I Can Placing Earth Between 3 Black Holes Slow Down Time?

Click For Summary
Placing Earth equidistant from three spinning black holes would not slow down time for its inhabitants due to the time dilation effect; time would appear to pass normally on Earth. Time dilation only affects the passage of time relative to distant observers, meaning no additional time would be gained for activities like watching Netflix. The concept of differential aging suggests that if someone travels close to a black hole and returns, they could be younger than those who stayed behind, having taken a shorter path through spacetime. However, this does not equate to experiencing more time to enjoy life. Ultimately, the idea of gaining extra time through proximity to black holes is a misconception.
Joe Bond
Messages
4
Reaction score
2
I am just wondering if placing the Earth equidistant from 3 black holes that are spinnng would slow down time on the Earth, due to the time dilation effect. Would that give us more time to live?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
Why do you need three? Being in orbit around one would do. And it only slows down the passage of time relative to observers far away from the black hole. For the inhabitants of Earth time would seem to pass normally. Nobody would have gained any extra time to watch Netflix before they died.
 
  • Like
Likes berkeman, Dale and Joe Bond
Joe Bond said:
I am just wondering if placing the Earth equidistant from 3 black holes that are spinnng would slow down time on the Earth, due to the time dilation effect. Would that give us more time to live?
Assuming of course we aren't past the event horizon yet we are relatively close
 
Bandersnatch said:
Why do you need three? Being in orbit around one would do. And it only slows down the passage of time relative to observers far away from the black hole. For the inhabitants of Earth time would seem to pass normally. Nobody would have gained any extra time to watch Netflix before they died.
oh I see, that's sad. Thank you for your reply
 
Joe Bond said:
oh I see, that's sad. Thank you for your reply
Time dilation isn't something that you directly experience. Instead, the special and general theories of relativity entail something called differential ageing. This means that if you go and spend some time close to a black hole and then return, you may well be significant younger than someone who stayed at home. The reason for this is that you have taken a shorter path through spacetime. The length of your path through spacetime is precisely the amount of proper time that has elapsed for you. Proper time is what you experience.

So, although when you return you may be younger than the friends you left behind, you have literally experienced less time. In that sense you can't directly get the best of both worlds by ageing less yet experiencing the same amount of time to enjoy life. You need herbal remedies for that!
 
  • Like
Likes cianfa72 and Joe Bond
PeroK said:
Time dilation isn't something that you directly experience. Instead, the special and general theories of relativity entail something called differential ageing. This means that if you go and spend some time close to a black hole and then return, you may well be significant younger than someone who stayed at home. The reason for this is that you have taken a shorter path through spacetime. The length of your path through spacetime is precisely the amount of proper time that has elapsed for you. Proper time is what you experience.

So, although when you return you may be younger than the friends you left behind, you have literally experienced less time. In that sense you can't directly get the best of both worlds by ageing less yet experiencing the same amount of time to enjoy life. You need herbal remedies for that!
thank you for your reply
 
Hello, everyone, hope someone will resolve my doubts. I have posted here some two years ago asking for an explanation of the Lorentz transforms derivation found in the Einstein 1905 paper. The answer I got seemed quite satisfactory. Two years after I revisit this derivation and this is what I see. In the Einstein original paper, the Lorentz transforms derivation included as a premise that light is always propagated along the direction perpendicular to the line of motion when viewed from the...