Europeans and Small Talk or Lack Thereof

  • Thread starter Thread starter eNtRopY
  • Start date Start date
Click For Summary

Discussion Overview

The discussion revolves around cultural differences in small talk between Europeans and Americans, exploring perceptions of communication styles, social norms, and personal experiences. Participants share anecdotes and opinions on the nature of conversations during social gatherings, particularly in dining settings.

Discussion Character

  • Debate/contested
  • Exploratory
  • Conceptual clarification

Main Points Raised

  • Some participants express frustration with the perceived lack of small talk among Europeans, describing it as "creepy" and uncomfortable.
  • Others suggest that cultural differences may influence communication styles, with some Europeans preferring silence over small talk.
  • A few participants argue that the English may not fit the stereotype of being quiet, noting that small talk is more common among them compared to Germans or Scandinavians.
  • Some contributions highlight that silence can indicate comfort in a relationship, referencing a scene from "Pulp Fiction" to illustrate this point.
  • There are mentions of personal experiences with Finnish individuals, with some participants humorously acknowledging stereotypes about Finns being quiet or boring.
  • Participants also discuss the idea that Americans may engage in more small talk due to cultural norms, while Europeans might prioritize different conversational topics or enjoy silence.
  • One participant expresses a preference for meaningful conversations over what they perceive as "spam" in online discussions, contrasting this with their experiences of silence in social settings.

Areas of Agreement / Disagreement

Participants do not reach a consensus on the nature of small talk across cultures. While some agree that cultural differences exist, others challenge the notion that Europeans lack conversational skills, leading to a variety of perspectives on the topic.

Contextual Notes

Limitations include varying definitions of small talk and cultural norms, as well as personal biases influencing perceptions of communication styles. The discussion reflects a mix of humor and serious commentary, with no clear resolution on the topic.

Who May Find This Useful

Individuals interested in cultural studies, communication styles, or social interactions across different societies may find this discussion relevant.

  • #31
The funny thing actually is, that I won't reply with the question how they are doing, but I will still get the 'good' from them, telling you what kind of a reflex it is.

In Europe people will great you with a hi, or hello to acknowledge you while a how are you is associated with a conversation. So I guess this is an example of a culture shock which is translated into rudeness for the observator.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #32
Saying what the way someone converses irritates you, is like me saying that the way you sip your tea irritates me
 
  • #33
The thing that irritates me is the lack of interest. How are you doing? Good. Good. It's crazy. It happened once in the museum, someone walks up to another and it was clear they hadn't seen each other in a long time: HI! How are you doing? Good, how about you? Good, yes, good. Good. And they went their separate ways. What to do in a museum, you have a press conference to attent? Your quarterly presentation is on in two minutes? It shockes me. But again, other culture other standars, other customs. If they are fine with it, that is their thing. If you don't like it, find another place that suits you, so that is exactly what I will be doing. Problem solved.

And Entropy, I DO have to give you the fact that Americans, especially girls can have the tendency to talk A LOT on and on and on, rattle rattle. So much so that my fellow non-american collegues have the hardest time understanding what they are saying, causing much confusion and thus entertainment. Of the american girls I know.. 90% talk that way, but then, I don't know too many of them.
 
  • #34
Originally posted by Monique
Funny comment for a person that doesn't believe in stereotypes hmm, Entropy?

I guess that the person was just intimidated by having an american sitting across.. maybe he/she doesn't speak english?? People can be shy in speaking a foreign language you know. So now that problem is solved..

It is very strange that you are assuming I am referring to only one incident. Furthermore, it is strange that assume I only speak English.

Anyway, what I am talking about is all the occasions in which I went to lunch or dinner with groups of Europeans and observed frequent episodes of long awkward silence.

Also, I have been meeting with a Finnish girl for the last month for social purposes, and I have been somewhat creeped out by her silent manner. I mean, in America, if I meet a girl for drinks, and she contributes little to the conversation, then I can safely assume that she has no interest in me and move on. Yet, this girl continues to call me which clearly indicates that she does not completely distest my company. The situation confuses me, but I have recently read a few articles on the silent nature of Finnish people -- including one entitled the Silence of the Finns. So, I am beginning to accept the fact that it is her... not me. Not that this is a bad thing. I remember when I was in America, I always complained about how pointless small talk is. However, like I said, when you're sitting across from someone who is just sitting there existing, you start to feel like something is terribly wrong... at least if you're an American anyway.

eNtRopY
 
  • #35
[After a long pause in their conversation]
Mia Wallace: Don't you hate that?
Vincent Vega: Hate what?
Mia Wallace: Uncomfortable silences.

Mia: Why do we feel it's necessary to yak about bull**** in order to become comfortable?

This is the cmdr was getting at, apparently Americans feel the need to yak about bull****, whereas most europeans don't feel the need to ruin a good meal by talking and letting it get cold.
 
  • #36
Originally posted by Monique
The thing that irritates me is the lack of interest. How are you doing? Good. Good. It's crazy. It happened once in the museum, someone walks up to another and it was clear they hadn't seen each other in a long time: HI! How are you doing? Good, how about you? Good, yes, good. Good. And they went their separate ways. What to do in a museum, you have a press conference to attent? Your quarterly presentation is on in two minutes? It shockes me. But again, other culture other standars, other customs. If they are fine with it, that is their thing. If you don't like it, find another place that suits you, so that is exactly what I will be doing. Problem solved.

The real problem is that you just don't understand the meaning behind the words.

When I am in the states, every morning I walk into my school and see my fellow collegues, I always say, hey, how's it going? Usually they answer back with good to which I reply that's great, and then I simply carry on with my day.

