Does the Spring Continue to Stretch Indefinitely Beyond the Elastic Limit?

3 replies · 4K views · last reply
rollcast
Messages
403
Reaction score
0

Homework Statement


The Attempt at a Solution



Physics apparatus diagram of a spring stretched by hanging 100 g masses over a pulley, with a graph below of length of the spring in mm against mass attached to the spring in g, from 0 to 1000 g.

Marking scheme extract for question 1(a): (i) two marks for the line not passing through the origin or length not doubling with mass; (ii) extension values of 50 mm at 200 g and 25 mm at 100 g; (iii) straight line 600 g to 800 g and upward curve 800 g to 1000 g, marked independently.


Its question 1 A (III) I don't understand.

I have included a copy of the question paper and the mark scheme.

I understand the continuation of the straight line up to 800N however after does the line curve like the blue / red one on my diagram?

I would have thought it should have leveled off at a constant length as after the spring is past the elastic limit it will only stretch so far before it turns into a straight bit of wire?

The mark scheme would suggest that the spring should continue to stretch to infinity as more weights are added?

Thanks
Al
 
Attachments
  • Diagram of a spring hung from a pulley with 100 g masses, above a graph of spring length in mm against mass in g from 0 to 1000 g, with a straight line up to about 800 g and curved red and blue continuations beyond it.
    Capture.PNG
    14.1 KB · Views: 1,779
  • Mark scheme extract for question 1(a) on spring extension: (i) a straight line does not pass through 0,0 or length does not double when mass doubles [1]; (ii) 200 g gives extension 200 - 150 = 50, 100 g gives 25 mm [1]; (iii) straight line from 600 g to 800 g and upward curve from 800 g to 1000 g, independent [1][1], total [2].
    Capture1.PNG
    18.2 KB · Views: 731
Once past the elastic limit the spring may stretch way more than per Hooke's law. And it won't return to it's unstretched length once the weight is removed. You are correct, of course, that at some point the spring may unravel and be nothing but a straight wire. I don't think they intend for the graph to go that far.
 
Doc Al said:
Once past the elastic limit the spring may stretch way more than per Hooke's law. And it won't return to it's unstretched length once the weight is removed. You are correct, of course, that at some point the spring may unravel and be nothing but a straight wire. I don't think they intend for the graph to go that far.

So its the Red curve then?
 
rollcast said:
So its the Red curve then?
Yes, that's what I would say.