Find tension in string between two blocks on horizontal surface

4 replies · 2K views · last reply
I_Try_Math
Messages
119
Reaction score
25
Homework Statement
Two blocks connected by a string are pulled across a horizontal surface by a force applied to one of the blocks, as shown below. The coefficient of kinetic friction between the blocks and the surface is 0.25. If each block has an acceleration of 2 m/s^2 to the right, what is the magnitude F of the applied force?
Relevant Equations
F = ma
Physics diagram of two blocks on a horizontal surface: a 1.0 kg block joined by a string to a 3.0 kg block, which is pulled by force F at 60 degrees above the horizontal.

Handwritten work on a dark grid background in green chalk: a free-body diagram with normal force N up, mg down and a force F at 60 degrees, then net force equations in the horizontal with F_x minus f = ma and mu_k N, leading to F_x = 17.8 N, cos 60 = 17.8 / |F|, and boxed answer |F| = 35.6 N.

Did I draw the free body diagram incorrectly by treating the two blocks as one system? My textbook claims the answer is 25 N.
 
Your mistake is not exactly that you treat as one system but that you calculate the total normal force as equal to the total weight of the two bodies. Think again.

Hint : Each box has different normal force on it, in one it is equal to its weight but on the other it is NOT!!!
 
  • Like
  • Informative
Likes   Reactions: I_Try_Math and Orodruin
Delta2 said:
Your mistake is not exactly that you treat as one system but that you calculate the total normal force as equal to the total weight of the two bodies. Think again.

Hint : Each box has different normal force on it, in one it is equal to its weight but on the other it is NOT!!!
If I understand correctly, the magnitude of the larger block's normal force will be different than its weight which will change the friction calculation. Thank you very much for your help on this question, I'll redo the problem soon.
 
I_Try_Math said:
the magnitude of the larger block's normal force will be different than its weight which will change the friction calculation.
That's true, but for the purpose of answering the question in post #1 you can treat the two blocks as a unit. You just have to get the total normal force right.
Answering the question in the thread title is a different matter.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: Delta2 and I_Try_Math
I_Try_Math said:
If I understand correctly, the magnitude of the larger block's normal force will be different than its weight which will change the friction calculation. Thank you very much for your help on this question, I'll redo the problem soon.
Yes. With a force of ##25N## at that angle, you might imagine that the first block is almost being pulled off the ground. It's a strange angle for the problem setter to choose.
 
Last edited: