Can an electron collide with the nucleus of an atom?

In summary, an electron from outside the atom could not collide with any part of the nucleus, because it is not in an s or s-hybrid orbital. However, if the electron is in a hybrid orbital, it has a small probability of being found within the nucleus. The same goes for a photon.
  • #1
ItsDaveDude
25
0
Can an electron (from outside the atom) collide with the nucleus of an atom, and does this happen at normal energy levels? What usually happens when it does?

If it doesn't happen is it because the electrons of the atom repel the incoming electron with their charge.

Finally same question, but this time its a photon colliding with the nucleus, does this change anything, and what is the result and why?

Thanks!
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
The S-shell actually has non-zero expectation value at the nucleus. It all depends on what you call a collision.
 
  • #3
I don't know how to refine my concept of collision to ask the question better.

Can you sub-divide the answer to my question into the different ways you would define collision so I can understand better and have an answer to the questions I asked based on how the answer changes (and why) according to your definitions of collision.
 
  • #4
Basically, if your question is whether you could find an electron within the nucleus at any given time, the answer is yes, provided that the electron in question is in s or s-hybrid orbital. At any given time, there is a small chance that this electron would be found in the nucleus.

However, this does not really result in any special kind of interaction. Electron is a wave, and so are the particles making up the nucleus. They already interact electromagnetically. That's what keeps the electron where it is. And the electron does not interact strongly, so it being within the nucleus doesn't change anything compared to when it's in the vicinity of the nucleus.
 
  • #5
Ok, so according to your logic, an electron from outside the atom could not collide with any part of the nucleus (because it is not in an s or s-hybrid orbital). Is that because the other electrons would repel it?

What about the case of a photon?

As an aside, I've been told by Feynman that photons are particles, and that their wave behavior is explained by probability amplitude calculations and that they aren't really waves. I don't want to open a can of worms about whether they are or not, but can you tell me so I know is Feynman generally regarded as wrong then on this, and what is the general state of the art on this idea (again I don't want to know if they are waves or particles, but what is the current consensus belief today (as opposed to Feynman's time) if there is one).
 
  • #6
I just realized you said "from outside", so let me refine everything.

First of all, even an external electron can be represented in term of spherical waves, so it can still be written in terms of orbital hybrids. If the resulting hybridization includes s-shells, then there is a probability that the electron will be found within nucleus. If that is what you mean by collision, there you go.

For an external electron, you can also look at momentum transfer. That's the scattering event. At low energy, an incoming electron will scatter from the electrons around the atom, rather than nucleus. At high energy, you can get electron to scatter from the nucleus itself. Same deal with the photon. So if that's what you consider collision, then it's a matter of energy.

I think you misunderstood Feynman on particle-wave duality.
 
  • #7
You don't have to take my interpretation of Feynman, listen to him state it directly here within the first 30 seconds and explain why:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GqTvGLVwnQ4&feature=player_detailpage#t=418s

And my question still is: I've been told by Feynman that photons are particles, and that their wave behavior is explained by probability amplitude calculations and that they aren't really waves. I don't want to open a can of worms about whether they are or not, but can you tell me so I know is Feynman generally regarded as wrong then on this, and what is the general state of the art on this idea (again I don't want to know if they are waves or particles, but what is the current consensus belief today (as opposed to Feynman's time) if there is one).
 
  • #8
Anything Feynman says about QED is right. That's the shortest answer I can give you to your question. But you are still misunderstanding the distinction between particle and a wave if such a question comes up.
 
  • #9
I don't know if "electron/K" capture is relevant to this discussion.Although the effect refers to orbital electrons,at previous times those electrons could have been outside the atom the total event going through different stages.
 
Last edited:
  • #10
What about electron capture of protons? Do you consider it as an example of collision?
 
  • #11
ZealScience said:
What about electron capture of protons? Do you consider it as an example of collision?
That's not any different from coulomb scattering. Electron just happens to emit W boson instead of a photon and you get a flavor/isospin change.
 

1. Can an electron collide with the nucleus of an atom?

Yes, an electron can collide with the nucleus of an atom. This can happen through various processes such as scattering, absorption, and emission of particles.

2. What happens when an electron collides with the nucleus of an atom?

When an electron collides with the nucleus of an atom, it can transfer energy to the nucleus, causing it to move or vibrate. This can result in changes in the atom's structure or properties.

3. Is it possible for an electron to collide with the nucleus of an atom and not transfer any energy?

Yes, it is possible for an electron to collide with the nucleus of an atom and not transfer any energy. This can happen when the collision is elastic, meaning that the electron and nucleus bounce off each other without any energy exchange.

4. Can an electron collide with the nucleus of an atom and change the atom's identity?

No, an electron cannot collide with the nucleus of an atom and change its identity. The identity of an atom is determined by the number of protons in its nucleus, and a collision with an electron does not change this number.

5. Are there any conditions in which an electron cannot collide with the nucleus of an atom?

Yes, there are conditions in which an electron cannot collide with the nucleus of an atom. For example, in a stable atom, the electron is confined to specific energy levels and cannot collide with the nucleus. In addition, at very high energies, quantum effects can prevent the electron from reaching the nucleus.

Similar threads

Replies
54
Views
2K
  • Quantum Physics
Replies
6
Views
1K
  • Quantum Physics
Replies
6
Views
2K
Replies
4
Views
1K
  • Quantum Physics
Replies
13
Views
2K
Replies
7
Views
1K
  • Quantum Physics
Replies
5
Views
1K
Replies
43
Views
3K
  • Quantum Physics
Replies
2
Views
958
  • Quantum Physics
Replies
23
Views
4K
Back
Top