Does anyone know what fish eat if they don't have teeth?

  • Thread starter Thread starter AngelShare
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Teeth
Click For Summary

Discussion Overview

The discussion revolves around the dietary habits of toothless fish, particularly in freshwater environments, and the adaptations of a fictional fish created by a participant. The scope includes theoretical considerations of fish adaptations, ecological roles, and design elements for a school project.

Discussion Character

  • Exploratory
  • Conceptual clarification
  • Homework-related
  • Debate/contested

Main Points Raised

  • One participant questions whether plankton can be found in large lakes and if a toothless fish could consume them.
  • Another participant suggests that small life forms exist in freshwater, although they are uncertain if they are classified as plankton, and posits that small fish could eat these organisms.
  • A different reply mentions that certain fish, like those in the Clupeidae family, have adaptations such as gill rakers to filter plankton from the water, although they may have small teeth.
  • There is a discussion about the relationship between fin size and swimming speed, with suggestions that larger fins may be necessary for stability at higher speeds.
  • One participant asserts that most fish do not have teeth, while others argue that many bony fish possess some form of teeth, with variations in size and location.
  • A participant shares a personal experience regarding feedback from a teacher on a project, expressing frustration over points deducted for not adequately addressing why the fish developed its adaptations and its evolutionary ancestor.
  • Another participant emphasizes that adaptations are typically acquired to fulfill ecological needs rather than due to a lack of predation, suggesting a hypothetical scenario to illustrate this point.

Areas of Agreement / Disagreement

Participants express differing views on the prevalence and function of teeth in fish, the dietary habits of toothless fish, and the reasons behind specific adaptations. The discussion remains unresolved with multiple competing perspectives on these topics.

Contextual Notes

Participants mention various assumptions about fish adaptations, the classification of food sources, and the ecological roles of different fish species, which may not be fully explored or defined.

Who May Find This Useful

Readers interested in fish biology, adaptations, ecological interactions, and project-based learning in biology may find this discussion relevant.

AngelShare
Messages
208
Reaction score
0
Does anyone know what fish eat if they don't have teeth? I drew a fish (As was instructed.) and gave it different adaptations. For example, my fish is dark on the top and light on the bottom- countershading. It's shaped like a torpedo and has small scales which makes it a fast swimmer. However, I don't know if it can lack teeth if it lives in a lake as the list I found online of fish adaptations has such fish eating plankton. Can plankton be found in large lakes and, if so, could a small toothless fish eat them?:confused:

Oh, and another thing...if my fish is a fast swimmer, what would make more sense? It having large fins or small fins?
 
Last edited:
Physics news on Phys.org
These are my guesses, fish are not my specialty.

Small life forms are found in freshwater, although I am not sure whether they are called plankton technically. And I don't see why small fish cannot eat those. At higher speeds a fish would need larger fins for stability. See Wikipedia entry "Fin"
 
Last edited:
AngelShare said:
Does anyone know what fish eat if they don't have teeth? I drew a fish (As was instructed.) and gave it different adaptations. For example, my fish is dark on the top and light on the bottom- countershading. It's shaped like a torpedo and has small scales which makes it a fast swimmer. However, I don't know if it can lack teeth if it lives in a lake as the list I found online of fish adaptations has such fish eating plankton. Can plankton be found in large lakes and, if so, could a small toothless fish eat them?:confused:
Oh, and another thing...if my fish is a fast swimmer, what would make more sense? It having large fins or small fins?
Hey Angleshare,
There are numerous fish that live on freshwater zooplankton. They typically use specialized adaptations on their gills called gill rakers that can strain out the plankton from the water as they swim through it. Some examples I can think of are from the Clupeidae family: Alewife, Alosa pseudoharengus, American Shad, Alosa sapidissima and Atlantic menhaden, Brevoortia tyrannus. These fish may have some teeth (I think they do because some eat small fish and invertebrates as well), but they are not large teeth like one sees on sharks or walleye or barracuda. Which bring me to the next part, speed and fins.
It is somewhat dependent on what "type" of speed you are talking about. Is it a fast ambush predator that only gives bursts of speed, like the barracuda, or does it cruise open waters for longer periods of time chasing prey, like marlin or sailfish? You should be able to find pictures of these fish easily on the web and you can see that these different fish have different fin shapes but roughly similar body shapes. The larger fins of the marlins and sailfins are used for fast, open water maneuvering and catching prey. The barracuda, while it caudal fin is fairly large, is mostly a 'slam in fast and bite" prey hunter, not a chaser and does not need "large" fins for maneuvering.
 
The March '95 isssue of SciAm has a very interesting article on how fish swim so efficiently. If you can't find a paper copy, it's available here http://www.sciamdigital.com/browse.cfm?sequencenameCHAR=item&methodnameCHAR=resource_getitembrowse&interfacenameCHAR=browse.cfm&ISSUEID_CHAR=AC87C917-3259-4C24-A03A-5A5A8327ACA", but you have to pay for it that way.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Most fish don't have teeth (obviously). The ones that do I suspect tend to eat prey that are large in comparison to their own size, so that they can tear the food into bite-sized chunks. Most fish eat food that can be taken into the mouth whole, thus no need for teeth. Small crustaceans, algae, worms, other smaller fish etc.
 
