Build a Strong Bridge with Limited Resources: A Budget-Friendly Challenge

Click For Summary

Discussion Overview

The discussion revolves around a challenge to design and build a bridge that spans a 40-cm gap, capable of supporting 1kg for 10 seconds while flexing no more than 2.5 cm. Participants explore various design ideas, materials, and constraints, including budget considerations and creative design elements.

Discussion Character

  • Exploratory
  • Technical explanation
  • Debate/contested
  • Homework-related

Main Points Raised

  • One participant describes their group's design as simple yet effective, capable of supporting 2.5kg, and discusses the use of tape and alignment of toothpicks for structural integrity.
  • Another participant questions the practical purpose of the bridge, suggesting that a simple A-frame could suffice.
  • A participant emphasizes that the bridge only needs to hold 1kg at the center, not serve a practical function.
  • There is a discussion about the definition of 'cool' in engineering, with one participant suggesting that it involves meeting specifications efficiently and aesthetically.
  • Extra points for creativity are mentioned, but they are contingent on staying within budget.
  • One participant proposes the idea of a suspension bridge using string, noting the need for appropriate end conditions.

Areas of Agreement / Disagreement

Participants express differing views on the purpose and design criteria of the bridge, with some focusing on structural integrity and others on creativity and aesthetics. The discussion remains unresolved regarding the balance between practical design and creative expression.

Contextual Notes

Participants have not clarified specific assumptions about the definitions of 'creative' design or the implications of the budget on material choices. The discussion includes various interpretations of the project's goals.

jkv6391
Messages
7
Reaction score
0
Here's a little challenge:

You need to build a bridge to fill a 40-cm gap. The bridge must be able to support 1kg for 10 seconds and flex no more than 2.5 cm. Your budget is $95 million.

Materials given are 18-cm straws at $1m, 18-cm toothpicks at 18-cm each at $5m, 6-cm toothpicks at $20m for 360 a package, 33 meters of
tape at $30m, 1 meter of string at $5m.
 
Engineering news on Phys.org
This sounds like a class project to me. What are your thoughts on it? Any preliminary sketches or calculations?
 
Yeah. It's a class project.
Right now my group has the most efficient design in the room. The design is painfully simple but the part that's done right now can carry about 2.5kg. I'm just looking for ideas about something a bit... cooler.

The design is like... the entire bridge is made up of three segments , each are 18 cm each. The 18-cm sticks are wrapped in tape to prevent it all from falling apart if they break. the 6-cm toothpicks are all aligned in a row one layer thick; It's all held together by tape on the top and bottom. We might add extra rigidity to the bottom by putting an isometric pattern on it. So far there is about $30m left in the budget.
 
You do not mention if your bridge has to be a practical means of conveying
things from a to b, a simple A frame could be a bridge.
 
No, the bridge serves no practical purpose. It only needs to be able to hold 1kg at the center.
 
jkv6391 said:
I'm just looking for ideas about something a bit... cooler.
In engineering, 'cool' is meeting or exceeding the specified parameters on time and on budget. Cooler is doing it ahead of time and under budget. If aesthetics are part of the requirements, then by all means make it look nice. If not, spending extra to dress it up is a waste of time and money.
 
Extra points will be awarded for the most creative design, however they are not awarded if it goes over budget.
 
In that case, it's pretty much up to your imagination along with the basic engineering principles. To me, that's pretty much architecture. By 'creative' design, do they mean 'peculiar' or 'artistic'?
 
Since you can use string, perhaps a suspension bridge of some sort would be "cool". But you would need end conditions that would allow it.