Banked Curve - Minimum Turn Radius

13 replies · 5K views · last reply
Devtycoon
Messages
21
Reaction score
0

Homework Statement


A car traveling 10 m/s is moving along a track banked at 5 degrees. The tire-road friction coefficient is .3 What is the minimum radius it can travel without slipping?

v0= 10 m/s
Bank Angle Θ = 5°
μ=0.3

Note I am working through prep material for the exam. The solution in the book skips steps and doesn't make sense.

Homework Equations


Normal and Tangential Kinetics for Planar Problems - FE Exam Reference Guide Page 70 - Dynamics
∑Ft=mat
∑Fn=mvt/ρ , where ρ is the radius of curvature

The Attempt at a Solution


∑Fx=Fc-Fμ
∑Fx=mv2/ρ-μmgcosΘ=0, where Θ=5°
ρ=v2/μgcosΘ=100/.3⋅*9.81⋅cos(5°)=34.1 mNote:

Why is the review manual saying to use the following solution? I do not understand the FΘ term or how it was derived.

Fc=Fμ+Fθ
mv2/ρ=μmg+mg⋅tanΘ
ρ=26m
Free-body diagram of a block on a plane inclined at theta = 5 degrees, with x and y axes rotated to the slope, showing N normal, Ff friction and Fg gravity forces; beside it a sketch of a curve with Fc and Fg and v = 10 m/s.
Note: Thanks for the help. I don't understand the solution and my attempt is the wrong answer.
 
##F_c = F_\mu + F_\theta## appears to decompose the centripetal force into a part caused by friction with coefficient ##\mu## and a part caused by the inward radial component of the normal force exerted by banked track.

So you know that the banked track is pushing normal to its force with some force ##F## (acting at angle ##\theta##relative to vertical). The vertical component of ##F## balances downward gravity, so
$$F \cos\theta = mg.$$
Meanwhile, the inward radial component of ##F## is what's left, namely
$$F_\theta = F\sin\theta.$$
Now combine them to get an expression for ##F_\theta## as a function of ##mg## and ##\theta##.

Also, I wonder if you are supposed to use the small angle approxation to get ##F_\mu = \mu mg##.
 
I am confused. Is my FBD messed up? I see a gravitational force in the direction of the centripetal force.

Hand-drawn free-body diagram of a block on a banked slope tilted 5 degrees, with axes X' and Y', labelled forces F_N (normal), F_c (centripetal), F_f (friction) and W (weight).
 
Devtycoon said:
I am confused. Is my FBD messed up? I see a gravitational force in the direction of the centripetal force.

View attachment 87216
The centripetal force must be horizontal, as the car moves along a horizontal circle.
 
Car is on a 5 degree bank. Did I still mess up the FBD?

Free-body diagram of a car on a 5 degree banked surface, with rotated axes X' along the incline and Y' perpendicular to it, showing forces W, F_N, F_c, and F_cY.
 
There is a normal force FN which is perpendicular to the road and static friction Fs that is parallel with it. The force of friction acts inward in case of smallest possible radius, to prevent the car sliding out.
Free-body diagram of a block on an inclined plane with labelled forces: N normal to the slope, Fs static friction along the slope pointing down-slope, Fcp horizontal to the left, and W weight pointing straight down.
 
I am confused because the solutions states:

Fc = Ff + FθThe overhead view looks like this. Right?
Handwritten sketch of a curved path arc with a point on it, a velocity arrow labelled V = 10 m/s pointing up-right, a normal acceleration arrow a_n pointing toward the centre, and a blue force arrow labelled F_o + F_f pointing outward; top left shows ΣF_N = m a_n = mv²/ρ.
 
I do not understand your notations.
The friction is not horizontal.
Decompose all forces into horizontal and vertical components.
 
First of all. Thanks for your help. I clearly am having a physics fundamental issue here. I have a fundamental question before I rehash the scenario here.Centripetal force is sucking the car in towards the instantaneous center of rotation right?

Hand-drawn diagram of a car on a curved path: a red-outlined yellow dot on a black curve, a blue arrow labeled V = 10 m/s pointing up, a dashed line labeled rho to a point marked IC, and a legend defining rho as radius of curvature in meters.
 
The centripetal force points towards the centre of curvature. But it does not "suck the car". It is not an operating force: it is the resultant of all forces acting on the car.
What do you mean on IoCp?
 
ehild said:
The centripetal force points towards the centre of curvature. But it does not "sucks the car". It is not an operating force: it is the resultant of all forces acting on the car.
What do you mean on IoCp?

I got sloppy with the paint tool. Sorry. It was supposed to be I.C. , the acronym for instantaneous center.

Okay next fundamental question, there are 3 additional forces acting on the particle. The friction force, force due to bank angle and the normal force due to gravity.

1) Is the force of friction preventing the car from slipping towards or away from the center of curvature?

2) What does the book mean when it states "The bank angle is the centrifugal force contributing to the normal force."
 
Devtycoon said:
Okay next fundamental question, there are 3 additional forces acting on the particle. The friction force, force due to bank angle and the normal force due to gravity.

There is no force due to bank angle, and the normal force is not due to gravity.
The forces are gravity, normal force (due to the road) and friction.

Devtycoon said:
1) Is the force of friction preventing the car from slipping towards or away from the center of curvature?

You have to figure it out. The force of static friction is less or equal to μN.

Devtycoon said:
2) What does the book mean when it states "The bank angle is the centrifugal force contributing to the normal force."

That statement has no sense. The bank angle is not a force.
 
Devtycoon said:
How can I thank you for your help?
Show your (correct) solution :)