DaveC426913 said:
Most fish don't have teeth (obviously).
I think you'd be surprised how many fish do have teeth, most telosts, or bony fish have some form of tooth (see cichlid article below). Part of that lies in what one views as teeth. I think we can all agree that sharks, piranha, barracuda, etc all have teeth, but there are many fish that have very small teeth, or teeth that are localized to regions other than the ridges of the jaw.
One of the best examples of fish teeth and their variation amoung species and across evolution is found in the cichlid fishes of Africa. Check http://www.biology.gatech.edu/professors/labsites/streelman%20web%20pg/toothed.pdf" which by outward apprearance have a very fleshy soft mouth only to find very obvious pharyngeal teeth located further down the oral cavity/esophagous, cichlids share the trait of pharyngeal teeth as well.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Thanks for the help, everyone.:biggrin:

However, I'm still a bit stuck...I did what I was told...

Draw, build, create a PowerPoint, or other representation to show your new fish species. Include the information you researched above on Fishbase.

Include the following information about your fish:

New name of your fish. (be creative!)
In what habitat your fish would live?
Describe at least two adaptations your fish has to live in the habitat.
Why would your fish have adapted? (competition for food, habitat, or other)


...but my teacher's comment was as follows...

"Why did your fish develop it's adaptations (10 pts)?
What is the name of the fish that yours evolved from (3 pts)"


My fish developed its adaptations because...

"The Mano Estratta, being a small, plankton eating fish in a large lake, needs its torpedo shaped body and small scales for quick getaways as both make it a fast swimmer. Its coloring, being dark on top and light on the bottom, helps to hide it from, not only predators above it but ones beneath it as well. It has a small mouth and no teeth so it eats mainly plankton.

It requires such adaptations as it, unlike larger fish around it, is harmless."


Now he's adding junk. I drew the damn fish, named it, researched fish adaptations on other sites besides the one he provided us with, and threw it all together in PowerPoint and yet he only gave me 27 points out of 40...I need those points.:frown:

His second question is a bit harder for me to answer...I have no clue. Could someone help? http://www.fishbase.org/search.cfm" is the site he gave us to use. I wouldn't know how to go about answering it...
 
Last edited by a moderator:
So he took off 13 pts because you didn't address the issues of why the fish developed the adaptations it did and what fish it evolved from, correct? Is the next part of your post your response to this or was that included in your previously submitted project? Regardless, it needs a little work. The last sentence bothers me. Typically animals don't acquire characteristics because they don't do something (in this case it doesn't prey on other fish), they generally acquire characteristics or traits or adaptations to fulfill a need or fill a niche. Thus, if a species is introduced into a new habitat it will adapt to best fit into that environment. Perhaps a hypothetical example, say a very large lake exists with a normal complement of fish, bottom feeders, large predators, etc., but nothing exists that activiely cruises open water eating zooplankton. A nearby stream overflows and some minnows get dumped in, they normally eat small invertebrates and some larger plankton, but there are already fish in the lake that eat the invertebrates so the minnows eventually evolve traits like you describe to better pursue zooplankton as a food source and at the same time avoid predation by the resident predators. They don't live on the bottom or near structure, so they have to "outswim" their predators, perhaps they also start schooling in large numbers another good way to aviod predation. You need to think about what the adaptations do for the fish, thus the last sentence in the first part reads better as "They eat plankton, thus have small teeth... (plus many plankton eaters have relativley large mouths to collect more food, think about whale sharks or other filter feeders). As far as the ancestor, you need to find a fish that is similar to your fish, but not identical. Use the fish base to search for fish that share some things in common with your like eating plankton or open water, fast swimmers. I think this will help.
 
Aye, it was the answer I provided in my assignment. I knew it wasn't terribly in depth but since his question had the examples "competition for food, habitat, or other" I thought that's what he wanted. Alright, I can do the Fishbase thing, I just got to look around...but the other part might need a bit of work, as you said. Let me see...I should start off by changing my statement a bit...

"The Mano Estratta, being a small, plankton eating fish in a large lake, needs its torpedo shaped body and small scales for quick getaways as both make it a fast swimmer. Its coloring, being dark on top and light on the bottom, helps to hide it from, not only predators above it but ones beneath it as well. It eats mainly plankton thus it having a small mouth and no teeth.

It acquired such adaptations because..."


Now, in your scenario, my fish would be the one that was newly introduced somehow, right? That means my fish would have had to have evolved from a slower fish thus it adapting by becoming faster? In that case...oh no, I can't get that Fish Base link to work. O_o

...Ah, nevermind, it works now. ^_^ Eh, I was going to post the fish I found but it looks like it may take a while...anyways, would it work if I were to say my fish evolved from [insert name here] because it was...does it make sense to say that it was put in the lake for fishing? I think I've heard of people doing that...introducing fish into nearby lakes and such for fishing. Or is that wrong?:redface:
 

Similar threads

  • · Replies 1 ·
Replies
1
Views
3K
Replies
6
Views
2K
Replies
1
Views
4K
  • · Replies 11 ·
Replies
11
Views
3K
  • · Replies 21 ·
Replies
21
Views
3K
  • · Replies 108 ·
4
Replies
108
Views
20K
  • · Replies 6 ·
Replies
6
Views
4K
  • · Replies 1 ·
Replies
1
Views
4K
  • · Replies 2 ·
Replies
2
Views
4K
  • · Replies 4 ·
Replies
4
Views
3K