MHB Calculating Probabilities in Poker Hand: An Example

AI Thread Summary
The discussion focuses on calculating probabilities for various poker hands using a set of 10,000 random five-digit numbers, assumed to be independent. The calculations for hands like full house, one pair, three of a kind, and four of a kind are presented, with specific formulas used for each scenario. There is confusion regarding the denominator, as the user questions why it is consistently set at 10,000 instead of using combinations like 10C5. The user also expresses skepticism about achieving probabilities greater than one and the accuracy of results for five of a kind. The conversation highlights the need for clarity on how to determine total possibilities when calculating probabilities in this context.
shivajikobardan
Messages
637
Reaction score
54
An example of how probabilities are calculated in poker hand.

https://lh5.googleusercontent.com/pCynfBFNqfR00y8rEKWoXYkbSCGR310FpejMJ_iGWlwD7ttkCZjunp-TLKFMmU0A94CDsR4Bb-X8i6ai8RxiLLPdWlf1j9g6BZdjq1ppPZzp0JZOBjCVqwvKCK9XmGfg7Ks7VnN4IoWZIY3gqWvmKw
Probability and Statistics with Applications: A Problem Solving Text By Leonard Asimow, Ph.D., ASA, Mark Maxwell, Ph.D., ASA
You can ask me for more details about question, I won't paste them here, as it'd make the question too lengthy to view.

What problem I'm trying to do?

I am trying to find expected probability for random number independence testing aka poker test.

We've 10,000 random numbers of five digit each. They're assumed to be independent.

My calculations-:

1) Full house
10C1*9C1/10,000
=0.009

I'm correct. My only confusion here would be the denominator. Why is it 10,000?
According to the above example, should not it be 10C5?

Explanation of my thought process-:
https://lh4.googleusercontent.com/xDjxqD8_wg0IXSRCdB51bWMOn-mwptbgDut1uDOC22EdDHlom1Dmi6yo7n2TLlEJsnT3xqAa1Ifo4JJIIh8cnnVoKSCnNaIQioCy6fPP5rKNF53jgsvoCCDJ_X32-CEyu4w5z3A0FqUEla037Us-7Q
First pick 1 digit out of 10 digits. Then next, pick another digit(only 1 digit as we need a pair), out of remaining 9 digits.

2) 1 pair:

Again I looked at that highlighted figure.
For one pair, from 10 digits, choose 1 digit. That 1 digit makes a pair. Now you've remaining 3 choices. But none of those choices can be same to each other. So,

10C1*9C1*8C1*7C1/10,000
=0.504
I'm correct here as well.

3) 3 of a kind:
Here, I need to pick only single digit for 3 places, then 2 different digits for the remaining 2 places.
So,
10C1*9C1*8C1/10,000
=0.072

Here, also I'm correct. But not anymore.

4) Four of a kind:
https://lh5.googleusercontent.com/bO1wsBA0d8FQty9ydQpGTtl3Zzlma8Z0qfeeABkzVg4UVBr2hM268mbUritJur8e0D5gn79KKItkM8TgMhfzEzLpVUT4C5Yvif--9JAA2wiAQYX9YST0uL8GLVPfZ2MvAKZ8VSnh5SLoQWDnx26RqA
So from 10 digits, I need to pick 1 digit and out remaining 9 digits, I need to pick another 1 digit.
So, it should be 10C1*9C1/10,000
But it becomes similar to full house. This is wrong. I don't get why this became wrong.

5) 5 different digits:

This should've been simple, I got the answer but I got the answer greater than 1.

10C1*9C1*8C1*7C1*6C1/10,000
=3.024

I'm not sure why I got this. I am skeptical about the denominator since the start as I feel that's randomly chosen here unlike above where we did 52C5. If I increase 1 "zero" in denominator, the answer would be correct. (I've seen techniques like 10/10*9*10*8/10*7/10*6/10, but i prefer to do it as per the first poker example figure I showed so that it becomes simple for understanding).

6) Five of a kind:

It should be 10C1/10,000
=0.001
but it is instead 0.0001, so it's asking for another "zero" in the denominator for correct answer. I don't know why.
We have just 10,000 random numbers.

This is the reason for studying this-:
https://genuinenotes.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/Random-Numbers.pdf
 
Technology news on Phys.org
For the denominator, think about thr total number of possibilities.

How are picking from 52 cards different from choosing digits?
 
Thread 'Star maps using Blender'
Blender just recently dropped a new version, 4.5(with 5.0 on the horizon), and within it was a new feature for which I immediately thought of a use for. The new feature was a .csv importer for Geometry nodes. Geometry nodes are a method of modelling that uses a node tree to create 3D models which offers more flexibility than straight modeling does. The .csv importer node allows you to bring in a .csv file and use the data in it to control aspects of your model. So for example, if you...
I tried a web search "the loss of programming ", and found an article saying that all aspects of writing, developing, and testing software programs will one day all be handled through artificial intelligence. One must wonder then, who is responsible. WHO is responsible for any problems, bugs, deficiencies, or whatever malfunctions which the programs make their users endure? Things may work wrong however the "wrong" happens. AI needs to fix the problems for the users. Any way to...
Back
Top