Are 2 and 4 “special” numbers?

  • Level: Undergrad 
  • Thread starter mr3000
  • Start date
23 replies · 1K views · last reply
mr3000
Messages
22
Reaction score
6
TL;DR
2+2=4
2*2=4
2^2=4
2↑↑2=4
2↑↑↑2=4
2(infinity↑)2=4

2 and four are the only numbers with this relationship.

Why?
2+2=4
2*2=4
2^2=4
2↑↑2=4
2↑↑↑2=4
2(infinity↑)2=4

2 and 4 are the only numbers with this relationship.

Why?
 
mr3000 said:
2+2=4 Why?

Because 2 = 1 + 1 (and 4 = 1 + (1 + (1 + 1))) by definition.

mr3000 said:
2*2=4 Why?

Because 2 + 2 = 4 (by the equivalence of multiplication by an integer and repeated addition).

mr3000 said:
2^2=4 Why?

Because 2 × 2 = 4 (by the equivalence of integer exponentiation and repeated multiplication).

mr3000 said:
2↑↑2=4

This is not correct...

mr3000 said:
2↑↑↑2=4

nor is this...

mr3000 said:
2(infinity↑)2=4

and this is meaningless.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: Ibix and PeroK
mr3000 said:
Are 2 and 4 “special” numbers?

Yes, they are respectively the smallest prime and the smallest composite numbers.

Can you think of a number that isn't special? How about 1729?
 
  • Like
  • Haha
Likes   Reactions: jedishrfu and sbrothy
pbuk said:
Can you think of a number that isn't special?
Can't be. If there were integers that were not special, there'd be a smallest one, and that would make it special, a paradox. Hence all number are special.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: jedishrfu, sbrothy and PeroK
Halc said:
If there were special integers, there'd be a smallest one, and that would make it special, a paradox. Hence all number are special.
Did you mean to write "If there were non-special integers,..."?
 
  • Like
  • Agree
Likes   Reactions: jedishrfu, sbrothy and Halc
renormalize said:
Did you mean to write "If there were non-special integers,..."?
Well, since he proved that the set of non-special integers is empty, it is true that all integers in the set of non-special integers are special.
 
Last edited:
They are also special for infinitely many reasons. Otherwise those that are special for the least number of reasons would be special for one more reason.
 
pbuk said:
This is not correct...



nor is this...
You are wrong.

## 2\uparrow2=2\times2=4\\ ##
## 2\uparrow\uparrow2=2\uparrow2=2\times2=4\\ ##
## 2\uparrow\uparrow\uparrow2=2\uparrow\uparrow2=2\uparrow2=2\times2=4\\ ##
## \vdots\\ ##
## 2\uparrow^n2=2\uparrow^{n-1}2=2\uparrow^{n-2}2=\cdots=2\uparrow2=2\times2=4\\ ##
Where ## n ## is a natural number. For ## n=0 ##, ## \uparrow^n ## represents multiplication (iterated addition).

mr3000 said:
2(infinity↑)2=4
## \infty ## is not a natural number; therefore, ## \infty ## can be included by using limits.
## \lim_{n\to\infty}2\uparrow^n2=\lim_{n\to\infty}4=4 ##
 
Halc said:
Can't be. If there were special integers, there'd be a smallest one, and that would make it special, a paradox. Hence all number are special.

Indeed. I was hoping to encourage the OP to think about this.
 
Gavran said:
You are wrong.

Yes I am (about 2↑↑2 and 2↑↑↑2) , I should have written:

mr3000 said:
2↑↑2=4 Why?

Because 2↑2 = 4 (by the definition of ↑↑).

mr3000 said:
2↑↑↑2=4 Why?

Because 2↑↑2 = 4 (by the definition of ↑↑↑).

However 2(infinity↑)2 (assuming this is intended to mean ## 2 \uparrow^\infty 2 ##) is not defined because ## a \uparrow^n b ## is only defined for integers a, b, n and ## \infty ## is not an integer.

You could write ## \lim_{n \to \infty} 2 \uparrow^n 2 = 4 ##, however this is not the same thing.
 
