Can 2x4 Studs Adequately Support a 3000lb Aquarium?

  • Thread starter Thread starter fe342185
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Support Weight
Click For Summary

Discussion Overview

The discussion revolves around the structural integrity and safety of placing a 3000lb aquarium on a loft in a third-floor condo, specifically focusing on whether 2x4 studs can adequately support this weight. Participants explore various considerations, including load distribution, structural analysis, and the need for professional consultation.

Discussion Character

  • Debate/contested
  • Technical explanation
  • Exploratory

Main Points Raised

  • One participant expresses concern about the adequacy of 2x4 studs to support a 3000lb load, suggesting that a detailed load analysis is necessary due to additional existing loads on the structure.
  • Another participant questions the decision to purchase a condo without a concrete slab, implying that this would simplify the load considerations.
  • There is a suggestion that if the aquarium were on a concrete slab, the compressive load would be easier to manage, although concerns about the slab's thickness are noted.
  • A participant shares their experience with building inspectors, indicating that typical inspectors may not perform detailed load assessments and recommends seeking a professional engineer (P.E.) for a thorough evaluation.
  • One participant provides a link to resources for finding qualified inspectors in Staten Island, NY, emphasizing the importance of hiring someone who can conduct a proper load analysis.

Areas of Agreement / Disagreement

Participants generally agree that a professional assessment is necessary due to the complexities involved in supporting such a heavy load. However, there is no consensus on the adequacy of the existing structure or the best course of action.

Contextual Notes

Participants highlight the need to consider additional loads on the structure, such as those from the roof and environmental factors. There is uncertainty regarding the specific structural capabilities of the loft and the implications of the existing building design.

Who May Find This Useful

Individuals considering placing heavy aquariums or similar loads in residential settings, especially in multi-story buildings, may find this discussion relevant.

fe342185
Messages
3
Reaction score
0
Please HELP! Can 2x4 studs support this weight?

Hi All,
New to the Forum and have a question. I want to put an aquarium (220Gallon) on a loft in the third floor Condo I will be purchasing. My guess of the total weight of the tank is close to 3000lbs filled. The Tank is 72"Length x 24" Deep x 30" tall. I do not own the First floor but i do know they have a concrete foundation. The loft is 22'x15'

My Plan:
Place the aquarium against an outside wall (Load Bearing) therefore i will catch at least 4 floor joist (2x6) that has a span of 12ft. Each end on a load bearing wall. The outside walls are very likely using 2x4x8 on both the first and second floor studs.

Should I?:
* Add additonal Floor joist and if so how many? I figured double up.
* Add 4x4 inside the wall below since there is a window under there also.

Additional Info:
The tank stand will have 6 - 8 legs resting on a 2x4 or 4x4 to spread the weight out evenly. In addition I was going to set the tank 6"-10" away from the wall to shift some of the weight to the other load bearing wall.

BTW - Do I need to support the walls in the first floor also. I figured the weight will be distributed over a longer span by the time it gets down there. I hope not since I do not own that floor.

Is my calculation correct? 3000/12(sq feet) = 250lbs/sqft.

Open to any suggestion.

Thank you for all you assistance.
 
Engineering news on Phys.org
I highly doubt that you will get a person to stick their neck out with the information you have given. There is no way to answer your question just on the assumptions you've made.

Honestly, I would have a consultant look at it. You are adding a 3000 Lbf load, granted, over a rather large surface area, to an existing floor. If your condo is anything like the ones I have seen though, I would not trust it from the get go. You have neglected one very large issue in your reasoning and that is that the load bearing walls are also taking the load of other things, i.e. the roof, snow loads, wind loads, etc...All of those loads are on top of what you want to add. There are a lot of things that need to be looked at, not just the load per square foot.

The only way to be certain is to walk through the structure and do a detailed load analysis. Don't regret cheapening out on this. Get a professional in your area to look at it.
 
Sorry to be captain obvious here, but since you have not purchased the condo yet, why not get one that has a ground floor with a concrete slab underneath? I guess you still have to worry a bit about cracking the slab...
 
If it was on the concrete slab, it would be easy sailing. Then you could look at simply the compressive load and go about your business. Granted, you would have to know what the thickness of the slab is. 250 Lbf/ft^2 is pushing it, but it would probably be ok there. My hot tub is around 150 Lbf/ft^2 loading on my patio.
 
Who do I call on? ...

I had a building inspector look at the condo to look for termites and check the building condition and structure. I asked him about the aquarium and he was not able to give an answer. What is the specific type of inspector or engineer do I look for.
BTW I am in Staten Island NY so if anyone can recommend a place or person it would be great.

Thank all.
 
Thank you. I will try that.
 

Similar threads

Replies
3
Views
2K
Replies
4
Views
30K
  • · Replies 2 ·
Replies
2
Views
6K
  • · Replies 11 ·
Replies
11
Views
6K