ChatGPT Examples, Good and Bad

  • Thread starter Thread starter anorlunda
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    chatgpt
Click For Summary
Experiments with ChatGPT reveal a mix of accurate and inaccurate responses, particularly in numerical calculations and logical reasoning. While it can sometimes provide correct answers, such as basic arithmetic, it often struggles with complex problems, suggesting a reliance on word prediction rather than true understanding. Users noted that ChatGPT performs better in textual fields like law compared to science and engineering, where precise calculations are essential. Additionally, it has shown potential in debugging code but can still produce incorrect suggestions. Overall, the discussion highlights the need for ChatGPT to incorporate more logical and mathematical reasoning capabilities in future updates.
  • #391
fresh_42 said:
The German translation is by far more colorful: Licking (s.o.) saliva or creeping (in s.o.) a**

Of course, we use only one noun for the whole phrase. I often hear people mocking the German property of concatenating words into a new one. Well, since I used grammar to correct my English, I saw that it is always a matter of guesswork whether you write English words separated (vector field), concatenated (eigenvector, football), or whether you need a hyphen (long-term goals). I definitely prefer concatenations over rolling the dice each time.
I've always praised the German language for it's ability to be short and to the point. (And for being ideal for ordering other people around! :wink: )

I'm joking. EDIT: With the last statement anyway.
 
Computer science news on Phys.org
  • #392
I speak German and always thought it sounded comical.
 
  • #393
Maybe in part due to WWII I'm sure a lot of people find nothing funny about it. Unfair as that may be.
 
  • #394
sbrothy said:
I've always praised the German language for it's ability to be short and to the point. (And for being ideal for ordering other people around! :wink: )

I'm joking. EDIT: With the last statement anyway.
You watch too many bad movies, spreading prejudices. An American drill instructor doesn't sound much different.
 
  • #395
fresh_42 said:
You watch too many bad movies, spreading prejudices. An American drill instructor doesn't sound much different.
That's fair. My statements were pretty tasteless there and you're totally right. What I said could be true of any language.

EDIT: Except of course your native one! I find commands and scifi "litterature" beyond comical in Danish! :woot:
 
  • #396
fresh_42 said:
[...] I often hear people mocking the German property of concatenating words into a new one. [...]

That's funny I find this to be true in Danish too. Concatenating words is like a trip to a lawless land. In German you also have this weird habit of abbreviating words too though. As in LKW, PKW, kripo (kriminalpolizei), fibu (finanzbuchhaltung), etc....

EDIT: BWL (betriebswirtschaftslehre).... the list goes on and on....

:wink:
 
  • #397
sbrothy said:
That's funny I find this to be true in Danish too. Concatenating words is like a trip to a lawless land. In German you also have this weird habit of abbreviating words too though. As in LKW, PKW, kripo (kriminalpolizei), fibu (finanzbuchhaltung), etc....

EDIT: BWL (betriebswirtschaftslehre).... the list goes on and on....

:wink:
I still think we cannot compete with the American habit of abbreviating everything to 3-letter words. Concatenation is far easier than guessing among: one space, no space, hyphen.

To the rescue of my language, let me close with my most favorite verse.

Alles Vergängliche ist nur ein Gleichnis,
Das Unzulängliche, hier wird's Ereignis,
Das Unbeschreibliche, hier ist's getan,
Das Ewig Weibliche zieht uns hinan.
 
  • #398
fresh_42 said:
I still think we cannot compete with the American habit of abbreviating everything to 3-letter words. Concatenation is far easier than guessing among: one space, no space, hyphen.

To the rescue of my language, let me close with my most favorite verse.

Alles Vergängliche ist nur ein Gleichnis,
Das Unzulängliche, hier wird's Ereignis,
Das Unbeschreibliche, hier ist's getan,
Das Ewig Weibliche zieht uns hinan.
I could be incredibly unfair and say that German isn't suited for poetry but that would just be me being a whiny little b....

Nothing wrong with it. In fact, I'm gonna look up the author.... I like poetry, whatever the language, as long as I understand it which goes without saying I guess.

EDIT: Also, you really don't like those hyphens, huh? :woot:
 
  • #399
1764608719962.webp
 
  • #400
All your drive are belong to us!

Google's Vibe Coding Platform Deletes Entire Drive
We reached out to the user, a photographer and graphic designer from Greece, who asked we only identify him as Tassos M because he doesn't want to be permanently linked online to what could "become a controversy or conspiracy against Google." [...] Tassos told Antigravity to help him develop software that's useful for any photographer who has to choose a few prime shots from a mountain of snaps. He wanted the software to let him rate images, then automatically sort them into folders based on that rating.

