
Last edited:
lurflurf said:
exp(2∏n i)=1
so
(exp(2∏n i/3))^3=1
also
exp(2∏n ix)=cos(2∏n ix)+i sin(2∏n ix)
so
exp(2∏n i/3)=cos(2∏n i/3)+i sin(2∏n i/3)
Small correction (too many i's):
exp(2∏n ix)=cos(2∏n x) + i sin(2∏n x)
so
exp(2∏n i/3)=cos(2∏n/3) + i sin(2∏n/3)
... and cos(2∏/3) = -cos(∏/3) = -(√3)/2 etc.
 
chuy52506 said:
But where is the root e(2*m*pi*i)/3 derived from? and how is this equivalent to the roots:2,-1+i*sqrt(3),-1-i*sqrt(3) for m=1,2,3

What you are getting confused about is the field of the reals vs. the field of complex numbers. Over the field of the reals there is only one solution to the equation r^3-8=0 namely r=2, but over the field of complex numbers there are 3 distinct solutions to the equation r^3-8=0.

To see this understand that exp(i2m\pi)=1 for any m\epsilon\mathbb{Z}. So if, r^3=8\cdot1=8exp(i2m\pi) then
r =2exp(\frac{i2m\pi}{3}) but you can see the only distinct ones are for m= 0,1,2 since for m beyond or below that you repeat your answers. To answer your other question you need to know about Euler's formula which says that: e^{i\phi}=cos(\phi)+isin(\phi)

So for example, 2exp(i\frac{2\pi}{3})=2(cos(\frac{2\pi}{3})+i\sin({\frac{2\pi}{3}})=2(-\frac{1}{2}+i\frac{\sqrt{3}}{2})
 
Last edited:

Similar threads

  • · Replies 3 ·
Replies
3
Views
1K
  • · Replies 52 ·
2
Replies
52
Views
8K
  • · Replies 2 ·
Replies
2
Views
2K
  • · Replies 2 ·
Replies
2
Views
4K
  • · Replies 7 ·
Replies
7
Views
3K
  • · Replies 3 ·
Replies
3
Views
2K
  • · Replies 1 ·
Replies
1
Views
2K
  • · Replies 2 ·
Replies
2
Views
3K
  • · Replies 1 ·
Replies
1
Views
3K
  • · Replies 1 ·
Replies
1
Views
2K