Algodoo and Physics Analysis of Interactions

Click For Summary
The discussion focuses on analyzing a Rube Goldberg device created in Algodoo, specifically examining the physics of a ball's interaction with a windmill. Key points include calculating the ball's velocity upon impact, analyzing changes in potential energy (PE), kinetic energy (KE), and momentum during its descent, and assessing energy conservation throughout the process. The system is assumed to be frictionless, with stationary triangular blocks and specific angles provided for calculations. Participants emphasize the importance of using energy conservation principles and momentum conservation to derive the necessary equations and results. The conversation highlights the need for numerical data to facilitate accurate calculations.
Noe Wong
Messages
4
Reaction score
1

Homework Statement


[/B]
I have created a very simple Rube Goldberg device in Algodoo, and I need to analyze 3 correlating steps within it, using physics descriptives and equations. My primary focus is the ball as it hits the windmill, which I need to describe and calculate its velocity at that stage. Next, I have to analyze the step prior to that: describing and solving for how the balls potential energy, kinetic energy, and momentum are changed during the descent through the ramps and how it translates to the next step; was the total energy conserved when it hit the windmill? Lastly, I need to describe the interaction as the ball after it hits the windmill - how its PE, KE and momentum changed during that interaction and how the total energy was conserved if at all and how it was transferred from one object to another, along with the final conservation of momentum throughout the 3 steps.

Homework Equations


[/B]
PE = KE
Momentum = Mass(Velocity)
PE = (m)(g)(h)
Not sure of others that may apply

The Attempt at a Solution


[/B]
As you can see by the attached (I wish I could attach the .phz file to see it in motion), I created my simple machine in Algodoo which is the first part of the assignment. I have been trying to figuring out how to apply the above equations to the system but could not figure out where and how they could be applied, especially since the motion is not singular but contains multiple motions within a set (bouncing back and forth, free falling, projectile, etc). Any help you could provide by steering me in the right direction would be extremely helpful. Mahalo in advance.
 

Attachments

  • Screen Shot 2017-12-03 at 12.05.39 AM.png
    Screen Shot 2017-12-03 at 12.05.39 AM.png
    9.8 KB · Views: 914
Last edited by a moderator:
Physics news on Phys.org
With so many on here, can no one assist with suggestions ? I could really use some direction please? Anyone?
 
I might help you, but I have some questions

1-Is there a friction in this system ?
2-Are triangle blocks stationary or they move when the ball hits them ?
3-Whats the angle of the triangle blocks respect to an axis which, you ll use it to solve the problem ?
4-Windmill moves with constant angular velocity right ?

If we consider all system is frictionless, triangle blocks are stationary and If we know the angles of the blocks then it seems solvable to me.

If there's friction or triangles blocks are moving then we need to consider something else and it will be more complicated.

We need numericals for some data like height of the windmill, the angular velocity of the windmill etc. or we need to assign some symbols for them to solve the problem.
 
Aloha Arman,

Ohmygosh...Thank you in advance for answering the call! ANY input is greatly appreciated!

To answer your questions:

1- No air friction and no notable friction on triangles.
2- They are stationary.
3- Left triangles show -15 degrees and the right triangles show -165 degrees at the x axis

We can estimate the windmill to be 3 meters to top of the triangle, it has an angular velocity of -1.57 rad/s. Also, initial drop height of ball can be estimated to be approximately 25.5m.

Do you have access to Algodoo or can you open a .phz file? If so, I can send you the file to evaluate in motion if it is permissible, I am not sure the rules on that type of thing but this forum does not allow for this type of file.

Mahalo,
Noe
 
We can start with KE energy and PE, until the ball hits the windmill.

During this time we can try to understand the energy conservation and also the momentum of the ball.

Since there's no friction we know that energy will conserved in this process. So we have a ball falling down and its potential energy will turn to kinetic energy in this process. Using the energy conservation can you find the velocity of the ball at the last triangle block. For direction of the velocity you can use momentum of the ball. Since the triangle blocks are stationary using the momentum conservation try to calculate an angle where in the last triangle what could be the angle of the ball.
 
I am unsure as to how to find the angle of the ball, but upon impact to the last triangle, the velocity of the ball was noted in 3 directions: -5.77 m/s South, 6.37 m/s Southeast and 2.72 m/s East. Upon impact to the windmill, v = -12.07 m/s South, 12.23 m/s Southwest and -1.98 m/s West.

Mass of ball is .461g
Arman777 said:
I might help you, but I have some questions

1-Is there a friction in this system ?
2-Are triangle blocks stationary or they move when the ball hits them ?
3-Whats the angle of the triangle blocks respect to an axis which, you ll use it to solve the problem ?
4-Windmill moves with constant angular velocity right ?

If we consider all system is frictionless, triangle blocks are stationary and If we know the angles of the blocks then it seems solvable to me.

If there's friction or triangles blocks are moving then we need to consider something else and it will be more complicated.

We need numericals for some data like height of the windmill, the angular velocity of the windmill etc. or we need to assign some symbols for them to solve the problem.
Arman777 said:
We can start with KE energy and PE, until the ball hits the windmill.

During this time we can try to understand the energy conservation and also the momentum of the ball.

Since there's no friction we know that energy will conserved in this process. So we have a ball falling down and its potential energy will turn to kinetic energy in this process. Using the energy conservation can you find the velocity of the ball at the last triangle block. For direction of the velocity you can use momentum of the ball. Since the triangle blocks are stationary using the momentum conservation try to calculate an angle where in the last triangle what could be the angle of the ball.
Arman777 said:
We can start with KE energy and PE, until the ball hits the windmill.

During this time we can try to understand the energy conservation and also the momentum of the ball.

Since there's no friction we know that energy will conserved in this process. So we have a ball falling down and its potential energy will turn to kinetic energy in this process. Using the energy conservation can you find the velocity of the ball at the last triangle block. For direction of the velocity you can use momentum of the ball. Since the triangle blocks are stationary using the momentum conservation try to calculate an angle where in the last triangle what could be the angle of the ball.
 
The book claims the answer is that all the magnitudes are the same because "the gravitational force on the penguin is the same". I'm having trouble understanding this. I thought the buoyant force was equal to the weight of the fluid displaced. Weight depends on mass which depends on density. Therefore, due to the differing densities the buoyant force will be different in each case? Is this incorrect?

Similar threads

Replies
10
Views
3K
Replies
11
Views
3K
  • · Replies 11 ·
Replies
11
Views
2K
  • · Replies 7 ·
Replies
7
Views
2K
Replies
24
Views
3K
Replies
2
Views
2K
  • · Replies 12 ·
Replies
12
Views
2K
Replies
2
Views
1K
Replies
13
Views
3K
Replies
55
Views
5K