Can Planets Thrive in Binary Star Systems?

6 replies · 3K views · last reply
lifeonmercury
Messages
137
Reaction score
26
How can planets exist in star systems with two or three stars? Shouldn't the planets' orbits get severely disturbed by the other stars?
 
Maybe the planets orbit around the center of mass of the two stars? Not certain though.
 
If the planets are close enough to one star or the other, then there are stable orbits because the disturbance from the other star is not enough to make the orbits unstable. Just like Jupiter's moons can orbit Jupiter without being disturbed by the sun. There are also stable orbits that are far from both stars and orbit around the center of mass of the two stars, like Comeback City said.
 
Diagram of a binary star system showing two grey stars: a small circular orbit around the right star labelled S-type, and a large outer orbit enclosing both stars labelled P-type, with blue dots marking planets on each orbit.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Binary_star
Wikipedia says there are S-type and P-type orbitals. Could there possibly be an orbital where a planet orbits both stars, but in a "figure-eight"-type pattern?
 
Comeback City said:
Could there possibly be an orbital where a planet orbits both stars, but in a "figure-eight"-type pattern?
It seems like this quote from Wikipedia's Habitability of binary star systems article addresses this question:

In reality, some orbital ranges are impossible for dynamical reasons (the planet would be expelled from its orbit relatively quickly
 
lifeonmercury said:
How can planets exist in star systems with two or three stars? Shouldn't the planets' orbits get severely disturbed by the other stars?

How can Earth have Moon? Shouldn't Moon's orbit be severely disturbed by Sun?
It is. The Sun disturbs the eccentric orbit of Moon so severely as to turn it completely in less than 9 years.
The matter, however, is that the apsides of Moon's orbit precess through a full circle - while the actual eccentricity remains unchanged.
 
Actually the stars rotate about the center of the mass of both. The center of mass is a point on a straight line joining the centre of the stars.
Diagram of two stars orbiting a common centre of mass: a blue star and a red star each trace an elliptical orbit, with a black square marked Centre of Mass lying on the straight line joining them.
One of the configurations is this. However the centre of mass varies, it could be near the bigger star even on the bigger one but still the other will rotate. In case of the moon and the earth:
Diagram of the Earth-Moon system showing Earth and Moon centers joined by a line, with the barycenter marked between them just inside Earth's surface, about 1,700 km from the surface.
This is what happens and this is also a cause for tides
 
Attachments
  • Diagram titled Orbits of Stars in a Binary System: two elliptical orbits circle a central cross marked centre of mass, with Star A (high mass) on the right and Star B (lower mass) at lower left, joined by a line.
    upload_2017-2-7_16-10-26.png
    4.6 KB · Views: 583
  • Diagram titled Orbits of Stars in a Binary System showing two stars circling a common centre of mass marked with a red cross: Star A, high mass, in a small blue orbit, and Star B, lower mass, in a larger red orbit.
    upload_2017-2-7_16-10-53.png
    4.6 KB · Views: 569
  • Diagram of the Earth-Moon system showing the Earth and Moon orbiting a common center of mass, marked above the Earth, with a dashed line joining them and red curved arrows showing their motion.
    upload_2017-2-7_16-14-11.png
    2.4 KB · Views: 583
  • Diagram of two bodies orbiting a common centre of mass: a large blue circle on the left with a red dot marking the centre of mass and a small brown circle on the far right.
    upload_2017-2-7_16-14-39.png
    1.3 KB · Views: 561