Ester to acid chloride transformation

  • Topic: Chemistry 
  • Thread starter jolly_math
  • Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Organic chemistry
4 replies · 4K views · last reply
jolly_math
Messages
51
Reaction score
5
Homework Statement
Which best accomplishes the following transformation?
Relevant Equations
ester to acid chloride
Reaction scheme: methyl 3-hydroxycyclopentane-1-carboxylate, with a free OH on the ring, converted by a question-mark arrow to 3-hydroxycyclopentane-1-carbonyl chloride, an acid chloride with a Cl on the carbonyl.


Here are 2 options:
A)
Numbered list of four reagents: 1) R3SiCl, base; 2) NaOH, H2O; 3) SOCl2; 4) Bu4NF.
B)
Numbered list of four reagent steps: 1) R3SiCl, base; 2) H3O+, heat; 3) SOCl2; 4) HF, H2O.


For both syntheses, a protecting group is added to the alcohol, the ester is hydrolyzed to a carboxylic acid, then it is turned into an acid chloride using SOCl2. The difference is that A is base-catalyzed and B is acid-catalyzed.

The correct answer is A, but I don't understand why B doesn't work or is worse than A.

Thank you.
 
Eons passed since I worked with these things, but quick googling for stability of silyl ethers seems to be suggesting it is pH dependent.
 
Borek said:
Eons passed since I worked with these things, but quick googling for stability of silyl ethers seems to be suggesting it is pH dependent.
I've never seen this in my textbook or the resources I've used so far though. Is this a commonly-known fact?
 
Even wiki states: "Reaction with acids (...) removes the silyl group when protection is no longer needed.", so my bet is yes, it is something quite well known.