Do You think That We Can someday Fly like Birds?

  • #1
218
0
Do you think that one day we will replicate how birds fly? Do you think that one day we can put on a suit with artificial wings and fly?
 

Answers and Replies

  • #2
2,483
100
Do you think that one day we will replicate how birds fly? Do you think that one day we can put on a suit with artificial wings and fly?

We already have hang gliders but do they count?
 
  • #3
218
0
No, i won't count hang gliders.

I'm more on the mechanics of the wings, like we can create a mechanism that creates lift like a bird does (i.e. flapping it's wings).

Kind of like an ornithopter.
 
  • #4
895
98
We may someday be able to do that on the moon. Yes, I know there is no atmosphere on the moon. But perhaps someday we will have large artificial biospheres on the moon which will make extended man powered flight possible.
 
Last edited:
  • #5
A.T.
Science Advisor
11,290
2,677
I'm more on the mechanics of the wings, like we can create a mechanism that creates lift like a bird does (i.e. flapping it's wings).

Big birds don't do a lot of flapping. They glide like hang gliders most of the time. And humans are even much heavier than the biggest flying birds. The idea of humans flying by flapping like a hummingbird is ineffective. Rotors are better.
 
  • #6
117
0
No way. The muscles of a bird are very strong and specific in the exact areas required and it's taken them many many years to evolve that way
 
  • #7
OmCheeto
Gold Member
2,185
2,632
Do you think that one day we will replicate how birds fly? Do you think that one day we can put on a suit with artificial wings and fly?

Yes.

Human's have the physical strength to fly.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gossamer_Albatross

It is only a matter of time before someone clever enough, builds a device that does not look like a pedal powered glider.
 
  • #8
1,015
3
If evolution could create rotors it certainly would?
Are rotors more efficient than wings?

In any case, birds are incredibly light. Have a bird in your hand - it weights nothing :)
If one is willing to sacrifice heavy bones and the brain, then maybe one can fly :)

Unfortunately scaling all up is not in favour for us as mass scales cubic with dimensions (and muscles that are only on the surface scale quadric). Probably aerodynamics makes it even worse -> maybe some can make a scaling statement say how much the required power should scale up.
 
  • #9
218
0
No way. The muscles of a bird are very strong and specific in the exact areas required and it's taken them many many years to evolve that way
I wasn't really thinking of using our muscles. Maybe just a smart wing design that's powered by a battery or engine.
 
  • #10
117
0
I wasn't really thinking of using our muscles. Maybe just a smart wing design that's powered by a battery or engine.

Like a microlight?
I am not sure what the question is anymore. I don't think we will ever be able to strap on acouple of artificial wings and fly off 'like a bird' as was the question, but if we are talking about using an efficient wing and engine to fly then we already have that.... So I am a bit confused, perhaps you could draw the line for us, which I assume will be somewhere between da vinci wings (bird motion, muscle power) and a micro light (gliding with engine), as to what the actual question is.
 
  • #11
218
0
Kind of like a combination of da vinci wings and a micro light. Imagine a man flying with the da vinci's wings except it's powered by an engine?
 
  • #12
A.T.
Science Advisor
11,290
2,677
If evolution could create rotors it certainly would?
Difficult. How would you drive a rotor with muscles? You would need a bony crank shaft of something like this.
Are rotors more efficient than wings?
For hovering something of the size of a human, yes. Not for flying a certains distance.
 
  • #13
jtbell
Mentor
15,803
4,034
If one is willing to sacrifice heavy bones and the brain, then maybe one can fly :)

Hence the derogatory term "birdbrain." :biggrin:
 
  • #14
OmCheeto
Gold Member
2,185
2,632
If evolution could create rotors it certainly would?


Is this thread some kind of test?

20.jpg
 
  • #15
803
9
If it doesn't violate the laws of physics (which it doesn't), eventually I'm sure it will be possible. Strength won't be an issue,, as I'm sure that will get augmented either mechanically or biologically.

After that, it's just an issue of getting wings large enough to work. I suppose at least a hang-glider sized apparatus will be necessary...although it will obviosuly be something you need to put on. Not like you'll be walking to the store and just decide to jump in the air and start flying.

Although I suppose I'm thinking "in the box" here, I'm trying to work with what we know...
 
  • #16
117
0
Kind of like a combination of da vinci wings and a micro light. Imagine a man flying with the da vinci's wings except it's powered by an engine?

Oh right, now I see what you mean :-)
I would say it is physically possible like others have said, but I cannot support the view that it 'will happen', as there is no reason for it to… it's kinda like developing a car that uses cheetah legs to travel at 70mph on the motorway, when actually a wheel does a much better job (over smooth terrain)
The only advantage I can see of flapping wings, over gliding wings is the ability to hover, and if you needed that level of control (and I can totally see why you would) I suspect (with fairly high confidence) a rotor based design would be far more efficient.
Maybe there would be somebody out there in the future that fancies spending the time and money developing one, just for the fun of it, but personally I think that is your only hope of ever seeing one.

It is an interesting question however, as we have borrowed designs from nature before with good success, but I think this is one area in which a step backwards (towards rotors) is a step forwards.

A good parallel to this is the propellors used on speed boats, they recently trialed a design based on a fish tail movement (except they had two side by side to keep it balanced)… from memory, I seem to remember that it worked great, very smooth, but I have never seen one on a boat! I asume it had some drawbacks.

Along similar lines rememeber that swim suits that used shark skin technology to glide through the water better? Something about the rough surface trapping air bubbles… I think they got banned from competition use due to the unfair advantage they gave, but not sure if they are OK to use again now.
 
  • #17
803
9
I would say it is physically possible like others have said, but I cannot support the view that it 'will happen', as there is no reason for it to…

This is one of those things that if it can be done, somebody will do it....if for no other reason than to impress the chicks. I mean, hell, I would do it if I could.

In fact, as soon as somebody does it, somebody else will make a version that can carry a passenger (a chick).

Probably half the things we have in this world are for no other reason than to impress the chicks.
 
  • #18
2
0
maybe someday someone that is very good in inventing things, maybe one can invent that and think for an artificial wings for human..
but for now if i think of that it is really hard to do, it is really a matter of long study and discovery..
but we'll see all in the near future.

[spam link deleted]
 
Last edited by a moderator:
  • #19
QuantumPion
Science Advisor
Gold Member
902
42
Big birds don't do a lot of flapping. They glide like hang gliders most of the time. And humans are even much heavier than the biggest flying birds. The idea of humans flying by flapping like a hummingbird is ineffective. Rotors are better.

So...you're telling me instead of flapping my arms what I should be doing is holding my arms out straight and spin around real fast?
 

Related Threads on Do You think That We Can someday Fly like Birds?

  • Last Post
Replies
3
Views
11K
Replies
9
Views
3K
  • Last Post
Replies
11
Views
8K
  • Last Post
Replies
2
Views
2K
  • Last Post
Replies
4
Views
1K
Replies
8
Views
2K
Replies
22
Views
2K
Replies
17
Views
1K
Replies
9
Views
8K
Replies
22
Views
2K
Top