I Can I find a particle in two states simultaneously?

Click For Summary
In the discussion about finding a particle in two states simultaneously, it is clarified that a spin-1/2 particle can exist in a superposition of states. Specifically, a particle that is spin-up in the z-direction can be represented as a combination of spin-up and spin-down states in any other direction. Measurement in quantum mechanics does not reveal a particle in two states at once; rather, it yields a specific outcome based on the state prior to measurement. The concept of superposition allows for the particle to be in a state that encompasses both possibilities, but it is not accurate to say the particle is in two distinct states simultaneously. Ultimately, the nature of quantum measurement confirms that only one state is observed at a time.
Ahmed1029
Messages
109
Reaction score
40
If I want to get the spin angular momentum of a particle using the Stem-Gerlach experiment, I think I will find the spin 1/2 particle either spin up or spin down, but not both. I however want to ask this : Is there a non-zero probability that a particle which is spin-up in the z direction to be in both states of spin-up and spin-down simultaneously in an arbitrary direction that is not the z direction? Also, could measurement ever find the particle in the two states simultaneously?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
Ahmed1029 said:
If I want to get the spin angular momentum of a particle using the Stem-Gerlach experiment, I think I will find the spin 1/2 particle either spin up or spin down, but not both. I however want to ask this : Is there a non-zero probability that a particle which is spin-up in the z direction to be in both states of spin-up and spin-down simultaneously in an arbitrary direction that is not the z direction? Also, could measurement ever find the particle in the two states simultaneously?
Are you asking about states or measurement outcomes?

Do you understand the concept of superposition of states?

Ahmed1029 said:
Is there a non-zero probability that a particle which is spin-up in the z direction to be in both states of spin-up and spin-down simultaneously in an arbitrary direction that is not the z direction?
Spin up in the z-direction is a superposition of spin-up and spin down about any other direction.
Ahmed1029 said:
Also, could measurement ever find the particle in the two states simultaneously?
A measurement does not "find a particle in a state". A measuremement returns a measured value.
 
  • Like
Likes vanhees71, topsquark, Lord Jestocost and 1 other person
Ahmed1029 said:
If I want to get the spin angular momentum of a particle using the Stem-Gerlach experiment, I think I will find the spin 1/2 particle either spin up or spin down, but not both. I however want to ask this : Is there a non-zero probability that a particle which is spin-up in the z direction to be in both states of spin-up and spin-down simultaneously in an arbitrary direction that is not the z direction? Also, could measurement ever find the particle in the two states simultaneously?
Just to emphasize what PeroK said, a particle is never in two states simultaneously, that makes no sense. It can be in one state that is a superposition of other states.
 
  • Like
Likes vanhees71, topsquark and Ahmed1029
We often see discussions about what QM and QFT mean, but hardly anything on just how fundamental they are to much of physics. To rectify that, see the following; https://www.cambridge.org/engage/api-gateway/coe/assets/orp/resource/item/66a6a6005101a2ffa86cdd48/original/a-derivation-of-maxwell-s-equations-from-first-principles.pdf 'Somewhat magically, if one then applies local gauge invariance to the Dirac Lagrangian, a field appears, and from this field it is possible to derive Maxwell’s...

Similar threads