Estimating partition function from a graph of Boltzmann factors

1 reply · 1K views · last reply
LCSphysicist
Messages
644
Reaction score
163
Homework Statement
All below.
Relevant Equations
All below
Bar chart of probability P(s) against energy E(s), with bar heights decreasing roughly exponentially as energy rises; a smooth curve follows the bar tops. Energy axis ticks at kT, 2kT and 3kT.

I am not sure, but since the partition function Z is just the sum of all Boltzmann Factor
Equation for the partition function: Z equals the sum over states s of exp(-E(s)/kT), written as Z = Σ_s e^(-E(s)/kT).

We can just add:
Calculator history line showing the sum e^-0.7 + e^-1.3 + e^-1.4 + e^-1.9 + e^2.3 + e^2.5 + e^3.4 with the answer 2.987530452009326.

(some terms don't appear in the image, by the way, the estimative is nice, the result is above ANS)

But i didn't understand what the author did:
Printed text reading Problem 6.4: the ground state has energy 0 so e^0 = 1 in the partition function; nine gray bars total 13.0 cm, first bar 4.4 cm, so Z ≈ 3 and P(ground) ≈ 1/3.


While i didn't even care about the image of the functions (P(s), what he call by height), his resolution is based on it, not only, he talk nothing about the estimative of the exponents (the values on the abscissa), while my resolution is based on it.

What method he used?? Do you understand?
 
Attachments
  • Printed text of Problem 6.4 explaining that the ground state has energy 0, so Z is about 3 and the ground-state probability is about 1/3, using measured bar heights of 13.0 cm total and 4.4 cm for the first bar.
    1596797270517.png
    22.7 KB · Views: 189
I was confused at first because the first two terms of your sum are missing. What I see starts at ##+e^{-0.7}##.
The author is doing the same as you, but instead of measuring the x coordinates off the graph and computing each y coordinate, he is measuring the y values directly. This gives him cm rather than the actual Boltzmann factor, but he is only interested in ratios of values since it is going to be normalized to a total of 1 anyway.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: LCSphysicist