Energy of photon never becomes zero

  • Context: Undergrad 
  • Thread starter Thread starter NIKHEL RAINA
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Energy Photon Zero
Click For Summary

Discussion Overview

The discussion revolves around the nature of photons, their energy, and the implications of their behavior in relation to mass and intensity over distance. Participants explore concepts from special relativity, the behavior of light, and how intensity diminishes with distance, questioning the relationship between mass and energy in photons.

Discussion Character

  • Debate/contested
  • Technical explanation
  • Conceptual clarification

Main Points Raised

  • Some participants assert that photons gain energy and mass as they travel, suggesting that light never stops and continuously gains energy.
  • Others clarify that a photon has zero invariant mass and does not gain energy or mass as it travels, emphasizing that its energy is proportional to its frequency.
  • It is noted that the decrease in light intensity with distance is related to the number of photons per unit area rather than the energy of individual photons.
  • Some participants express confusion regarding the concepts of mass and energy in the context of photons and protons, seeking clearer explanations.
  • There is a mention of the Doppler effect, which affects the observed energy of photons but not their speed.
  • One participant questions the relevance of gravitational redshift and blueshift in the context of the discussion, indicating a desire for clarification.
  • Another participant suggests that the understanding of special relativity is flawed in the initial claims about photons.

Areas of Agreement / Disagreement

Participants generally disagree on the nature of mass and energy in photons, with some asserting that photons gain mass and energy, while others maintain that photons are massless and do not change energy as they travel. The discussion remains unresolved with multiple competing views.

Contextual Notes

There are limitations in the understanding of special relativity among some participants, and the discussion reveals confusion regarding the definitions of mass and energy in relation to photons and other particles.

NIKHEL RAINA
Messages
20
Reaction score
0
as we know that light consist packets of energy called photons
And mass of a
body when moving with the speed of light increases so, the mass of photon increases when it moves with light and when mass increases its energy is also increasing it means that when light travels it never stops and continousely gain energy
But in reality intensity of light at certian distance becomes zero...why?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
NIKHEL RAINA said:
as we know that light consist packets of energy called photons
And mass of a
body when moving with the speed of light increases so, the mass of photon increases when it moves with light and when mass increases its energy is also increasing it means that when light travels it never stops and continousely gain energy
But in reality intensity of light at certian distance becomes zero...why?

An object with (rest) mass never moves at the speed of light relative to any inertial observer. It gains energy and speed by forces acting on it. You can treat <total energy>/c^2 as relativistic mass, but this often just leads to confusion (there is only one Newtonian formula you can plug it into and get the right result).

A photon never changes energy or speed relative to an inertial observer. However, its energy (but not speed) are observer dependent due to the Doppler effect.

The decrease in intensity of light with distance is unrelated to photon's energy, it is a function of the number of photons per unit area. If you had a perfectly collimated ideal laser, its intensity would not change with distance. If you have N photons/second emitted in a spherical pattern, then as you double distance you have 1/4 as many photons per unit area.
 
NIKHEL RAINA said:
the mass of photon increases when it moves with light and when mass increases its energy is also increasing it means that when light travels it never stops and continousely gain energy
None of this is correct. A photon has whatever energy it has (proportional to its frequency) and its (invariant) mass is always zero. It does not gain invariant mass nor relativistic mass nor energy as it travels.
 
NIKHEL RAINA said:
as we know that light consist packets of energy called photons
And mass of a
body when moving with the speed of light increases so, the mass of photon increases when it moves with light and when mass increases its energy is also increasing it means that when light travels it never stops and continousely gain energy
But in reality intensity of light at certian distance becomes zero...why?

The mass m of an object is invariant. You seem to refer to the mass M that appears in very old textbooks and in some 'popular' presentations of relativity. In any case that M is only defined for massive particles, not for photons.

A photon is a massless particle m=0. Precisely being massless is the reason that its speed is constant and equals c.
 
