Are all substitution reactions reversible?

AI Thread Summary
The discussion centers on the reaction H2 + CuCl2 = Cu + 2HCl, identified as a substitution reaction. The main argument presented is that this reaction is not reversible because copper (Cu) is less active than hydrogen (H), preventing Cu from substituting H in HCl. The Gibbs energy is referenced to analyze the reaction's reversibility, emphasizing the need to consider both entropic and enthalpic contributions to Gibbs energy for the forward and reverse reactions. Calculations indicate that the Gibbs energy for HCl is significantly more negative than that for CuCl2, suggesting that the reaction favors the formation of HCl and makes the reverse reaction highly unfavorable. The equilibrium constant (Keq) of 5 x 10^27 at room temperature further supports the conclusion that reversing the reaction to form copper chloride is extremely difficult.
Akash47
Messages
53
Reaction score
5
Consider a reaction:
H2+CuCl2= Cu+2HCl
This is a substitution reaction.But is this may not be a reversible reaction since Cu is less active than .So Cu can't substitute H from HCl and make a backward reaction.Is my thinking right?
 
Chemistry news on Phys.org
Akash47 said:
Consider a reaction:
H2+CuCl2= Cu+2HCl
This is a substitution reaction.But is this may not be a reversible reaction since Cu is less active than .So Cu can't substitute H from HCl and make a backward reaction.Is my thinking right?
See Gibbs energy relation to the rate of direct and reverse reaction.
You need to sum entropic and enthalpic parts of Gibbs energy on left and right part of reaction equation to find the rates of both reverse and direct reaction.
 
trurle said:
See Gibbs energy relation to the rate of direct and reverse reaction.
You need to sum entropic and enthalpic parts of Gibbs energy on left and right part of reaction equation to find the rates of both reverse and direct reaction.
But isn't my opinion right what I've said in my first post?
 
Akash47 said:
Consider a reaction:
H2+CuCl2= Cu+2HCl
This is a substitution reaction.But is this may not be a reversible reaction since Cu is less active than .So Cu can't substitute H from HCl and make a backward reaction.Is my thinking right?
At room temperature, Gibbs energy:
Of HCl: -2*131170+2*51(T-T0)
Of CuCl2: -1*103000+2*91(T-T0)
You can see the HCl Gibbs energy of HCl is much more negative, and difference of entropies is small so heating do not help much.
According to
9f654171eeefde32716ba2c59ac50696c77a977b

equation,
Keq=5*10^27 for reaction in question at room temperature, this mean reaction is very difficult to reverse to the formation of copper chloride.
 
I want to test a humidity sensor with one or more saturated salt solutions. The table salt that I have on hand contains one of two anticaking agents, calcium silicate or sodium aluminosilicate. Will the presence of either of these additives (or iodine for that matter) significantly affect the equilibrium humidity? I searched and all the how-to-do-it guides did not address this question. One research paper I found reported that at 1.5% w/w calcium silicate increased the deliquescent point by...
Back
Top