Can anyone please review/verify this proof of assertion?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Math100
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Proof
Click For Summary
The discussion revolves around the proof that any prime of the form 3n+1 is also of the form 6m+1. The proof correctly establishes that since 2 is the only even prime and not of the form 3n+1, all primes of this form must be odd. It further demonstrates that if 3n+1 is odd, then n must be even, leading to the conclusion that 3n+1 can be expressed as 6m+1. Participants confirm the validity of the proof while suggesting minor rewording for clarity. The overall consensus is that the logic is sound and the proof is correct.
Math100
Messages
817
Reaction score
229
Homework Statement
Prove the assertion below:
Any prime of the form 3n+1 is also of the form 6m+1.
Relevant Equations
None.
Proof: Suppose that any prime of the form 3n+1
is also of the form 6m+1.
Note that 2 is the only even prime number
and it is not of the form 3n+1.
This means any prime of the form 3n+1 must be odd.
Since 3n+1 is odd, it follows that 3n must be even.
Then we have n=2m for some integer m.
Thus 3n+1=3(2m)+1
=6m+1.
Therefore, any prime of the form 3n+1 is also of the form 6m+1.

Above is my proof for this assertion. Can anyone please review/verify to see if it's correct?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
It is correct. Nothing to complain about.

You can also write it in formulas, after you excluded ##p=2## as you did:
##p=3n-1 \Longrightarrow 3\,|\,(p-1)## and, as you correctly observed, ##p## is odd, so ##p-1## is even, i.e.
##2\,|\,(p-1).## Because ##2## and ##3## are coprime (no common divisor), we get ##2\cdot 3\,|\,(p-1)## which is ##6m=p-1## or ##p=6m+1##.
 
fresh_42 said:
It is correct. Nothing to complain about.

You can also write it in formulas, after you excluded ##p=2## as you did:
##p=3n-1 \Longrightarrow 3\,|\,(p-1)## and, as you correctly observed, ##p## is odd, so ##p-1## is even, i.e.
##2\,|\,(p-1).## Because ##2## and ##3## are coprime (no common divisor), we get ##2\cdot 3\,|\,(p-1)## which is ##6m=p-1## or ##p=6m+1##.
Thank you!
 
Math100 said:
Thank you!
Note that coprime is important here! If two numbers have a common divisor, say ##4## and ##6##, then both divide ##12## but ##4\cdot 6## does not!
 
Your logic is correct, but I would recommend a little rewording.
Math100 said:
Homework Statement:: Prove the assertion below:
Any prime of the form 3n+1 is also of the form 6m+1.
Relevant Equations:: None.

Proof: Suppose that any prime of the form 3n+1
is also of the form 6m+1.
You do not want to "suppose" this. That would be assuming the fact that you want to prove.
You should start with something like:
Proof: Suppose we have a prime, p, of the form p=3n+1.
Math100 said:
Note that 2 is the only even prime number
and it is not of the form 3n+1.
So p is not 2.
Math100 said:
This means any prime of the form 3n+1 must be odd.
Since 3n+1 is odd, it follows that 3n must be even.
Then we have n=2m for some integer m.
Thus 3n+1=3(2m)+1
=6m+1.
p = 6m+1.
##\blacksquare##
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Likes Math100 and Orodruin
FactChecker said:
Your logic is correct, but I would recommend a little rewording.

You do not want to "suppose" this. That would be assuming the fact that you want to prove.
You should start with something like:
Proof: Suppose we have a prime, p, of the form p=3n+1.

So p is not 2.

p = 6m+1.
##\blacksquare##
Thank you!
 

Similar threads

Replies
7
Views
3K
  • · Replies 2 ·
Replies
2
Views
1K
  • · Replies 2 ·
Replies
2
Views
3K
Replies
5
Views
2K
  • · Replies 2 ·
Replies
2
Views
4K
Replies
3
Views
1K
Replies
12
Views
2K
  • · Replies 4 ·
Replies
4
Views
1K
  • · Replies 4 ·
Replies
4
Views
7K
  • · Replies 9 ·
Replies
9
Views
2K