PAllen said:
An object with (rest) mass never moves at the speed of light relative to any inertial observer. It gains energy and speed by forces acting on it. You can treat <total energy>/c^2 as relativistic mass, but this often just leads to confusion (there is only one Newtonian formula you can plug it into and get the right result).

A photon never changes energy or speed relative to an inertial observer. However, its energy (but not speed) are observer dependent due to the Doppler effect.

The decrease in intensity of light with distance is unrelated to photon's energy, it is a function of the number of photons per unit area. If you had a perfectly collimated ideal laser, its intensity would not change with distance. If you have N photons/second emitted in a spherical pattern, then as you double distance you have 1/4 as many photons per unit area.

Dear it may be due to my little knowledge but if u try to explain more pricisely step wise that how mass of moving proton not increase so i am able to understood
E-mc"
 
I would say that if the mass of the proton is equal to zero and you follow the basic rules of multiplication the answer is there. However i believe you ask the question under the assumption that the photon must have mass. E is equal to the mass times the speed of light squared would also mean that the photon has no energy to work backwards. I may be completely wrong and probably am
 
NIKHEL RAINA said:
Dear it may be due to my little knowledge but if u try to explain more pricisely step wise that how mass of moving proton not increase so i am able to understood
E-mc"

Do you mean proton or photon? I'll answer both:

1) If a proton is accelerated, its energy increases. You can choose to consider this (increasing) E/c^2 as increasing relativistic mass - but this leads to confusion because you can't use in place of mass most formulas of Newtonian mechanics. Thus, my preference is just to see it as increasing energy, while rest mass remains constant.

2) A photon cannot be accelerated and cannot change energy relative to a given inertial observer. Different inertial observers can see a given photon having different energies. It is very misleading to view a photons 'relativistic mass' as E/c^2 - you will almost always be led to wrong conclusions doing this.

3) I explained already how light intensity decreasing with distance is related only to number of photons per unit area.
 
PAllen said:
A photon never changes energy or speed relative to an inertial observer. However, its energy (but not speed) are observer dependent due to the Doppler effect.
Could you explain your statement wrt gravitational red- and blueshift?
 
Passionflower said:
Could you explain your statement wrt gravitational red- and blueshift?

The context was pure SR. I saw no need to add confusion; there was enough already.
 
  • #10
PAllen said:
Do you mean proton or photon? I'll answer both:

1) If a proton is accelerated, its energy increases. You can choose to consider this (increasing) E/c^2 as increasing relativistic mass - but this leads to confusion because you can't use in place of mass most formulas of Newtonian mechanics. Thus, my preference is just to see it as increasing energy, while rest mass remains constant.

2) A photon cannot be accelerated and cannot change energy relative to a given inertial observer. Different inertial observers can see a given photon having different energies. It is very misleading to view a photons 'relativistic mass' as E/c^2 - you will almost always be led to wrong conclusions doing this.

3) I explained already how light intensity decreasing with distance is related only to number of photons per unit area.
Sorry for confusing u i wrote proton instead of photon
 
  • #11
NIKHEL RAINA said:
as we know that light consist packets of energy called photons
And mass of a
body when moving with the speed of light increases so, the mass of photon increases when it moves with light and when mass increases its energy is also increasing it means that when light travels it never stops and continousely gain energy
But in reality intensity of light at certian distance becomes zero...why?

You have a very faulty understanding of Special Relativity. Please read the FAQ subforums, both in the General Physics forum and the Relativity forum.

Zz.
 

Similar threads

  • · Replies 26 ·
Replies
26
Views
2K
  • · Replies 1 ·
Replies
1
Views
1K
  • · Replies 23 ·
Replies
23
Views
3K
  • · Replies 8 ·
Replies
8
Views
2K
  • · Replies 4 ·
Replies
4
Views
1K
  • · Replies 6 ·
Replies
6
Views
2K
  • · Replies 10 ·
Replies
10
Views
2K
  • · Replies 51 ·
2
Replies
51
Views
5K
  • · Replies 7 ·
Replies
7
Views
2K
  • · Replies 130 ·
5
Replies
130
Views
16K