Finding My Calculation Error: Where Did I Go Wrong?

  • Thread starter Thread starter hidemi
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Calculation Error
AI Thread Summary
The discussion centers on a calculation error regarding the ranking of the integral of the magnetic field, ∫B.ds, in the context of a capacitor's electric field. The original poster mistakenly ranked the values of B instead of focusing on the integral as specified in the question. It was clarified that the displacement current, I_D, should be used rather than the actual current, as no physical current crosses the capacitor gap. The correct ranking for the magnitude of ∫B.ds was determined to be 1<2<3=4, highlighting that the original answers provided were incorrect. Understanding the role of displacement current is crucial for accurately addressing the problem.
hidemi
Messages
206
Reaction score
36
Homework Statement
The diagram shows one plate of a parallel-plate capacitor from whin the capacitor. The plate is circular and has radius R. The dashed circles are four integration paths and radii of r1=R/4, r2=R/2, r3=3R/2, and r4=2R. Rank the paths according to the magnitude of ∫B.ds
around the paths during the discharging of the capacitor, least to greatest.

A) 1, 2 and 3 tie, then 4
B) 1,2,3,4
C) 1, then 2 and 4 tie, then 3
D) 4,3,1,2

the answer is C

E) all tie
Relevant Equations
B = μ0*I / 2πr
My calculation is as attached. Where am I wrong?
 

Attachments

  • 1614869296931.png
    1614869296931.png
    3.2 KB · Views: 184
  • 1.jpg
    1.jpg
    16.1 KB · Views: 197
Physics news on Phys.org
I agree with your results for B. So, it looks like (C) would be the correct answer if the question asked for the ranking of B on each path, rather than asking for the ranking of ∫Bds. None of the answers appear to be correct for the ranking of ∫Bds.

[Edit: For the ranking of ∫Bds, you can argue that one of the answers is correct if you take into account the fringing of the E field of the capacitor.]
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Likes Delta2 and hidemi
hidemi said:
... Rank the paths according to the magnitude of ∫B.ds
.
My calculation is as attached. Where am I wrong?
From your working it looks like you have tried to rank the different values of B. But the question specifically says “Rank ... according to the magnitude of ∫B.ds”. You answered the wrong question!

The question is about displacement current. So ideally you shouldn’t use ##I##. Use (for example) ##I_D##.

(Explanatory note follows, if needed:

Inside of the capacitor is a dielectric (vacuum, or air, or some other insulator). This mean no physical current (moving charge) actually crosses the gap between the plates.

The changing electric flux inside the capacitor generates a magnetic field. ##I_D## is a ‘fictitious’ current which would create the same magnetic field as the changing electric flux. So, when finding the magnetic field, we can ‘pretend’ ##I_D## is actually flowing between the plates like a real current.)

Since the electric field is uniform, ##I_D##’s distribution is the same as a uniform current through a cylindrical conductor radius R. The current, ##I_r##, through an ‘inner cylinder’ (r≤R) is ##I_D \frac {r^2}{R^2}## because it is proportional to cross-sectional area.

The current, ##I_r##, through an ‘outer cylinder’ (r>R) is , ##I_r=I_D##, because it is the total current.

Ampere’s law tell us ##\int B.ds = \mu_0 I_r##. So we are simply being asked to rank the values of ##\mu_0 I_r## for different value of r.

Once that’s fully understood, no calculations at all are needed to answer the question! What do you think the answer should be?

Unfortunately (as already noted by @TSny) the correct answer is not on the answer-list.
 
  • Like
Likes TSny, Delta2 and hidemi
Thank you so much.
 
TSny said:
I agree with your results for B. So, it looks like (C) would be the correct answer if the question asked for the ranking of B on each path, rather than asking for the ranking of ∫Bds. None of the answers appear to be correct for the ranking of ∫Bds.

[Edit: For the ranking of ∫Bds, you can argue that one of the answers is correct if you take into account the fringing of the E field of the capacitor.]
Thank so much.
 
The correct answer for the ranking of the magnitude (absolute value) of ##\int \mathbf{B}\cdot d\mathbf{s}## (and not for the ranking of B as your work is) is 1<2<3=4.
 
  • Like
Likes hidemi
Delta2 said:
The correct answer for the ranking of the magnitude (absolute value) of ##\int \mathbf{B}\cdot d\mathbf{s}## (and not for the ranking of B as your work is) is 1<2<3=4.
Yes I agree with you, thanks for commenting!
 
  • Like
Likes Delta2
Back
Top