Discussion Overview
The discussion revolves around a geography challenge initiated by a participant named Janitor, who shares digital pictures taken during a trip and invites others to guess their locations. The scope includes geographical identification and exploration of various sites, primarily within the western part of the lower 48 United States.
Discussion Character
- Exploratory
- Debate/contested
- Conceptual clarification
Main Points Raised
- Janitor mentions the possibility of the pictures being taken anywhere in the world but suggests they are likely from accessible locations in the western U.S.
- Participants express curiosity and anticipation about the images and their locations.
- Some participants propose specific locations, such as the "Lost Turnpike of Pennsylvania" and the Grand Canyon, but these guesses are met with corrections or further questions.
- There is discussion about the technical difficulties Janitor faces with image uploading, including size limitations.
- Janitor describes a photograph taken from behind a safety rail and mentions a dusty area with looser soil, suggesting it may be difficult for others to guess the location accurately.
- Participants speculate about the nature of the locations, with some suggesting volcanic craters and others discussing the geological features visible in the images.
- Janitor confirms that one of the locations is the Thiokol plant in northern Utah, which is associated with the Space Shuttle's boosters.
- There is a mention of historical significance related to one of the locations, hinting at connections to American history.
- Participants discuss the presence of hazardous materials observed during Janitor's trip, raising questions about their uses and implications.
Areas of Agreement / Disagreement
Participants do not reach a consensus on the locations of the images, with multiple competing guesses and ongoing uncertainty about the correct answers. Some participants express confidence in their guesses, while others remain unsure or correct earlier claims.
Contextual Notes
There are unresolved technical issues regarding image uploads, and participants rely on descriptions rather than visual confirmation. The discussion includes various assumptions about geographical features and historical contexts that remain unverified.