All real numbers are complex numbers?And are I #'s orthogonal R#'s?

  • Thread starter nabeel17
  • Start date
  • #1
57
1
A) I understand that complex numbers come in the form z= a+ib where a and b are real numbers. In the special case that b = 0 you get pure real numbers which are a subset of complex numbers. I read that both real and imaginary numbers are complex numbers so I am a little confused with notations.

What then is the purpose of saying something is a member of the reals or a member of complex if real numbers are also part of the complex numbers. Also how do you determine what is a larger number when comparing say 4i with 3. Do I take the modulus of 4i (which is 2) and compare that?

B) Now going to the complex plane, we use something like vector addition to map a complex number using some amount of real and some amount of imaginary. The real and imaginary axis are orthogonal to each other so I am wondering if real and imaginary numbers are orthogonal? For example if I have two real orthogonal vectors u=(1,1) and v=(1,-1), the dot product gives 0. But two complex numbers that are "orthogonal" say s=1+i and t=1-i give a "dot product" of 2 (using i*-i=1). Also since a complex number uses real and imaginary components, why can I not do a dot product (or vector multiplication) and say s (dot) t =|s||t|cosα and since α= 90, then s (dot) t=0? I'm not sure if I am asking the right questions here or if I even understand what I'm asking but can someone try to clear this up?
 

Answers and Replies

  • #2
jbunniii
Science Advisor
Homework Helper
Insights Author
Gold Member
3,473
255
What then is the purpose of saying something is a member of the reals or a member of complex if real numbers are also part of the complex numbers.
It is true that the real numbers can be considered as a subset of the complex numbers. Saying that ##x## is a real number gives you more specific information than saying that ##x## is complex, just as saying that ##x## is a positive integer gives you more information than saying that ##x## is an integer.

Also how do you determine what is a larger number when comparing say 4i with 3. Do I take the modulus of 4i (which is 2) and compare that?
It's not too hard to show that there is no way to order the complex numbers, so it does not make sense to ask which is larger: ##4i## or ##3##. Indeed, it can be shown that, up to isomorphism, the only complete ordered field is ##\mathbb{R}##, the set of real numbers.

B) Now going to the complex plane, we use something like vector addition to map a complex number using some amount of real and some amount of imaginary. The real and imaginary axis are orthogonal to each other so I am wondering if real and imaginary numbers are orthogonal?
Yes, that's true. But be careful to define the dot product correctly for complex numbers. If ##z = a+bi## and ##w = x+yi##, then ##x \cdot y = ax + by = \text{Re}(z\overline{w})##.

For example if I have two real orthogonal vectors u=(1,1) and v=(1,-1), the dot product gives 0.
Correct. In general, the dot product of two vectors ##(a,b)## and ##(x,y)## in ##\mathbb{R}^2## is ##ax + by##.

But two complex numbers that are "orthogonal" say s=1+i and t=1-i give a "dot product" of 2 (using i*-i=1).
No, the dot product of ##s## and ##t## is defined to be consistent with the ##\mathbb{R}^2## definition. In this case, ##s\cdot t = \text{Re}(s\overline{t}) = \text{Re}((1+i)(1+i)) = \text{Re}(2i) = 0##.
Also since a complex number uses real and imaginary components, why can I not do a dot product (or vector multiplication) and say s (dot) t =|s||t|cosα and since α= 90, then s (dot) t=0?
Yes, that's correct.
 
  • Like
Likes 1 person
  • #3
57
1
Ahh, thanks for clearing that up!
 
  • #4
1
0
I don't know if this has already been stated but imaginary numbers (or complex numbers) are not real numbers, but all numbers are complex numbers because you can think of all numbers as having "+0i" after them.

For instance, 1 is a real number, but it is also a complex number because it is also "1 + 0i".
1i on the other hand is a complex number and not a real number because you cannot represent it on the real number line.
 
  • #5
pwsnafu
Science Advisor
1,080
85
I don't know if this has already been stated but imaginary numbers (or complex numbers) are not real numbers, but all numbers are complex numbers because you can think of all numbers as having "+0i" after them.

"all numbers" is wrong, you mean "all real numbers".

For instance, 1 is a real number, but it is also a complex number because it is also "1 + 0i".

The correct way to phrase this is that the embedding ##x \mapsto x+0i## is a field isomorphism.

1i on the other hand is a complex number and not a real number because you cannot represent it on the real number line.

It is worth pointing out that this is only true as fields (or rings). As groups the real numbers is isomorphic to the imaginary numbers.
 
  • #6
WWGD
Science Advisor
Gold Member
5,495
3,956
It's not too hard to show that there is no way to order the complex numbers, so it does not make sense to ask which is larger: ##4i## or ##3##. Indeed, it can be shown that, up to isomorphism, the only complete ordered field is ##\mathbb{R}##, the set of real numbers.

Nitpick: the Complex Numbers cannot be made into an ordered field, i.e., so that there is a specific relationship between the field properties and the order properties,but, by the well-ordering principle, they can be well-ordered.
 
  • #7
jbunniii
Science Advisor
Homework Helper
Insights Author
Gold Member
3,473
255
Nitpick: the Complex Numbers cannot be made into an ordered field, i.e., so that there is a specific relationship between the field properties and the order properties,but, by the well-ordering principle, they can be well-ordered.
You're right, my wording was careless.
 
  • #8
WWGD
Science Advisor
Gold Member
5,495
3,956
You're right, my wording was careless.

Join the (my) club.
 

Related Threads on All real numbers are complex numbers?And are I #'s orthogonal R#'s?

Replies
7
Views
2K
Replies
2
Views
8K
Replies
6
Views
635
Replies
3
Views
811
Replies
3
Views
34K
  • Last Post
Replies
1
Views
2K
Replies
3
Views
8K
  • Last Post
Replies
5
Views
2K
Replies
10
Views
19K
Replies
2
Views
1K
Top