Last edited:
PeroK said:
Perhaps "special" is an ill-defined, self-referential property?
Paradoxes easily pop up given self-referential situations, but in this case, I think your 'ill-defined' is probably the primary problem.

Leaving it ill-defined, a number being special seems to be evaluated on a continuum rather than a binary assessment, or as @martinbn points out, a count of reasons.

So yea, 242 is not particularly special, but it is probably more special than 1729 and less special than 243 or 47,176,870. There's no first non-special integer since none has a rating of 'not special at all'.


and @renormalize : Thx, fixed
 
I like to think of it as equivalent to the fact that if you start looking for small change on the sidewalk you’re gonna find small change on the sidewalk.

Not very helpful but it makes a meaningless kind of sense.
 
Halc said:
So yea, 242 is not particularly special, but it is probably more special than 1729
Well, 1729 is more special.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: pbuk, PeroK and Halc
martinbn said:
Well, 1729 is more special.
Not only special, but special for being famously special, beating out 47,176,870
 
Ramanujan had a kinship with 1729 as he investigated Fermats theorem. 1729 is known as a taxicab number from when GH Hardy visited Ramanujan at the hospital and remarked about how unremarkable his taxicab number 1729 was.

Ramanujan said it was quite remarkable being the sum of two cubes two different ways.

1729 = 1^3+12^3 = 10^3+9^3
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: dextercioby and Charles Link
jedishrfu said:
Ramanujan had a kinship with 1729 as he investigated Fermats theorem. 1729 is known as a taxicab number from when GH Hardy visited Ramanujan at the hospital and remarked about how unremarkable his taxicab number 1729 was.

Ramanujan said it was quite remarkable being the sum of two cubes two different ways.

1729 = 1^3+12^3 = 10^3+9^3
But 1729 is not a cube itself, and could not be by Fermat's last theorem. :)
 
jedishrfu said:
Ramanujan had a kinship with 1729 as he investigated Fermats theorem. 1729 is known as a taxicab number from when GH Hardy visited Ramanujan at the hospital and remarked about how unremarkable his taxicab number 1729 was.

Ramanujan said it was quite remarkable being the sum of two cubes two different ways.

1729 = 1^3+12^3 = 10^3+9^3
And being the smallest such number.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: Charles Link
Halc said:
Can't be. If there were integers that were not special, there'd be a smallest one, and that would make it special, a paradox. Hence all number are special.
Doesn't this assume that all special integers are positive?
 
Dale said:
Doesn't this assume that all special integers are positive?
Thought of that, but by 'smallest' uninteresting number, I thought it kind of obvious that I meant magnitude, not most-negative. It still squeamed me out a bit to type 'integer' in that post. You're the first one to call it out.

-1729 is just as interesting by that reasoning. I wonder if negative values are legal when finding pairs of cubes that add up to x.
 
Halc said:
I thought it kind of obvious that I meant magnitude, not most-negative.
Then the proof shows that if ##n## is a least-magnitude non-special number then ##-n## must also be a non-special number. That way neither ##n## nor ##-n## are special.
 
Consider the foĺlowing definition: "the set of special numbers is the subset of all natural numbers (positive integers and zero) such that addition and multiplication between any pair of such special numbers is the same number".

So it's the set of all solutions to ab=a+b in N. These are only (0,0) and (2,2). So you can argue that 4 could also be "special" because it's both 2+2 and 2x2.
 
Dale said:
Then the proof shows that if ##n## is a least-magnitude non-special number then ##-n## must also be a non-special number. That way neither ##n## nor ##-n## are special.
If it’s the least magnitude non- special number doesn’t that kinda make it special in it’s own right? Or perhaps that’s what you meant or perhaps it was sarcasm on your part and it went over my head. I wont lie: much here does. :smile:
 
sbrothy said:
If it’s the least magnitude non- special number doesn’t that kinda make it special in it’s own right?
It is not “the” least magnitude non-special number. It is “a” least magnitude non-special number. There are two: ##n## and ##-n##, so neither is special.