Finding closest point on surface x²y²z = 4 to origin

3 replies · 3K views · last reply
theWapiti
Messages
14
Reaction score
1

Homework Statement



Find the first-octant point P(x,y,z) on the surface closest to the given fixed point Q (0,0,0).
The surface x2y2z=4

Homework Equations



Equation d = square root of (x² + y² + (4/(x²y²))²), giving the distance from a point on the surface x²y²z = 4 to the origin, written as LaTeX-style typeset math.
is the distance along PQ.

EDIT:

Handwritten-style equation: D = x^2 + y^2 + (4/(x^2 y^2))^2 = x^2 + y^2 + 16/(x^4 y^4), the squared distance expression with z eliminated.


The Attempt at a Solution



Equation z = 4 / (x^2 y^2) typeset in LaTeX-style math.


Handwritten calculus working: partial derivative of D with respect to x equals 2x + 64/(x^5 y^4) = 0, leading to x = 2/y^(4/6).


I get stuck here every time. I feel like I'm just selling myself short here, but I don't know how to resolve the situation for when the critical point has a variable in it.
 
Last edited:
theWapiti said:

Homework Statement



Find the first-octant point P(x,y,z) on the surface closest to the given fixed point Q (0,0,0).
The surface x2y2z=4

Homework Equations



Equation d = square root of (x^2 + y^2 + (4/(x^2 y^2))^2), giving distance from the origin to the surface x^2 y^2 z = 4 in plane form.
is the distance along PQ.

The Attempt at a Solution



Equation z = 4 / (x^2 y^2), typeset as a displayed formula.


Handwritten derivation: partial D over partial x = 2x + 64/(x^5 y^4) = 0, which gives x = 2/y^(4/6).


I get stuck here every time. I feel like I'm just selling myself short here, but I don't know how to resolve the situation for when the critical point has a variable in it.

Your derivative is incorrect. Try again, more slowly this time.

When you've done that, then take the partial with respect to y (this should be easy because the problem is symmetric, so you just need to swap the x and y variables in your partial with respect to x) and set that equal to 0 as well. You then have two equations in two unknowns.
 
Mentallic said:
Your derivative is incorrect. Try again, more slowly this time.

When you've done that, then take the partial with respect to y (this should be easy because the problem is symmetric, so you just need to swap the x and y variables in your partial with respect to x) and set that equal to 0 as well. You then have two equations in two unknowns.

I feel like I'm probably just making myself problems here, but I can't for the life of me get past this still.

I was minimizing for the distance squared, which gave the two partials. But how can I solve if I have y in terms of x and x in terms of y?!
 
Well I feel like a dummy. Got it now, obviously. Sometimes the problem is made so much more difficult in your own mind!