Discrepancy with Normal Force Problems

2 replies · 2K views · last reply
Physkat
Messages
10
Reaction score
0
As I try to set up equations regarding Newtonian forces, I am looking for patterns in example problems I read. It's really frustrating then when I see different approaches that I can't see a connection to.

There are two problems that I've attached that seem to solve - what seems to me about the same content - differently.

First, the "physics book" file. This is a problem from on Forces and Newton's Laws of Motion. When calculating Fx, this problem does NOT take into account FN (Normal force). Other problems I have seen set up like this say the "x component of FN is 0, and the y component of FN is FN. The x components in this problem are dealing with W and T, which I get.

Next, look at the screen shots (in succession) I took of my online instructional of the same topic. Here you will see that for a similar object in a similar situation (a block that is on a ramp), they say the x component of FN is FN*cos90, and the y component is FN*sin90. It seems strange because since they have it lined up on the y axis, would not the x component be 0, and the y component be FN? I don't get the rationale for accounting for the cos/sin90 part. I know we are trying to find the angle ultimately, but why the difference in the approaches and how do I differentiate between the two?
Thank you.
 
Attachments
  • Textbook page showing Figure 4.36: free-body diagrams for two blocks, block 1 on a frictionless 30.0° incline and block 2 hanging, joined by a cord over a pulley, with forces W1, T and W2 labeled.
    physics book.JPG
    69.8 KB · Views: 527
  • Free-body diagram of a 2 kg block on an incline at angle alpha, with the y axis perpendicular to the ramp and x axis along it, showing forces W, F_N and f_s.
    Screen #1.png
    30.6 KB · Views: 538
  • Free-body diagram of a block on a ramp with an x-y axis tilted along the ramp surface, showing friction force fs pointing up the slope, normal force FN perpendicular to it, and weight W pointing straight down, with angle alpha marked between W and the y-axis.
    Screen #2.png
    25.5 KB · Views: 550
  • Handwritten-style worked solution on a block on an incline: W = mg and Fs = μsFN, two force equations solved by substitution to give tan α = 0.45, α = 24.2°.
    Screen #3.png
    17.5 KB · Views: 525
Physkat said:
they say the x component of FN is FN*cos90

Physkat said:
would not the x component be 0
And what is the value of cos 90?
 
Oh boy - I feel silly. Zero, of course. Thank you Haruspex. I was so focused on the set up of the problem I looked past that. Then the sin90*FN would simply be FN, as I originally thought. And I also tried to do the screen shot problem in a slightly different way (I tried the ramp sloping down from the right, whereas they had it down from the left), thinking I would get the same answer, but I did not. So I need to go back and see what I did wrong. Anyway, thank you again for this simple insight!