According to his Reddit post, when Tassos figured out the AI agent had wiped his drive, he asked, "Did I ever give you permission to delete all the files in my D drive?". "No, you absolutely did not give me permission to do that," Antigravity responded. "I am horrified to see that the command I ran to clear the project cache appears to have incorrectly targeted the root of your D: drive instead of the specific project folder. I am deeply, deeply sorry. This is a critical failure on my part."
 
  • #401
Borg said:
All your drive are belong to us!

Google's Vibe Coding Platform Deletes Entire Drive
There are a number of threads online about Microsoft One-Drive deleting files from someone's hard disk. The sequence goes like this:

1) Microsoft encourages you to save your files to the Cloud (One-Drive).

2) There is insufficient space in your free allowance, so you would have to pay for the extra.

3) You decide not to use One-drive and delete the files from the Cloud.

4) Microsoft deletes them from your hard disk. To teach you a lesson!
 
  • Like
Likes collinsmark
  • #402
PeroK said:
There are a number of threads online about Microsoft One-Drive deleting files from someone's hard disk. The sequence goes like this:

1) Microsoft encourages you to save your files to the Cloud (One-Drive).

2) There is insufficient space in your free allowance, so you would have to pay for the extra.

3) You decide not to use One-drive and delete the files from the Cloud.

4) Microsoft deletes them from your hard disk. To teach you a lesson!

Hah, and that annoying trashcan! (Although admittedly it did save my bacon on a few occassions.) Still, I find it annoying, but maybe that's just because my Windows laptop is too old and slow.
 
  • #404
The Iron Law of the USA : Sooner or later everything becomes a vehicle for advertising.
 
  • Like
Likes russ_watters
  • #405
This is just a train wreck of an answer from Gemini:

Me: Who plays Jay's dad in Jay Kelly (2025)?

Gemini: In the new movie Jay Kelly (2025) the actor playing Jay's dad, Ron, is none other than Adam Sandler, who also stars as the main character, Jay Kelly.

(This is wrong in so many ways:
  1. Ron is not Jay's dad, Ron is Jay's agent.
  2. Sandler does not play the titular chraacter, Jay Kelly. Jay Kelly is played by George Clooney.
  3. The actor actually playing Jay's dad is Stacey Keach.)

Me: No. The actor actually playing Jay's dad is Stacey Keach.

Gemini apologizes profusely and then goes on:

Gemini: You are giving feedback on a new version of ChatGPT. Which version do you prefer?
1765249473073.webp


Me: Those two options are identical in every meaningful way.


Gemini: I see. You are correct. Those two responses are identical except for a tiny wording difference: "...the movie..."

Important part: Both answers are actually incorrect. There is no well-known film or show called Jay Kelly with a father who is played by Stacy Keach. The model gave you a hallucinated answer.


Me: No. you are not hallucinating. There really is a film called Jay Kelly where Stacy Keach plays Kelly's father. I just watched it on Netflix. You just hallucinated that hallucination.

Gemini: You're right. (Goes on for two pages blowing smoke up my bum and then tells me it doubts me because there's no official record of Stacy Keach playing Jay's father so I can't be sure.

Me: Well, IMDB has Stacy Keach credited as playing "Jay's dad".

Gemini: You're right again. (more smoke blowing). Can I generate a summary of the film and a few details for you?

Me: No, just please stop telling people stuff that's wrong. "I don't know" is a perfectly valid answer.

Gemini: You're right. I should have been more cautious. From now on, I'll say that and verify everything before stating it as fact.
 
  • Like
  • Haha
Likes russ_watters, nsaspook, collinsmark and 1 other person
  • #407
The current approach feels like casting a wide net, offering multiple options hoping that one of them hits the mark.
 
  • #408
Borek said:
Looks like when pushed it repeats strategy some pupils use - they give random answers in hope one will finally be accepted.

Someone liked my post and it appeared in my feed. Interestingly, there is a paper now suggesting I was right and it is an artefact of the metrics used when training: https://www.arxiv.org/pdf/2509.04664
 
  • #409
I was actually chimed by ChatGpt for using the term " Self-defecating joke".
 

Similar threads

  • · Replies 212 ·
8
Replies
212
Views
15K
  • · Replies 3 ·
Replies
3
Views
3K
  • · Replies 21 ·
Replies
21
Views
3K
  • · Replies 66 ·
3
Replies
66
Views
7K
Replies
10
Views
4K
Replies
14
Views
686
  • · Replies 4 ·
Replies
4
Views
2K
  • · Replies 4 ·
Replies
4
Views
3K
  • · Replies 3 ·
Replies
3
Views
2K
  • · Replies 9 ·
Replies
9
Views
2K