Deriving solenoid magnetic field from coil formula

5 replies · 4K views · last reply
Prashasti
Messages
63
Reaction score
2

Homework Statement


Can I derive an equation for magnetic field inside a solenoid using the formula for magnetic field on the axis of a current carrying coil?

Homework Equations


B = μI/2r ( Magnetic field at the centre of a current carrying coil)

The Attempt at a Solution


B = μI/2r
Let the number of turns per unit length of the solenoid be 'n' and its length be 'a'
So,
B = μnaI/2r
Which is definitely not equal to μnI (Calculated using Ampere's Circuital Law)
What's wrong?[/B]
 
Prashasti said:

Homework Statement


Can I derive an equation for magnetic field inside a solenoid using the formula for magnetic field on the axis of a current carrying coil?

Homework Equations


B = μI/2r ( Magnetic field at the centre of a current carrying coil)
The formula refers to the magnetic field of an infinitely long straight current-carrying wire, at distance r from the wire. It is not valid in the centre of a loop.
 
Well, my teacher has been using that formula...

Diagram of a current loop of radius R in the x-y plane with a current element IdL at the top, distance r to a field point on the z-axis at angle θ; the field components dB_x, dB_z and dB are shown, with text noting the x-components cancel by symmetry.

The application of the Biot Savart Law on the centerline of a current loop involves integrating the z-component.

Equation for the Biot-Savart field element of a current loop: dB_Z = (mu_0 I dL / 4 pi) times R divided by (z^2 + R^2) raised to the power 3/2.

The symmetry is such that all the terms in this element are constant except the distance element dL , which when integrated just gives the circumference of the circle. The magnetic field is then

Equation for the axial magnetic field of a current loop: B_Z = (μ0/4π) · 2πR²I / (z² + R²)^(3/2).

So, if we apply the same,
z = 0 (At the centre of the loop)
So, B = μI/2R
Isn't it correct??
 
It is correct for the magnetic field at the centre of a single loop. If you have a coil, all loops have their magnetic field inside the other loops. You should use the formula for B(z) and sum (integrate) the contributions of all loops.
 
Prashasti said:
Isn't it correct??
Yes, but tha's for a single loop, using Biot-Savart. Not the thing for here..

Rather than integrate per post #5 my hint is to form a closed loop going thru the entire solenoid middle and closing outside the solenoid. You can now apply Ampere's law to get B.
Hint: contributions to the integral outside the loop may be ignored.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: Prashasti