Where exactly is the problem?

I am being courteous in that I am acknowledging the existence of people I know, and I am being polite enough to make sure that they are not having any problems. When an American asks someone How's it going?, What's up?, or How are you doing?, what he/she means is Are you still okay? I will assume so unless you tell me otherwise. It's not that we are insincere. We're actually quite sincere, but at the same time we are realistic. If someone is willing to offer a piece of personal information about themselves then, I believe, most Americans will respect that.

Here is a good example. One day I saw an acquaintence and naturally said, Hi, how's it going? She replied with Bad. I just found out I won't be able to declare the biochemistry major. She was quite upset; so, I took a moment to comfort her. Obviously, I didn't have to stay there and listen to her problems, but I think that any American would consider a blantant display of insincerity to be quite rude.

eNtRopY
 
  • #37
But do you not find that when someone does say that they are feling bad you are surprised by there answer. Normally when i ask someone how are they feeling i don't expect them to come back at me with "no I am not my dog died this morning after running it over whilst failing my driving test". You just don't expect that, because people tend not too let others know how they feel unless they are good friends with that person.
 
  • #38
Originally posted by Andy
[After a long pause in their conversation]
Mia Wallace: Don't you hate that?
Vincent Vega: Hate what?
Mia Wallace: Uncomfortable silences.

Mia: Why do we feel it's necessary to yak about bull**** in order to become comfortable?

This is the cmdr was getting at, apparently Americans feel the need to yak about bull****, whereas most europeans don't feel the need to ruin a good meal by talking and letting it get cold.

Yes, I know the reference. I saw the movie a million times before you were even born.

The situation I have previously described involved just me, a European girl, two glasses, and a bottle of red wine. There was no meal. Like I've already said, it's easy to talk about cutting the crap, but when you actually experience a long uncomfortable silence, that's another story.

So, perhaps Americans like to have some constant form of communication with each other just to know that the other person is still paying attention. Perhaps, the situation is similar to the telecommunications concept of handshaking. I think that Americans value good conversation, but when there are periods of silence, they don't want to loose that data channel. I'm not entirely sure.

Here's my question for you Europeans who are obviously above relating to another human being...

If I wanted to go to a bar and drink wine in silence, then why would I bother to do that with another human being? Am I not capable of not talking to someone all by myself?

eNtRopY
 
  • #39
Originally posted by Andy
But do you not find that when someone does say that they are feling bad you are surprised by there answer. Normally when i ask someone how are they feeling i don't expect them to come back at me with "no I am not my dog died this morning after running it over whilst failing my driving test". You just don't expect that, because people tend not too let others know how they feel unless they are good friends with that person.

No. Like I said, if someone tells me that he/she is truely not okay then I will take the time to do what I can to make that person feel better. I don't care how well I know (or do not know) that person, if someone confides in me with his/her personal feelings, I will show that person respect out of courtesy. And, I don't think that I am the only American who feels this way. Granted, I think most Americans would be shocked if someone they hardly knew made him/herself emotionally vulnerable by telling of his/her true problems, but I also think that most Americans would not be so disrespectful as to openly show disinterest in the other person's situation.

eNtRopY
 
  • #40
Originally posted by eNtRopY
The real problem is that you just don't understand the meaning behind the words.

When I am in the states, every morning I walk into my school and see my fellow collegues, I always say, hey, how's it going? Usually they answer back with good to which I reply that's great, and then I simply carry on with my day.

Where exactly is the problem?

I am being courteous in that I am acknowledging the existence of people I know, and I am being polite enough to make sure that they are not having any problems. When an American asks someone How's it going?, What's up?, or How are you doing?, what he/she means is Are you still okay? I will assume so unless you tell me otherwise. It's not that we are insincere. We're actually quite sincere, but at the same time we are realistic. If someone is willing to offer a piece of personal information about themselves then, I believe, most Americans will respect that.

Here is a good example. One day I saw an acquaintence and naturally said, Hi, how's it going? She replied with Bad. I just found out I won't be able to declare the biochemistry major. She was quite upset; so, I took a moment to comfort her. Obviously, I didn't have to stay there and listen to her problems, but I think that any American would consider a blantant display of insincerity to be quite rude.

eNtRopY

That is what I mean by cultural differences, I expect a different approach to a greeting. I actually had a lot of problems with that expression upon coming to the States, where people would just throw around that expression of 'how are you doing'. I still don't really know whether I should inquire to the cashier how they are doing if they ask me, while I am paying the bill.

Gererally in the Netherlands I feel that there is the following rule: the person who asks how another person is doing initiates a conversation and should make further inquiries on the affairs of the other person. The weather, work, the train that was late again. Otherwise you say goodmorning or just hoi, leaving it up to the other person to make an inquiry. Other nationalities might find that rude, so to quote the great thinker: it is all relative and it depends on the frame of the observer :)

So what I meant here is: you shouldn't HAVE to make yourself vulnerable by answering the question of how are you doing by saying not good. If the other person asks small talk first, the real state of mind will be revealed.

And Entropy, I regard myself as a very quite person, I can listen to a person with great attention and might not say much but be very interested. I don't feel that silences are awkward.. depending on the person who I am with ofcourse. But I have always felt that that is a very atypical dutch characteristic, where dutch people are very lifely and talk with much vigor. People here in the States have characterised me as having an Asian character, because of my gentle nature.

So what I am saying is: I don't think that dutch people would fall in your category of boring talkers (me neither by the way, depending on the situation).
 
Last edited:

Similar threads

PF Fan Fiction: Mathematicians in Love
  • · Replies 2 ·
Replies
2
Views
4K