Discussion Overview
The discussion revolves around calculating the molecular mass of a diprotic weak acid (H2A) based on a titration with a monoprotic strong base (NaOH). Participants explore the stoichiometric relationships involved in the neutralization process and the implications of using a weak acid in the titration.
Discussion Character
- Homework-related
- Mathematical reasoning
- Debate/contested
Main Points Raised
- One participant calculates the molarity of H2A and derives a molecular mass of 234.375 g/mol, but expresses uncertainty about the result.
- Another participant questions the placement of the stoichiometric coefficient (2) in the equation 2CaVa = CbVb, suggesting it may not be correct.
- A different participant explains that the coefficient reflects the number of moles of H+ ions, reinforcing the use of 2 in the equation based on the balanced reaction H2A + 2 NaOH.
- One participant attempts the calculation again, arriving at a different molecular mass of 58.59 g/mol, and raises a concern about the expected volume of strong base needed to neutralize a weak acid.
- Another participant clarifies that the strength of the acid does not affect the stoichiometric amount of base required for neutralization.
- One participant confirms their reliance on the first calculation and asserts that the moles calculated represent the entire 1.5 g sample of H2A.
- A question is posed about whether the titration was performed on the entire 100 mL aliquot, indicating a potential misunderstanding of the experimental setup.
Areas of Agreement / Disagreement
Participants express differing views on the correct application of stoichiometry in the titration calculations, with no consensus reached on the correct molecular mass of H2A or the implications of the acid's strength on the titration process.
Contextual Notes
Participants discuss the stoichiometric coefficients and their relevance to the calculations, but there is uncertainty regarding the implications of the weak acid's behavior in the titration and whether the calculations reflect the entire sample accurately.