Do many people believe in false QM ideas

  • Level: Graduate 
  • Thread starter Trollfaz
  • Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Ideas Qm
5 replies · 2K views · last reply
Trollfaz
Messages
144
Reaction score
16
When I first started QM i found all sorts of wild ideas on the internet, such as consciousness affects the experiment and the universe needs observers to exist. The articles also somehow misrepresent experiments such as the double slit experiment and the delayed choice experiments to claim that the ideas are proven. I believed in all those ideas until i seeked clarification from here.

I am wondering if there are many people out there who subscribe to those cranky ideas.
 
Trollfaz said:
When I first started QM i found all sorts of wild ideas on the internet, such as consciousness affects the experiment and the universe needs observers to exist. The articles also somehow misrepresent experiments such as the double slit experiment and the delayed choice experiments to claim that the ideas are proven. I believed in all those ideas until i seeked clarification from here.

I am wondering if there are many people out there who subscribe to those cranky ideas.
Hoards of them, but not among real scientists. Pop-sci and new age books sell quite well; probably better than serious books about actual science. I mean, after all, something like (depending on what poll you believe) 40% of Americans believe in angels, ghosts, space alien visitations, etc.
 
Black-and-white portrait of an elderly man with wavy white hair and a moustache beside a quote card reading: Great spirits have always encountered violent opposition from mediocre minds. Attributed to Albert Einstein, with AZ Quotes logo.
Quote card: portrait of an older man with gray hair and a tie beside white text on black reading "In the beginning there were only probabilities. The universe could only come into existence if someone observed it..." attributed to Martin Rees.
e-and-the-observer-exist-as-a-pair-i-cannot-imagine-a-consistent-theory-of-andrei-linde-88-13-75.jpg
Quote card: black-and-white portrait of a man with dark-framed glasses and a suit, beside the quote 'Observations not only disturb what is to be measured, they produce it.' attributed to Pascual Jordan, with the AZ Quotes logo.
Black and white portrait photo of a smiling bald man in a suit and tie beside a quotation on black background: "When the province of physical theory was extended to encompass microscopic phenomena... without reference to the consciousness." Attributed to Eugene Wigner, from AZ Quotes.
Black and white photo of an older man with glasses beside a quotation card reading: The doctrine that the world is made up of objects whose existence is independent of human consciousness turns out to be in conflict with quantum mechanics and with facts established by experiment. Attributed to Bernard d'Espagnat.
Black-and-white portrait of a man with swept-back hair next to a quotation in white text on a black background: "A physicist is just an atom's way of looking at itself." Attributed to Niels Bohr.
Black-and-white portrait photo of a man with swept-back hair in a suit and collar beside a quote card reading: Everything we call real is made of things that cannot be regarded as real. Attributed to Niels Bohr.
 
Attachments
  • Quote card: portrait of an older man with gray hair and a tie beside white text on black reading "In the beginning there were only probabilities. The universe could only come into existence if someone observed it..." attributed to Martin Rees.
    g-there-were-only-probabilities-the-universe-could-only-come-into-existence-martin-rees-56-55-13.jpg
    45.1 KB · Views: 668
  • e-and-the-observer-exist-as-a-pair-i-cannot-imagine-a-consistent-theory-of-andrei-linde-88-13-75.jpg
    e-and-the-observer-exist-as-a-pair-i-cannot-imagine-a-consistent-theory-of-andrei-linde-88-13-75.jpg
    33.5 KB · Views: 726
  • Quote card: black-and-white portrait of a man with dark-framed glasses and a suit, beside the quote 'Observations not only disturb what is to be measured, they produce it.' attributed to Pascual Jordan, with the AZ Quotes logo.
    ote-observations-not-only-disturb-what-is-to-be-measured-they-produce-it-pascual-jordan-58-47-90.jpg
    24.6 KB · Views: 716
  • Black and white portrait photo of a smiling bald man in a suit and tie beside a quotation on black background: "When the province of physical theory was extended to encompass microscopic phenomena... without reference to the consciousness." Attributed to Eugene Wigner, from AZ Quotes.
    ovince-of-physical-theory-was-extended-to-encompass-microscopic-phenomena-eugene-wigner-58-47-91.jpg
    47.7 KB · Views: 698
  • Black and white photo of an older man with glasses beside a quotation card reading: The doctrine that the world is made up of objects whose existence is independent of human consciousness turns out to be in conflict with quantum mechanics and with facts established by experiment. Attributed to Bernard d'Espagnat.
    at-the-world-is-made-up-of-objects-whose-existence-is-independent-of-bernard-d-espagnat-58-47-92.jpg
    39.3 KB · Views: 670
  • Black-and-white portrait of a man with swept-back hair next to a quotation in white text on a black background: "A physicist is just an atom's way of looking at itself." Attributed to Niels Bohr.
    quote-a-physicist-is-just-an-atom-s-way-of-looking-at-itself-niels-bohr-3-7-0770.jpg
    23.9 KB · Views: 674
  • Black-and-white portrait photo of a man with swept-back hair in a suit and collar beside a quote card reading: Everything we call real is made of things that cannot be regarded as real. Attributed to Niels Bohr.
    te-everything-we-call-real-is-made-of-things-that-cannot-be-regarded-as-real-niels-bohr-3-7-0754.jpg
    26.2 KB · Views: 612
  • Black-and-white portrait of an elderly man with wavy white hair and a moustache beside a quote card reading: Great spirits have always encountered violent opposition from mediocre minds. Attributed to Albert Einstein, with AZ Quotes logo.
    t-spirits-have-always-encountered-violent-opposition-from-mediocre-minds-albert-einstein-8-72-96.jpg
    27.1 KB · Views: 572
Last edited:
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: Lord Jestocost
Trollfaz said:
When I first started QM i found all sorts of wild ideas on the internet, such as consciousness affects the experiment and the universe needs observers to exist. The articles also somehow misrepresent experiments such as the double slit experiment and the delayed choice experiments to claim that the ideas are proven. I believed in all those ideas until i seeked clarification from here.

I am wondering if there are many people out there who subscribe to those cranky ideas.

Some ideas about quantum mechanics seem only strange in case one prefers to mentally keep oneself in the 19th century.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: phinds and AlexCaledin
Trollfaz said:
When I first started QM i found all sorts of wild ideas on the internet, such as consciousness affects the experiment and the universe needs observers to exist...

I have never understood why the term “consciousness” is so often associated with strange magical effects when discussing quantum mechanics. When quantum mechanics was coming up, some physicists immediately realized that “physical theories” of an "out there" are – so to speak – built upon our mental impressions/images of observed phenomena which must not be identical with the objective, intrinsic nature of phenomena. That was the farewell to the 19th century physics. Confusion arises merely in case one mixes up the "projections of observed phenomena on the inner screen of our consciousness" with the "objective, intrinsic nature of phenomena".

Here is a passage from the book “THE NATURE OF THE PHYSICAL WORLD” by Arthur Stanley Eddington:

“Besides the direct knowledge contained in each self-knowing unit, there is inferential knowledge. The latter includes our knowledge of the physical world. It is necessary to keep reminding ourselves that all knowledge of our environment from which the world of physics is constructed, has entered in the form of messages transmitted along the nerves to the seat of consciousness. Obviously the messages travel in code. When messages relating to a table are traveling in the nerves, the nerve-disturbance does not in the least resemble either the external table that originates the mental impression or the conception of the table that arises in consciousness.* In the central clearing station the incoming messages are sorted and decoded, partly by instinctive image-building inherited from the experience of our ancestors, partly by scientific comparison and reasoning. By this very indirect and hypothetical inference all our supposed acquaintance with and our theories of a world outside us have been built up. We are acquainted with an external world because its fibers run into our consciousness; it is only our own ends of the fibers that we know; from those ends we more or less successfully reconstruct the rest, as a paleontologist reconstructs an extinct monster from its footprint.

* I mean, resemble in intrinsic nature. It is true (as Bertrand Russell has emphasized) that the symbolic description of structure will be identical for the table in the external world and for the conception of the table in consciousness if the conception is scientifically correct. If the physicist does not attempt to penetrate beneath the structure he is indifferent as to which of the two we imagine ourselves to be discussing.”
 
Last edited by a moderator:
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: AlexCaledin